6 ms·
Ten Days of Silence
- futuravenir 11y agoVipassana is an absolutely wonderful experience. A 'brain washing' where it can rid your mind of all the crud that has accumulated from our culture and society. It puts you in touch with your body in a way that nothing my life ever has. I'd be happy to answer some questions if anybody has any.
- Neurocynic 11y agoSame here. It was difficult at first but became a very beautiful experience.
- futuravenir 11y agoPersonally, I found it easy. I live mostly in my head anyhow, so not talking wasn't a big deal to me. And before I went into it, I told myself that solitary confinement would be much worse and that this is a vacation where I get fed and just have to be quiet and try something new. Also, it was recommended by someone I respect very highly, so I was convinced it was worthwhile before ever going.
- Neurocynic 11y agoIt was difficult the first 5 days and then suddenly something clicked. It was all sunshine after that :)
- BlackJack 11y agoI've signed up for a 10-day course in mid August and am stoked about what I'll gain and also about the sheer difficulty. Could you talk more about the long-term effects of Vipassana on your body/life?
- futuravenir 11y agoI did it first in 2011. I've only done one session. I've tried to go back a few times but have created barriers in myself to doing so. It will do me more to go back to Vipassana than any single thing I can do for myself. It puts you at the center and you just follow along, being true. As far as long-term effects, I came out of the experience glowing. Heat didn't bother me. I saw clearly. The afterglow lasted for about three months. Slowly, I became a little bit agitated by things that didn't bother me during the period of afterglow. If I had continued to meditate regularly, I would have been fine. Centered. Since I didn't...Because I made excuses for myself...I'm in a not so great state these days. And yet, if I found myself again in the state after Vipassana, if I took care of myself and meditated, I would be in a much better mental state. It does great things, but it's not a cure-all. It changed my life more than anything else has and is immensely powerful. It introduced me to myself. For that I will always be grateful. And I hope I respect myself enough to go back soon.
- Neurocynic 11y agoI loved the clarity of thought that experience gave me. It is interesting how we both went thorough the same phases. The immense calm, the slow agitation and then excuses. I even went back for a short 4 day course but the 10 day one was the best. I hope you can go back once more and then continue the practice afterwards.
- futuravenir 11y agoI meditated today. Gosh was that nice. Thank you for your kind wishes and your shared experiences.
- carrotleads 11y agoIf it was benefecial, why didn't you do more of it.. Surely as rational people that is the course to take? I see the same with my Yoga practice... touchwood, I am mostly healthy and I should do more Yoga but somedays I am looking for reasons not to do my usual tiny practice.. Is it cause we don't make the outward connection between the practice and our wellbeing? PS : thinking aloud and trying to see if I am alone in this...
- babuskov 11y agoI tried Vipassana on my own while I was a student (it was much easier to get stretches of peaceful time). I read the instructions from a book and managed to get into a different state of mind in about 45 minutes or so. Is there really some point in sitting and trying it all day long? I mean, if you cannot "get" it within an hour, aren't you doing something wrong? Or it takes different length of time for different people? What was your experience? How long it took you to get into the other "state"? Were you able to get into it much faster afterwards?
- futuravenir 11y agoIt took me about a week. And it totally caught me off-guard. I had no expectations going in. It definitely takes different people different amounts of time. And if you are suffering, it is that much more difficult because you have pain that is holding you with attachment. I'm not able to get into that state very quickly at all...I haven't been in that state for years actually.
- Delmania 11y agoDo you continue to sit?
- futuravenir 11y agoToday I did for the first time in awhile. These conversations reinvigorated me to do so. Regularly though...I haven't been.
- Delmania 11y ago>Is there really some point in sitting and trying it all day long? I mean, if you cannot "get" it within an hour, aren't you doing something wrong? Or it takes different length of time for different people? Disclaimer: I am more a follower of Zen Buddhism. There is no right or wrong. The goal of this, any other forms of Buddhism, is satori. It can take some people a year, some people a lifetime, but at the end, practice and satori are one.
- ep103 11y agoDo I have to learn how to meditate before I go? How can I learn? Where do I find a place like this? If I want to do this, what are my first steps?
- ctolsen 11y agoYou don't have to learn anything, but it's a fairly big step to go straight for a long sit. See http://www.dhamma.org http://www.dhamma.org for info on intensive Vipassana courses. For something a bit easier that you can do at home, check out this self guided course: http://palousemindfulness.com/selfguidedMBSR_week1.html http://palousemindfulness.com/selfguidedMBSR_week1.html
- grantcox 11y agoI recommend learning how to meditate before you go. I attempted a 10 day vipasana as a complete beginner and with insufficient research, and assumed it would be some kind of "course". Instead we were instructed on what to meditate on (first day is literally "feel the breath entering your nose"), and then expected to sit still and meditate for 11 hours a day. This vipasana (Kathmandu, late 2011) had no "optional sessions", and no additional instructions. As a complete beginner I was disappointed and frustrated - was I doing it right, is there no technique to be taught, or tips to be given? The analogy I'd give is if I'd joined a 10 day fitness camp and the only instruction was "do deadlifts", and then you were left alone for 11 hours. What's a deadlift? Is this the right form? After an hour I feel like I've exhausted these muscles, do I really just keep doing it for ten more hours today? After three days of this, (each day having a slightly more specific focus but still lacking in the kind of direction or confirmation I was looking for), I left. I was a stone's throw from the Himalayas, and I felt that spending my remaining time in the mountains would do more for me than sitting in a dark room feeling confused and frustrated. I can't answer how to learn to meditate, I haven't followed it up (once burnt, twice shy). But you could try the vipasana way at home - sit in a quiet room and "feel the breath entering your nose" for an hour.
- javajosh 11y agoYou had an unfortunate experience. Perhaps if you took a course in an English speaking country the instructions would be clearer to you, and you'd be more aware of the availability of those who you can ask for help. And the evening discourses, which go into greater depth of explanation, would be more accessible to you.
- savage_platypus 11y agoThis sounds like more feel-good pseudoscientific hogwash. Is there any evidence that "not talking" can actually lead to an improved life, or is this yet another fad that makes people feel good about themselves?
- ma2rten 11y agoYes, there is evidence: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_on_meditation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_on_meditation
- savage_platypus 11y agoThe report concluded, "Scientific research on meditation practices does not appear to have a common theoretical perspective and is characterized by poor methodological quality. Firm conclusions on the effects of meditation practices in healthcare cannot be drawn based on the available evidence. Future research on meditation practices must be more rigorous in the design and execution of studies and in the analysis and reporting of results." (p. 6) It noted that there is no theoretical explanation of health effects from meditation common to all meditation techniques.
- pcrh 11y agoScientific research has shown that modification of behaviour and perceptions can be achieved without surgical or pharmaceutical intervention. This goes by the name of psychotherapy. In particular, cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) has been shown to work in randomized controlled trials [1]. As such therapies involve only guiding and helping people to think differently, it demonstrates that such guidance has have scientifically measurable effects on the mind and body. It follows from the above that the likelihood that practices such as meditation could have non-zero effects is high. Whether Vipassana itself does so could therefore be tested in the same manner as CBT was, and perhaps that is what should be done... [1]https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=randomized+controlled+trial+for+cbt&btnG=&as_sdt=1%2C5&as_sdtp= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=randomized+contro...
- 11y ago
- comrh 11y agoSounds amazing. I can't figure out if this would be great for my ADHD or similar to CIA torture.
- Neurocynic 11y agoIt would be great for ADHD stuff. As I mentioned in a comment above, it gave me amazing clarity of thought and stillness.
- ossreality 11y agoI feel extremely strongly the same way. Normally I'd be with others ranting on how this sounds like hogwash, but honestly, the idea of it terrifies me. I'm too addicted to constantly having something to be anxious about. It'd probably be difficult, but good for me.
- cpayne 11y agoIt would be both. 10 days of doing anything intensively is a LONG time! The author did say that several people couldn't last. I'm sure you would either crack or have a breakthrough...
- mayayo3 11y agoSometimes, you meet a new person and the first thing that you notice is the immense calm on their faces. You get good vibes from them. And even without talking, you can tell they are nice people. It happened with me recently a few times. As I got to know those people better, I learnt that they've all done Vipassana at some point in their lives. It might sound mumbo jumbo but these are the facts. I haven't done Vipassana but my girlfriend did, about a few months back. Honestly, I didn't see any noticeable change in her. I mean she loves puppies now as much as she did earlier. She definitely did have trippy, out of body experiences. Perhaps, others who don't see her as often as I do might be able to tell some very visible, external changes. However, there was one very peculiar effect. She had been complaining of a chronic back pain for almost a year. After she returned, her back pain was 90% gone! Some of my close friends have also recently returned from it, and they all seem calmer, more mindful people now.
- savage_platypus 11y agoReads like a scientology ad
- lamuerteflaca 11y ago>>Reads like a Scientology ad After just reading the first few lines I started thinking what a bunch of bull. Then I read your message and I laughed because it's so true...:) What worries me is that it is so easy to be taken in by this stuff. Specially if you are in a vulnerable state.
- seanp2k2 11y agoIt is what you make of it; that's also the whole point, so it's funny because it's meta. That's also why I find people who are super-invested in that type of thing and super serious about it hilarious; it's as if they don't get it because they think they get it so hard.
- crindy 11y agoDid you sign up just to bash vipassana? I'm curious as to why you feel so strongly about the issue. If it works for some people, it works for them. Does it cause harm to you if other people give it a try?
- pattttttt 11y agoMasturbation was not prohibited in the course, although they ask not to perform any spiritual practices (stretching doesn't count) as it'd disturb others and might produce mixed results.
- Animats 11y agoFrom the article: "About half a year ago I started taking psychedelic drugs fairly regularly. Partially because they were fun, but also because I could see how they benefited me therapeutically. When I heard that meditation could produce similar effects, I found a ten day intense silent meditation course I could join in Italy." Huey Lewis & the News: "I want a new drug One that won't make me sick One that won't make me crash my car Or make me feel three feet thick I want a new drug One that won't hurt my head One that won't make my mouth too dry Or make my eyes too red" I'm inclined to go with Feynman on this. He was once convinced in the 1960s by Dr. John Lilly to try LSD, being told it would improve his thinking. Feynman then thought, the next day, that he had solved a hard problem he'd been working on. While going to a meeting where he was doing to discuss his solution, he realized that he hadn't solved the problem, he had hallucinated that he had solved the problem. Feynman was furious. He wrote "I like to think, and I don't want to break the machine." That guy would probably get equally good results by taking 10 days off to go surfing.
- cpayne 11y agogood results by taking 10 days off to go surfing Or just 10 days of doing anything you don't normally do. 10 days of doing anything intensively would make a drastic results: - learn a new programming language - learn a new skill (cooking, painting, carpentry) - 10 straight days of helping someone less fortunate than yourself
- ctolsen 11y agoThere's scientific evidence that meditation improves memory, cognition, grey matter, concentration, and so on. The same is not true for surfing or generally relaxing. Just because people feel like there are similarities between experiences on psychedelics and meditation does not mean that they have equal outcomes.
- oskarth 11y agoThis is such a dismissive attitude. What Feynman is talking about is putting something artificial in your body with potentially adverse side effects. This has very little to do with sitting still in a room and watching your breathing. This is something people have done for thousands of years, and it consists "only" of sitting. Going on a surf vacation for 10 days isn't going to have nearly as big of an impact as something like this in this dimension. You may a get a lot better at surfing really quickly, and meet some friends. Which is great! If you don't think meditation is for your, fine, don't do it. But don't downplay people's experience by imposing your own limited world view on it. EDIT: My intention is not be dismissive of surfing as an activity. I would be surprised though if OP went on a 10 day surfing retreat and wrote a similar article to the one we are reading now.
- hackercurious 11y agoI wanted to add that there are several forms/types of Vipassana and several different types of centers that conduct retreats. Many people get confused and think that there is only one type of Vipassana. The Insight Meditation Society (IMS) is located near Boston and is the most extensive center in the US. “IMS offers Buddhist meditation retreats at two facilities – the Retreat Center and The Forest Refuge – in rural central Massachusetts. The Retreat Center is one of the two IMS centers in the United States. However, all Buddhist centers teach vipassana/vispashyana. It offers a full yearly schedule of more than 25 meditation courses, ranging in duration from a weekend to three months. Most retreats run for 7–9 days.” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insight_Meditation_Society https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insight_Meditation_Society Insight Meditation Society (IMS) uses a sliding scale to charge for its retreats and I have found them to be my favorite center for going on a retreat.
- KingMob 11y agoI came here to second this. The author clearly has experience only with Goenka and has absorbed their atypical use of the Pali word "vipassana". It's not usually used as a noun to describe a retreat. Nor was it "lost" for centuries. Most serious Theravadan retreat centers have been doing plenty of vipassana. IMS is a wonderful facility. On the west coast, its sister center is Spirit Rock, though they're not quite as well set up for long retreats.
- willyyr 11y agoI'm still looking back to my vipassana experience a few years ago. It's something I don't want to miss and it helped me focus again. Mindfulness is something beautiful. Also something that I think is not quite clear from the article is that vipassana is not some kind of crazy cult. It's basically "just" a technique.
- amttc 11y agoYeah, that part of the article I feel is off. I've never been on a retreat but I do sit. It's definitely an experience that I think people should try, but it doesn't really bear any resemblance to a trip (at least for me). It's more like turning a magnifying glass on how I make thoughts.
- brooklyndude 11y agoAdding some science, just those crazy people from Harvard: Harvard Unveils MRI Study Proving Meditation Literally Rebuilds The Brain’s Gray Matter In 8 Weeks Test subjects taking part in an 8-week program of mindfulness meditation showed results that astonished even the most experienced neuroscientists at Harvard University. The study was led by a Harvard-affiliated team of researchers based at Massachusetts General Hospital, and the team’s MRI scans documented for the very first time in medical history how meditation produced massive changes inside the brain’s gray matter. “Although the practice of meditation is associated with a sense of peacefulness and physical relaxation, practitioners have long claimed that meditation also provides cognitive and psychological benefits that persist throughout the day,” says study senior author Sara Lazar of the MGH Psychiatric Neuroimaging Research Program and a Harvard Medical School instructor in psychology. “This study demonstrates that changes in brain structure may underlie some of these reported improvements and that people are not just feeling better because they are spending time relaxing.” http://www.feelguide.com/2014/11/19/harvard-unveils-mri-study-proving-meditation-literally-rebuilds-the-brains-gray-matter-in-8-weeks/ http://www.feelguide.com/2014/11/19/harvard-unveils-mri-stud...
- hackercurious 11y agoCan Buddhist practice liberate us from the prison of physical pain? "How can meditation help when medicine falls short? Jon Kabat-Zinn, Ph.D., professor emeritus of medicine at the University of Massachusetts medical School, speaks to these questions as a long-time practitioner of Buddhist meditation and hatha yoga, and as a pioneer in the use of mindfulness to treat chronic pain and illness. More than 13,000 people have visited the world-renowned Stress Reduction Clinic that Kabat-Zinn established in 1979 at the UMass medical Center, and the eight-week program- described in Kabat-Zinn’s bestseller “Full Catastrophe Living”- is now also offered at some two hundred medical facilities worldwide." http://www.bemindful.org/kabatzinnart.htm http://www.bemindful.org/kabatzinnart.htm
- Roelven 11y agoThis is a terrible article. Meditation is a great way to get to know yourself better or solve problems, I would not compare it to "tripping balls" in any way. If you want to learn more I recommend reading about it on http://www.dhamma.org http://www.dhamma.org, where you can also find meditation centers near you.
- tempodox 11y agoPain is only temporary, pleasure is only temporary and you only bring yourself misery if you go chasing after either is the basic deal. And while those things sound simple as a rule of thumb, that doesn't make them easy to follow. That conclusion is worth something, whichever way you arrive at it. I guess it's one of the basic truths about our way of existence.
- dreamfactory2 11y agoSerenity now...
- throwaway12357 11y agoI have been trying to do 5 minutes a day of "ignorant meditation" (just sitting on the floor, clearing up my head, and focusing on breathing), but have seriously slacking off these past weeks. Are there any worthwhile youtube videos on mindfulness meditation? And is Vipassana meditation "better" than the other types?
- komaromy 11y agoI found the iOS "Yoga Nidra" app to be a good starting point. There is a trial version that gives you a 10-minute walkthrough.
- hypertexthero 11y ago> Remember that letting go is not forcing something to go away. Instead, letting go is an invitation. We generously allow the recipient to choose whether or not to accept the invitation, and we are happy either way. When we let go of something that distracts our meditation, we are gently inviting it to stop distracting us, but we generously allow it to decide whether or not it wants to stay. If it decides to leave, that is fine. If it decides to stay, that is fine too. We treat it with kindness and generosity during its entire presence. This is the practice of letting go. > Finally, if you do not remember a single thing you read in this chapter so far (maybe because you do not care about this book but your wife made you sit down and read it), happily, Jon Kabat-Zinn has a one-phrase summary of this entire chapter: > __Breathing as if your life depends on it.__ > If you can only remember a single phrase in this chapter, remember this, and you will understand mindfulness meditation. From Chade-Meng Tan's Search Inside Yourself: The Unexpected Path to Achieving Success, Happiness (and World Peace), warmly recommended: http://www.siybook.com/ http://www.siybook.com/
- daragh99 11y agoI've been a software engineer for 15 years, have meditated with varying degrees of consistency for 10 years, and have taught meditation to peers, friends and the public for the last 3 years. The conclusions reached in this article about the temporary nature of all states and experiences, as well as connecting with the wisdom of the body, resonate strongly with me. I'd add that the ability I have developed to monitor and redirect my thoughts, as well as enhanced concentration, are other direct benefits. I believe you can see some benefits from meditation without embracing the full retreat experience. But a retreat is definitely a step-up and solidifies a lot of the lessons. I've done 8-day insight retreats which are a little less austere than Vipassana but seem to bring about similar states and changes. I wrote the story of how I ended up teaching meditation (I teach 8-week courses with similar content to MBSR). You can read it here if you are interested: http://www.geekmindfitness.com/mindfulness/why-this-software-developer-teaches-mindfulness-meditation/ http://www.geekmindfitness.com/mindfulness/why-this-software... There's another write-up I did of how some of this affected my journey through anxiety, specifically impostor syndrome: http://www.geekmindfitness.com/mindfulness/how-mindfulness-meditation-stopped-me-feeling-like-a-fake/ http://www.geekmindfitness.com/mindfulness/how-mindfulness-m...