3 ms·
I think it is unfortunate when people do not express their biological potential, but I'm not sure that's what people actually want to talk about. I'm not sure t
by threatofrain 11y ago
I think it is unfortunate when people do not express their biological potential, but I'm not sure that's what people actually want to talk about. I'm not sure that really improves the human condition.
I see the problem as the sum of human economic actions creating a structure where only a few people can win and most people must lose. What does it matter if we bump up people's IQ? Would that make it so that more people try to apply to be leaders and CEO's of tomorrow, when there are so few positions available?
Is the lack of meritocracy the principle emotional bother here? Does society become better if it were meritocratic? I don't think so. Why not focus on the fact that there's a race where only a few people win? Is it because we're okay with the current distribution of wealth if we find out that it corresponds with intelligence?
All I see from this is a more efficient nation due to better labor allocation, which is an agreeable value, but is that what people wanted to talk about? Economic inefficiency due to bad labor allocation?
I think GATTACA shows a meritocratic world. A very meritocratic world. Now, it may be that the movie has some moral message to deliver on "true potential" being more than biology, but that society was largely on target with identifying potential, at least way better than our current world. A few errors now and then sounds very tolerable for a futuristic system, even if it results in a few tragic stories about a denied astronaut with heart problems. I'm sure they can improve and become even more accurate at identifying aspects of human merit.
But in that world, we have corporate dominance of working opportunities, elite rule over inferior biology, a feeling of fate, and shitty jobs -- a world of winners and losers. There will always be more people of merit than there will be jobs of merit. If this last statement is true, what are the implications for the losers of society?
- iamcurious 11y agoThere will always be more people of merit than there will be jobs of merit. If this last statement is true, what are the implications for the losers of society? This makes me think of the Hunter S. Thompson letter posted a few days ago[1]: Let’s assume that you think you have a choice of eight paths to follow (all pre-defined paths, of course). And let’s assume that you can’t see any real purpose in any of the eight. THEN— and here is the essence of all I’ve said— you MUST FIND A NINTH PATH. [1] http://www.openculture.com/2015/02/hunter-s-thompson-life-coach-tips-for-finding-meaning-in-life.html http://www.openculture.com/2015/02/hunter-s-thompson-life-co...
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoYou're accepting a number of premises there without questioning them, including corporatisation, labour/management/owner caste splits, and the fact that a silly science fiction movie is the best of all possible worlds. I suspect none of those are a given. >There will always be more people of merit than there will be jobs of merit. Which explains why it's so hard to hire good people, I guess.