3 ms·
> The last time she showed signs of non-conformist behaviour, her husband consulted the community leaders. They sent her to see a mental health specialist, who
by rdtsc 11y ago
> The last time she showed signs of non-conformist behaviour, her husband consulted the community leaders. They sent her to see a mental health specialist, who medicated her. ‘The mental illness card has been used often in cases like mine,’ she wrote. She has since seen another mental health specialist; he gave her a clean bill of health.
That is pretty brutal. "Mental health" was often used by opressive regimes to discredit and punish dissidents. In the Soviet Union they would do that to religious figures (Orthodox Christian priests and political dissidents). The card then was flipped. The religious figures were basically considered "mentally ill" for believing that God exists, and they would be subjected to heavy doses of medications in order to "snap them out of it" in hopes they would see the truth. Of course, the true underlying reason was to remove them from public life so they don't spread those ideas, and as a side-effect torture to punish them so others may learn their lesson from it..
- JesperRavn 11y agoSad that the political power of the Hasidic community is able to result in the justice/medical system being abused like this. While people are rightly wary of other tight knit religious communities, I think that abuses like this in the Hasidic community go unchecked because it's politically unacceptable for police and politicians to criticize the Hasidic community.
- ars 11y agoIt's more likely that he really did think she had a problem and was trying to help. Not that he was trying to abuse the medical system to get his way.
- hueving 11y agoIt's doubtful that a person in a position of that power and responsibility is that stupid.
- philwelch 11y agoI don't know if it's because you're especially naive or I'm especially cynical, but that comment is absurd to me. If only power and responsibility were a guarantee against someone being that stupid, we would live in a much better world!
- salgernon 11y agoI've been forever scarred - in a good way - by the James Burke series "the day the universe changed". In I think the penultimate episode he explains as we watch a dramatization of a witch being tried and burned at the stake that the people perpetrating the horrible act truly believed that they were doing a good thing. That their reality included witches and Devils and gods and that they were doing this woman a favor for her immortal soul. It sounds rediculous to us today but sending someone to be medicated because they don't adhere to your particular belief system seems right in line with that kind of thinking. (To say nothing of religions that practice exorcism, Rebirthing and eschewing gluten. ) Personally I wonder what beliefs we hold today will be absolutely appalling to our descendants 400 years from now. Probably eating meat (and I say this as someone that is in now way pro-veg, and I eat meat all the time - I just suspect we will find that our current working theories of animal behavior will prove that we are morally responsible for great pain in other sentient beings.) because our society keeps it acceptable in our perceived (or imposed) reality.