4 ms·
But what we're saying here is this. We use sets to model the real world. They do remarkably well, and the math we've developed to work on them includes calcul
by ColinWright 11y ago
But what we're saying here is this.
We use sets to model the real world. They do remarkably well, and the math we've developed to work on them includes calculus to make bridges that stay up, fluid dynamics that make aeroplanes fly, and discrete math that helps us understand routing, scheduling, and all sorts of stuff.
We use the real line to model distances. In the real world we are limited as to the accuracy we can use, but modelling those limitations is nasty. It's easier to assume that things are continuous. In its turn, we make choices that make working with these models easier, and they turn out to be amazingly useful.
But then we start poking the dusty corners. The choices we make in the development of the theory have consequences, and math is about exploring both the choices, and their consequences.
So we can choose that between every two numbers there's another number. We can choose that there's a number whose square is 2. We can choose that the sum of the reciprocals of squares : 1+1/4+1/9+1/16+1/25+1/36+ ... : is a real number.
And we can choose that there is no smallest positive number. That has a consequence. If you believe that there is no smallest positive number, then 0.99999... has to equal 1. You can't have one without the other.
So we can talk about "the length of a line." Then we can talk about the "length" of a set of points on a line. Then we start to find that these simplistic models, these obvious and natural choices, even though they are amazingly useful have some unexpected consequences.
Does that help you to understand the context?
I'd be really interested in developing an agreed dialog about this. Will you send me an email?
- summerdown2 11y ago> I'd be really interested in developing an agreed dialog about this. Will you send me an email? I've sent you an email, as requested. From the sound of it, though, the answer to my puzzlement, is that it doesn't apply to this universe. In which case, I don't think it's a problem at all. I'm quite happy to imagine mathematicians doing work on geometries that don't map to the real world, for example. Mostly, then, is this just a question of presentation? I mean, if you said "this does not apply to the real world, but to some fictitious mathematical assumption that assumes things can be divided up infinitely," I don't think anyone would have an issue with it. It sounds like it's a problem to most people because it's presented as if it's a real-world result. Or, at least, that seems to be the impression I get, given the other comments. What I mean is, is there's a question of misdirection here? I.e. the theorem is presented as this non-intuitive thing that can't possibly be the case in the real world, then when someone asks what would happen if you tried it in the real world, the answer is "it's assuming some things that aren't true for the real world." Because if that's the case, I'm not sure I see the paradox. Assuming a weird set of ideas, I would expect you can come up with weird answers. Here's a question, though, because something is nagging at me. And I'm going to assume this is a universe of infinite points and no atoms (as I understand it, at least). Let's say we have a sphere of volume 4/3 pi r^3 = 100 Now you do your cuts, but don't reassemble yet. The sphere is still the original sphere, with all the shapes it has been cut into still in virtually their original spaces. The total volume still has to be 100, right? I mean they all still fit into the original space. So now, you immerse it in water, in a bathtub ready to overflow, and start manipulating the pieces. At what point does the water level rise?
- ColinWright 11y agoI've replied to your email, but to reply here to your specific question: > immerse it in water, in a bathtub ready > to overflow, and start manipulating the > pieces. > At what point does the water level rise? A lovely question. The answer is that the "water" isn't "water", it has to be the same infinitely fine "mush" that the ball is made of. As a result, as you move the pieces out so the "water" ends up forming non-measurable holes to fit them into, and the complement is also non-measurable. So in the same way as the balls kind of "fold out" to become two balls, so the water kind of "folds in" and takes up less space than it used to, exactly balancing the actions of the pieces.
- lmm 11y agoThe four pieces don't have measure, don't have unambiguous volume. It might help to think of them as fractals (though in fact they're even more ambiguous than that). The only "realistic" answer I can give is that each of the four pieces would "take up" the full volume of the sphere as you moved them apart. Each of the four pieces is "shaped" like the whole sphere, but with infinitesimally small holes where the other four go. So not a single "water droplet" would ever go inside the four pieces, and while you were moving them around they'd take up the space of four of the original sphere.
- reagency 11y agoHow are they more ambiguous than fractals? The key structure is a shape that can be rotated onto a subset of itself. I guess with common fractals, you camnoly scale an object onto a subset of itself. The magic of BT is that the ball-shape allows a rotation that looks like a scaling.
- lmm 11y agoA fractal tends to be kind of contiguous - for most points in the fractal there's a neighbourhood of those points that's also in the fractal, and similarly for points not in the fractal. These are "dust sets", dense everywhere in the sphere and their complements also dense.
- 11y ago
- summerdown2 11y agoActually, reading the comic another poster put up here: http://www.irregularwebcomic.net/2339.html http://www.irregularwebcomic.net/2339.html ... I think I've managed to get my head round it. Or, at least form an initial model. It's like the old puzzle of the hotel with infinite rooms, each one labelled with an integer. Then, another infinite set of guests turn up. The hotel manager asks every person currently in the hotel to double their room number and go to that one. Because there are infinite even numbers, this works fine. Then, the new set of infinite guests sleep in the odd number rooms. If I'm right, of course, then this only works because infinity is really odd - and you couldn't get an infinity room hotel in the real world. Is this a reasonable way of thinking about it?
- digama 11y agoShort answer, yes that's a good way to think about it. The Hilbert Hotel paradox is closely related to the B-T paradox, it only adds a few more complications to make a stronger statement. The key step in the B-T paradox is setting up a two-dimenional free group in just three-dimensional rotations. This is an infinite discrete set, a sort of analogue of the integers (which is the one-dimensional free group). In the integers it is no surprise (or maybe it is) that you can take the positive integers and shift them all to the right by one unit and then suddenly you have made a "hole" from apparently nothing (the Hilbert's hotel paradox). One worrisome part of this is that the "rooms" must get infinitely far away, but B-T exploits the fact that by using irrational rotations you an wrap the whole construction into the space taken up by a single sphere. Add just a little more mathematical mumbo jumbo and you have a two-dimensional free group, which is a hotel such that every room is as big as all the rest of the rooms and you can set up the hotel so that each room is as big as all the rest of the rooms, and then you can do magic such that a move to the left actually leaves as much space as the whole hotel. And since it's all wrapped up in a ball it doesn't even run off to infinity to do this. You do need the rooms to be points with zero volume, though; otherwise even with one-atom rooms you still need to shove the entire infinite hotel into a finite space and you will run out of room.