4 ms·
I find myself jealous of these people. For the price of a little hypocrisy, you get to be part of a very supportive community. You get structure for your life,
by modeless 11y ago
I find myself jealous of these people. For the price of a little hypocrisy, you get to be part of a very supportive community. You get structure for your life, a large number of social gatherings, and a big pool of potential friends and romantic partners. I almost considered going to church just for that reason (back when I was in college and friends with a lot of devout Christians), but I couldn't stomach the hypocrisy of going to church as an atheist.
Perhaps somebody could start an "atheist church", but the concept is unpalatable to me. I don't want atheism to define my life in the same way belief defines the life of religious adherents. I don't want to attend atheist classes or listen to an atheist preacher or be around evangelical atheists. I just want a large community of people who stick together, follow a common moral code, support each other, and have regular social events.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoThere are non-religious communities as well. Take music fans for example. They do all that social gatherings stuff. Board games players also. And at least their object of praise provably exists.
- vinceguidry 11y agoThere's also 'the community' as in, neighborhood associations and council meetings and the like. http://ctb.ku.edu/en/table-of-contents http://ctb.ku.edu/en/table-of-contents
- schoen 11y agoSomeone did start an atheist church along these lines: http://sundayassembly.com/ http://sundayassembly.com/ This is at least the second time that people have done so: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethical_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethical_movement I don't have any experience with either movement, so I don't know whether they would be very similar to or very different from what you would like.
- mercer 11y agoI have experience with the something like former and while I'd characterize it as very positive, it doesn't quite compare to the community of the church I used to be an active member of. My impression is that some of these initiatives emulate the 'wrong' parts of church. While I'm not certain of this, I suspect that this has something to do with the fact that many churches in more recent times have made the same mistake, and these initiatives often involve people with a background in these kinds of churches. My background is Evangelical, and in my opinion they do 'community' extremely well. Perhaps they're the best 'form' to emulate, and since the 'content' is often relatively... flimsy, it is easily replaced with other things. That said, the initiatives I've experienced were still very worthwhile and enjoyable! Let me elaborate. Via meetup.com a friend of mine organized meetings every two weeks. Rather than follow the 'Sunday service' model, it was closer to the 'weekday small-group' model that is part of most churches, and particularly important Evangelical ones (to the point of using the Sunday as little more than evangelism). We'd meet in a group of around 8-14 people and after some initial conversation, we'd split up into groups with a piece of text chosen by the conversation leader. This could be a bible passage, but also something else entirely. Then, we'd start talking about the topic, following a few basic rules. Most crucially, we were strongly encouraged to not primarily debate or discuss our viewpoints, but to try and keep things personal and focused on experience. This, of course, created bonds through the (forced) openness and the resulting recognition and empathy. Afterwards, we'd go to a bar and just mingle and talk about whatever. Usually much of that would be spending more time talking about the topic we'd discussed earlier. Many people came because they were tired of 'empty' conversations in the typical social events, often because they had a desire to discuss 'higher' things with 'smart people'. Some ended up disappointed that they had little room to espouse their views and belittle the 'superficial people' with an in-group, but most came to appreciate and value the personal, meaningful conversations. And, of course, inevitably the 'intellectuals' would end up discussing philosophy or religion and the like anyways, but now with a foundation of empathy and friendship. It was also extremely valuable to see a mixed group of individuals that would often not associate or even avoid each other. One of my favorite regulars was a guy who owned a printing-press in a neighboring city and just came by because his adopted 16-year old daughter wanted to attend. He had a lot of trouble with the 'level' of conversation initially, and clearly was not used to talking about intellectual things or sharing personal-ish stuff. But over time he came to enjoy the thoughtful conversation and the free-form 'pub time' afterwards and many of us, in turn, came to appreciate that he was not just some 'simpleton' and often contributed immensely to the conversation by virtue of having a very different, more experiential outlook on life (and a very different past). Some of the most valuable things that I had as a church member and that I always missed were the community, the personal interaction within such groups, the encouragement to show at least some vulnerability, and the mix of wildly different people exchanging views and experiences. And those were the best things that these 'sunday assembly' type initiatives offered, in my opinion.
- dropit_sphere 11y agoYou might enjoy Scott Alexander's post on this topic: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/24/there-are-rules-here/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/24/there-are-rules-here/
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoSounds like you might be interested in a (unitarian) universalist church.
- andrewchambers 11y agoIt's called a club, sports clubs, chess clubs etc.
- seanp2k2 11y agoTL;DR especially in large metro areas, there are lots of other groups doing fun stuff, so I don't think (church - theism) is necessary (but it is an interesting idea). Churches aren't the only way to meet people. Festivals are great if you're in California; there's basically at least one a month if you're looking. If that's not your scene, there are tons of various meet-ups around. Not quite the same as religion, but some are really organized and dedicated. Group exercise was my thing for a few years; cycling groups are great because you get to spend lots of time outside getting in [better] shape, and the people are generally friendly / interesting in my experience. Sailing is really fun too if you find the right club. "Yacht club" might not immediately sound like something you want to be involved in, but Cal Sailing Club at Berkeley marina, for example, is different. It's a co-op ($100 per quarter for membership, they have their own boats) with a really friendly and community-oriented atmosphere.
- sliverstorm 11y agoFestivals etc aren't quite suited. Studies have shown that friendship etc forms best when you both "have" to be there, and regularly see eachother at these events. I'm not describing this eloquently, but basically Sunday church and weekday K-12 education are both prime substrate for forming strong friendship, while random run-ins at festivals and concerts are decidedly not. Considering the decline in church attendance in young adulthood, and the fact that you don't attend grade school anymore, small wonder strong friendship is harder to come by.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoChurch is a much less popular/common way to meet people than it used to be: https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2015/06/chart7.png?w=655&h=873 https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2015/06/chart7.png?w=...
- obstinate 11y agoOnline is drinking everything else's milkshake! What a graph! It's easy to see why it appeals so well -- every candidate you examine is looking for a predictable thing, which assuming you're doing your search properly, is roughly the same as what you're looking for. There's still a significant risk that any given match won't care for you or vice versa, but it eliminates an entire layer of annoyance -- that is, that the person you're approaching is not looking for a relationship, or not looking for the kind that you are.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoIt's nothing compared to same sex couples: https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2015/06/chart_samesex2.png?w=655&h=873 https://timedotcom.files.wordpress.com/2015/06/chart_samesex...
- philwelch 11y ago> Perhaps somebody could start an "atheist church", but the concept is unpalatable to me. Sounds like the Unitarian Universalists to me.
- steve19 11y agoThere are plenty of atheists (or let's say non-theist) churches and organizations trying to emulate churches. There are in fact plenty of books written on the topic. I read one recently but cannot recall the name or author, essentially promoting exactly what you said in your comment (he was a UC Philosophy professor I think) As a devout religious person, let me say there are plenty of religious folks who don't believe in God, and who do not see a contradiction in this (whether or not they say so). There are those who reject the traditional doctrine of Christianity (God included) and who those who focus so keenly on the traditions that they care little for the concept of God. On the reverse side of the coin, there are plenty of people who I know who claim to be Rational Atheists but who are barely able to reason. I have also met people who claim to be Atheists but who are at "best" Agnostic, or "worst" they are, deep down, Thiests. Hearing someone "I am a Christian/Muslim" means very little. Hearing them say "I am Atheist" might mean a little more (as in it is not the default choice) but also says very little about what they really believe deep down. It comes down to who you wish to associate with. It is easier to be a Christian politician in the USA than an Atheist politician, and, if my college days were anything to go by, easier to be an Atheist student or professor than a devout religious student/professor.
- xroche 11y ago> Perhaps somebody could start an "atheist church", but the concept is unpalatable to me In France, a lot of atheist Jews joined Freemasonry at the beginning of the 20th century for this very reason: they were highly educated, atheists, and felt that they were missing something because they did not gather anymore for religious reasons. But rather than flocking to pray uselessly (yes, this is a bit provocative), they used their time to think about and improve society - it would be called a "think tank" today I presume. This led to major improvements in the french society at that time, and especially a law that separated church and state, leading to a fully secular society (so the "1905" law in France) (And this is one of the reason why Freemasons were persecuted by the nazi-friendly governments in France during the WW2 - they were hated by far rights religious people for being atheists AND for accepting Jews, and because of previous secular laws)
- jorangreef 11y agoAs you say, I don't think you can have true fellowship if it does not have its basis in the truth. I know of someone who was studying neuroscience in England, and when he thought through the ramifications of his atheist beliefs he was depressed at where it was leading for his life. He wondered if perhaps there was not something of the truth which he might have missed and I think it made him less hostile to considering the points of views of others. Fellowship means loyalty, faithfulness, partnership, a sense of belonging, love for one another, very much like Tolkien's Fellowship of the Ring. And fellowship in Christ's church can't be had outside of fellowship with the eye witness historical accounts of Jesus. John Zebedee writing from the 1st century puts it like this: "That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked at and our hands have touched - this we proclaim concerning the Word of life. The life appeared; we have seen it and testify to it, and we proclaim to you the eternal life, which was with the Father and has appeared to us. We proclaim to you what we have seen and heard, so that you also may have fellowship with us. And our fellowship is with the Father and with his Son, Jesus Christ. We write this to make our joy complete." If we believe that people like John, who suffered tremendously for what they considered to be the truth, were actually telling the truth about historical events, then we can have fellowship with the apostles, and we can have fellowship with God himself.
- martin1975 11y agoYou sound like you'd be an excellent leader of the modeless cult. ;) Whatever you do, I urge you to not touch Unitarian Universalists even with a 50 foot pole who are wolves in sheep clothing, a gathering of hypocrites, nothing more.
- dd9990 11y ago"I just want a large community of people who stick together, follow a common moral code, support each other, and have regular social events." It's called Humanist - see if there's a community in your area. It has a common moral code based on the rejection of the supernatural and it's actually voted on every few years. I would define Humanism as pragmatic atheism which steals the best parts of religion - community, charity work, choirs, regular meetups etc.
- Delmania 11y agoLook into Buddhism. You get all of that, but there's no obligation to believe in a god.
- jinushaun 11y agoAmen. I've also wrestled with these thoughts growing up. Atheists don't have the same sense of community that religious people do. Sure, I've done the meet up thing, sports, music, etc. but they all fizzle out. Nothing keeps people coming back day after day. Music festivals happen once a year, church happens every week with more than just a handful of people. And reading all the suggestions below, I don't understand why people are recommending alternative religions. He stated he wanted the community, without the belief. This is why I miss school. It was something that got a bunch of people together on a regular basis. You didn't personally meet, hang out with or like every individual person, but I think it had what the OP is asking for.
- jarboot 11y agoBeing in a church includes you in a fantastic community. If anyone is sick, my childhood church would cook meals and bring them over. If you needed a job, someone could find you an opening (that's how I got my first job). Everyone carpooled to church events, had house parties, and because it was a Lutheran church (WELS), drank quite a bit too. I've never believed in god, but since my dad was President of the congregation I sort of went along for the ride. I still play piano for the church (and thank the church for starting the spark for it), even though I don't really believe in all that. It's just a nice and caring community. When I'm older, I'm absolutely going to try joining some sort of church.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Being in a church includes you in a fantastic community. That rather strongly depends on the church (and you; communities aren't objectively fantastic, the same community can be fantastic for one person and a nightmare for another; this is definitely as true of church communities as communities in general.)
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Perhaps somebody could start an "atheist church", Already been done, see, e.g., the "Sunday Assembly" phenomenon. > I don't want atheism to define my life in the same way belief defines the life of religious adherents. I don't want to attend atheist classes or listen to an atheist preacher or be around evangelical atheists. I just want a large community of people who stick together, follow a common moral code, support each other, and have regular social events. From what I've heard, most Sunday Assembly groups are a lot like what you describe wanting, and less like what you describe not wanting.