4 ms·
Never skip Aaronson's comments on his blog posts. They're often as good as the posts themselves. Here's a great example: "Whenever I hear this style of argumen
by lern_too_spel 11y ago
Never skip Aaronson's comments on his blog posts. They're often as good as the posts themselves. Here's a great example:
"Whenever I hear this style of argument, I’m reminded of Marcia Clark’s closing argument in the OJ Simpson trial: 'We have proved that OJ Simpson is a murderer. The defense has proved that Mark Fuhrman is a racist.'
"Likewise, in this case: 'We have proved that climate change is a grave threat to the survival of human civilization. You have proved that rich, do-gooder liberals can come off as annoying hypocrites.'
"Unfortunately, the human mind is wired in such a way that, just as 'Mark Fuhrman is a racist' actually worked to get OJ acquitted for murder, so 'Al Gore and Leonardo DiCaprio are smug elitists, flying around in their private jets' is considered by millions to be a strong argument for climate inaction."
- briandear 11y agoIf Al Gore were so profoundly afraid of climate change, he wouldn't fly in a private jet or have a huge mansion with massive electrical consumption. Since he does those things, then he's obviously not convinced that human activity affects climate. Interestingly, if he donated the billions in profits he has made from his climate change "investments" then perhaps he could be taken more seriously. Al Gore invests in "green" companies. He uses his platform to scare the world. He becomes a billionaire. He continues living his life exactly as he did before. Anyone that attempts to give Al Gore any credibility whatsoever has none themselves. It's interesting because Warren Buffet is often cited by leftists because Buffet supports raising income taxes. See the Buffet secretary story from 2011 where he complained that his secretary pays a higher income tax rate than he does. Interestingly, Buffet did not call for a raising of the capital gains tax -- the form of income from which Buffet derives his wealth. The relevance of this example is that these marquee people that try and influence public policy ALWAYS act rationally towards their own best interests. Al Gore promotes AGW and becomes a billionaire. Buffet suggests raising income taxes to potentially deflect calls to raise capital gains taxes. This "settled science" bullshit is exactly that. No science is "settled," yet there are those that want to fundamentally alter civilization based on politically-influenced mathematical models. Interestingly, even the IPCC admits that "we redistribute world's wealth by climate policy." Looking at the AGW issue objectively, given all of the scandal, the misrepresentations, the outright lies (i.e. the polar ice cap will be completely gone by 2016,) and the Chicken Little aspects, a person with no political opinions at all would be suspicious. The idea of human-caused global warming has been trumpeted with a zeal equal to that of the Eugenics movement -- and we all know how that turned out. As an example, Charles Davenport had a PhD in biology from Harvard and later was a Harvard professor. He also was the director of Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. At the time, one could say his scientific credentials were beyond reproach. One of his statements (among others) was, "I believe in such a selection of immigrants as shall not tend to adulterate our national germ plasm with socially unfit traits." This highly respected scientist helped and supported the Nazis, their scientific programs were based on much of Davenport's work. Yet, in 1911, he was elected to the National Academy of Sciences because of his eugenics work. Eugenics inspired Margaret Sanger to found Planned Parenthood, not to save society from unwanted pregnancies, but to prevent immigrant "inferiors" from breeding. A member of the National Academy of Sciences who laid the groundwork for the extermination of millions of people. All based on "settled science." So pardon me if I'm a bit skeptical when a billionaire politician like Al Gore tries to sell the world a bill of goods. We could argue that divestiture or the elimination of fossil fuels might be "good," but then again similar arguments for "goodness" were made in the justification eugenics. I'm certainly not comparing oil to genocide; I'm elucidating the potential rabbit hole down which we may go when we confuse the scientific with the political.
- wj 11y agoAl Gore is a billionaire?
- sxcurry 11y agoBut climate change has nothing to do with Al Gore, and how he might behave or misbehave. It's simple physics, and politics doesn't come into it. I agree that politics does come into any future response to climate change, but it doesn't affect the physics.
- fsk 11y agoYou missed the biggest criticism of Warren Buffet regarding taxes. Warren Buffet argues for high estate taxes. Bershire Hawthaway makes a lot of money buying family-owned businesses worth ~$100M, who are forced to sell due to the estate tax bill.
- sxcurry 11y agoJust FYI, from the Washington Post article on the estate tax, "The nonpartisan Tax Policy Center estimates that only 120 farms and small business, where at least half the assets are in farm or business assets, had to pay the estate tax in 2013."
- justin66 11y ago> He becomes a billionaire. This has never been true of Al Gore. You're confused about a lot of things but this is the oddest, as it's the easiest to verify.
- __z 11y agoAl Gore's net worth is about $200 million, for the people who don't want to google.
- Fishkins 11y ago> Interestingly, Buffet did not call for a raising of the capital gains tax -- the form of income from which Buffet derives his wealth. Um, why do you say that? Every statement I've seen from him very clearly says taxes on capital gains need to increase (at least for those earning large capital gains). http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/26/opinion/buffett-a-minimum-tax-for-the-wealthy.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/26/opinion/buffett-a-minimum-...
- SilasX 11y agoTo plagiarize from my comment on his blog about this: Regarding Al Gore types, I don’t think it’s fair to use them as an argument agains the science or need for action. But it is majestically fair to use their actions to argue against the inefficient "blacklist" approach, where they presume to tell me which goods have a negative net utility, rather than giving me a price and letting me decide whether I still want the incandescent light bulbs. If you don’t like legislation that would mandate a smaller home size or max flights per year (knowing you can pay for the externality), then don’t propose legislation that would mandate what kind of artificial light you can have!
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt's perfectly reasonable to ban some things and merely tax others. There's no broad legal or moral principle I'm aware off that makes banning things inherently wrong, doubly so if taxation is considered acceptable. High taxation is basically a difference in degree from banning, not in kind. So your attack on Al Gore is even more obscure than the usual ones. It could easily be turned around and argued that it's unfair to allow the rich to have the privilege of incandescent bulbs, while the poor have to suffer with the harsh but efficient LEDs. Having said that, as someone who thinks the free market is a powerful tool, I'd generally go for carbon taxes as that lets the market do it's thing, rather than more targetted bans, subsidies or taxes. But presumably the ban was effected with the intent of getting out from one local maximum caused by network effects and high up-front investments in the new tech (people will wrongly choose the cheap in the short term tech rather than the cheap in the long term), so it seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to do in my eyes.
- SilasX 11y agoIt's actually not perfectly reasonable to destroy all the utility gained from incandescent bulbs net of their easily affordable externality cost, nor to conclude that incandescent bulbs are obviously wasteful but a bigger house is not.