4 ms·
The 'very artificial correction' flap looks like much ado about nothing to me
- Kliment 17y agoExcellent analysis. And seriously, would someone trying to hide something document it this carefully?
- gaius 17y agoWell, sure. He wasn't trying to hide it from his colleagues; they were all in on it.
- olefoo 17y agoAnd those glaciers aren't shrinking, that's just the camera angles.
- gaius 17y agoNo-one's denying that the glacier's are shrinking. But if they've grown and shrunk naturally throughout history, that puts a markedly different spin on things. Same with the temperatures. The temperature went up a bit, then the "un-tricked" numbers show that it went down a bit. What does that tell you?
- henrikschroder 17y agoThree can keep a secret if two are dead. The biggest counter-argument to any sort of conspiracy is that it's really hard to keep a secret, so what would motivate such an effort? How would all potential whistleblowers be kept silent? What would these people gain from perpetuating a global warming scare? It really doesn't add up.
- gaius 17y agoAs evidenced by the fact that we're all poring over his code :-)
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI hate to weigh in on this but two things come to mind: 1) There's a really long way from groupthink to accusations of something like faking the moon landing. I don't even think the word "conspiracy" is apt, although I agree that, according to the way it looks, "they were in on it". There are legion of examples of large organizations or movements colluding to control the message on some issue or another. It's a very common thing. Just throwing out "conspiracies are difficult" as a refutation isn't going to cut it in this particular case. 2) Science is especially vulnerable to groupthink and there is a great tendency for everybody to move in a herd, as Thomas Kuhn pointed out in what was probably one of the topten scientific books of the 20th Century. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Samuel_Kuhn http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Samuel_Kuhn - that doesn't mean that science is broken, or even that the larger issue of AGW is settled one way or another. Most likely what is happening is that nobody knows what climate is doing, yet simple allusions to black-body radiation and greenhouse gases has driven climate scientists to a point where the politics are way ahead of the science. That just means they need to be extremely prudent with their data and methods, and check all assumptions. Also, John's analysis is much ado about nothing, in my opinion. You can take a random piece of code off the source control system -- they were using a SCM, right? -- and make it say all kinds of things. Unless you run the data you're not even sure if you're looking at the right code. Might as well be reading poetry. Sorry John, as much as I love the hacker angle here, you're not going to get very far in a discussion about code if you can't run it. In technical terms it's nonsense -- it has no meaning.
- gaius 17y agoSince I don't have the datasets that underlie this code I can't actually execute it That's the point. No-one can. Let me tell you, if a bank "lost" their trading data, or a drug company "lost" their clinical trials data, or an engineering firm "lost" the data they verified their avionics with, there would be hell to pay. Why's everyone giving these bozos, whose model materially affects all our lives, a free ride?
- KirinDave 17y agoBecause there is a lot of corroborating data and physical evidence to back up what they're saying? No one is giving these folks a free ride. Heck, the article you just quoted from steps into the code in detail to see what this "very artificial" adjustment does. We take for granted now that no data should ever be thrown away, but even as early as 5 years ago that simply wasn't economically feasible. Heck, even scientific institutions with data of extreme historical significance like NASA has lost key data (first moonwalk raw video) because of cost-cutting measures and bureaucratic SNAFUs. By the way, the way in which their model is materially affecting our lives is overall positive even if you don't believe in anthropogenic global warming. We have lots of reasons as a post-industrial nation to want to remove our dependence on foreign oil (and other foreign fuel sources which we have failed to stockpile, such as uranium). What's more, we can make a killing in the market if we can design low-overhead renewable energy systems for the rest of the world. So consider that you may disagree with the map but agree on the direction we're going.
- gaius 17y agoSo consider that you may disagree with the map but agree on the direction we're going. The Green camp themselves ought to be up in arms over this - they ought to have no fear of their data being scrutinized. That's what science is. Before admitting to "losing" the data, the CRU tried all sorts of excuses to evade their obligations under Freedom of Information - and now we only have their word that the data was lost when they said it was. Science or superstition, those are the only choices here.
- 17y ago
- gort 17y agoInteresting that the paper in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, which discusses "the decline", has amongst its authors Jones and Briffa, two names I've seen associated with the alleged "hiding" of the decline.