4 ms·
What's the disadvantage of those other foundations that makes them unsuitable for universal use?
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
What's the disadvantage of those other foundations that makes them unsuitable for universal use?
- black_knight 11y agoOf course the proponents of these other foundations claim that they are suitable for universal use. But sets came first, and is good enough for most purposes, and mathematicians in general are more concerned with mathematics than foundations. Actually the recent movement of "Homotopy Type Theory" is gaining some traction among non-logicians, giving easier formulations and proofs in category theory and topology. Also in computer science type theory is becoming more usual, since all results are constructive (provides algorithms) and is in fact a programming language in it self.
- tel 11y agoThey're certainly not unsuitable, but they have a tendency to take observation/realization/grasping/proving as an instantaneous process. In most people's regular understanding of logic, however, this is false. There is a process by which new data and new conclusions from that data are drawn and made available to you. So ultimately, if those things matter for either UX of mathematics or for actual mathematical content is a large question, but it's fairly clear that if you need to capture something closer to the actual dynamics of knowledge/learning/understanding then you are sunk when you base your foundations in set theory.