23 ms·
“A Statement with My View on Curtis Yarvin and Strange Loop”
- jessaustin 11y agoAs linked at https://twitter.com/puredanger/status/606663407635283968 https://twitter.com/puredanger/status/606663407635283968
- frou_dh 11y ago> Because of this, I am sorry that I must rescind your invitation and I will not be able to accept or include your talk at the conference. My apologies if this causes you any inconvenience. At least give a straight apology without mealy-mouthed "if..."
- kragen 11y agoNormally I agree with this point, but in this case it seemed like the "if" might actually be correct: because the time from invitation to rescission was so short, it's entirely possible that the invitation caused Yarvin no inconvenience; that he had not yet, for example, bought plane tickets to St. Louis.
- leereeves 11y agoComing soon: left and right wing tech conferences.
- jpt4 11y agoThe "No Voice, Free Exit" response: Hopefully right next to each other, dutifully segregated with freedom of movement maintained between each. Edit: Now, certain of the neo-reactos are hyper-cautious about the effects of entryism, which the above scenario would seem powerless to prevent, but so long as public displays of political identification have no effect on the actual behavior of the governors in the NVFE world the only thing for agent provocateurs to enter would be social circles, whose burden of maintaining memetic purity under fire would not be substantially different from the present, with even less down-stream stakes (as the strengthening or dissolution of such societies would not change sovereign policy).
- twoodfin 11y agoSorry, but yuck! Must politics divide everything in our lives? That sounds like a horrible world to live in.
- jpt4 11y agoThe advocatus diaboli is obliged no apology (nor the promotor fidei for that matter), being (ideally) merely hypothetical, to be spun-up and shut down as dialectic requires. However, do note that there is a difference between political divisions existing, and political divisions having effects beyond the groups of their self-identified constituents. The former, like the poor, will always be with us [0], differing only in visibilty. But, if visibility is a no-op, meaningless to the res publica's execution of policy, then is not the venom neutralized? We currently live in a world of political polarization, but worse, one's affinity towards those poles has material impact on one's life. Surrender Voice, NVFE claims, let like associate with like via Exit, and never be troubled by politics again. [0] Until humans are so radically different that neither remains.
- braythwayt 11y agoYou jest, but conferences are inherently cultural. That’s why people go: To meet people, to be part of a cultural experience. In this century, the technical content can be distributed far more efficiently over the Internet. And tech is already fractured along left and right lines. Some people are hard-line libertarians who believe that businesses should be able to hire and fire whomever they please for whatever reason they please, right down to celebrating the fact that Elon Musk wouldn’t hire someone who used the expression “shoot hoops.” Others deeply believe that tech is an opportunity to right social injustices, to give opportunities to those who were previously shut out, and to bring the world closer together. Whatever you or I believe about this particular decision, it is clearly consistent with the trend towards things like codes of conduct. And the reaction is clearly consistent with the reaction to things like codes of conduct.
- whatucantsay1 11y agoInteresting -- another discussion of this incident was at the top spot of HN some 30 mins ago, and was flagkilled. Is it that we're not interested in discussing it, or only interested in discussing it if certain people / viewpoints are not allowed?
- Mithaldu 11y agoPretty sure that the concensus is that the author of that submission is insane and trying to read his screed as something coming from a mentally healthy person is a waste of time.
- GuiA 11y agoRead it as a non insane person, found it a little rough around the edges but still a perfectly valid and relevant collection of statements. It's a sad world, one where anything that steps out a little bit of the approved "think here" zone is automatically flag killed.
- twoodfin 11y agoI agree that submission was more than a little out there, but it's strange how little impact this event has had on HN, given the subject matter. Maybe this submission will break through.
- leereeves 11y agoThe previous submission was #1 on the front page for a few minutes before it was flag killed. It wasn't overtly racist or filled with profanity; perhaps some people just wanted to silence it.
- jpt4 11y agoTo indulge in a bit of tinfoil-hatting re "some people just wanted to silence it": Tlon, Corp., the Red Hat to Urbit's Fedora, rejected Y-Combinator funding last year.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoI wonder - suppose someone Alex Miller agreed with, but who also caused controversy, was met with opposition by folks who disliked her. For example, suppose a bunch of gamergate types were to complain about Brianna Wu giving a purely technical talk about pathfinding and AI. Would all the folks who are so quick to defend Strangeloop also defend it in this case? Somehow I doubt it.
- tomjen3 11y agoAlmost certainly not, but that is the way of people. That's a separate question from whether they are right or wrong though. I distinctly don't like the way things are going and believe me I have no sympathy for the political views of Curtis, but the talk isn't about that. If Brianna Wu could actually deliver a technical talk, I say let her. If he wanted to talk about neoreaction there are other places he can go to.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoI'm not sure if you meant to imply that Yarvin wanted to talk about neoreaction, but he distinctly did not. His talk was about Urbit: https://github.com/urbit/urbit https://github.com/urbit/urbit
- tomjen3 11y agoI know, I was trying to contrast letting him speak on neoreaction with letting him speak on orbit.
- topynate 11y agoKicking people from your tech conference because they were racist outside of it hands veto power to whoever determines what racism is and when something is 'too racist'. The same goes for the other beyond-the-pale isms like sexism, fascism, etc. I commented on a flagged post on why this is an issue for me personally: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9674958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9674958
- braythwayt 11y agoIf I am the CEO of a company, and I listen to people before making my own decision, am I “handing them veto power?” I think this is Alex Miller’s decision.
- paxdickinson 11y agoIt'll be his decision next time too. And now that the Red Guards know he'll succumb to even the slightest bit of pressure, there will certainly be a next time.
- braythwayt 11y agoI don’t know that we can use words like “succumb.” It’s always that way when you have a strong opinion about a particular matter. For example, we can praise Obama for listening to scientists on certain matters, than complain he is caving under lobbying pressure on others. In the end, I prefer to say that it is Alex’s decision. He didn’t crumble, succumb, get browbeaten, or anything else. He decided, and that means you can hang the responsibility around his neck. People who can’t decide shouldn’t run things, it’s that simple.
- paxdickinson 11y agoIf you'd ever personally faced the wrath of the social justice left, you would probably agree that "succumb" is a highly appropriate word for it.
- 11y ago
- convexfunction 11y agoIt's funny because he definitely saw this coming. http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/09/technology-communism-and-brown-scare.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2013/09/technol...
- paxdickinson 11y agoThe repeated kills of previous threads on this topic illustrate the problem goes much deeper than Strangeloop. HN itself has long been policed by left wing stormtroopers eliminating anything they disagree with. I used to believe it could be saved but now I generally believe that the era of technology having a place for iconoclastic freethinkers is long over.
- ncallaway 11y agoThe great thing about technology is you can always make your own space. You can have a niche website — or other technological forum — that is a bastion of iconoclastic freethinkers. The problem that you're experiencing is that the mainstream public is now very much using technology. That means the average opinions expressed on the web on the internet have become much more mainstream. Which, pretty much by definition, means the average opinion has become much more hostile to iconoclastic thoughts.
- paxdickinson 11y agoI'm not talking about the mainstream. I'm talking about hiring and funding within our industry. If you haven't noticed a chilling effect over the last few years, maybe you don't have any nonconforming opinions.
- ncallaway 11y agoI run my own (self-funded) company, so I haven't been subject to hiring or funding in a few years. I wouldn't be shocked if a future client held our espoused opinions against us. I tend to strongly stand by any opinions that I advocate for publicly, and I'm willing to handle the repercussions from those opinions. If I felt the repercussions of those opinions were disproportionate I would advocate for those opinions anonymously. The ability to espouse unpopular opinions is the main reason why I strongly advocate for allowing anonymous speech.
- tomjen3 11y agoAnd if you make your own space online, then what happens when you lose your job because you were a member/founder of offensive side X? Heck, look at how much bullshit the Reddit founders have had to wade though?
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoWe're now going to have to deal with more outrage-as-a-weapon-to-silence-opponents. I wonder how the outraged would feel if it was, say, religious conservatives getting so upset that the organizers de-invited LGBT speakers.
- protomyth 11y agoInstitutional Endorsement versus Heckler's Veto makes for some interesting situations. I often wonder what would happen if an organizer going with the Heckler's Veto published all the "please remove this person" communication.
- saryant 11y agoThis incident reminds me of growing up as the son of an oil company's PR man in the Bay Area. We lived in one of the small towns in the North Bay. My father handled public and government relations for the oil refinery in that small town. A contingent of the opposition was especially vocal in their distaste for the plant. An orthodontist refused to take me on as a patient due to my father's job. Snide remarks from teachers were normal (but the school district relied on the refinery's charitable contributions—which my father controlled—so they had to play nice). Parents telling their kids they couldn't hang out at our house. There is a certain type of extremist who is unable to separate public and private lives and believes attacks on both are equally valid in advancing their agendas. We were glad to leave the state.
- whatucantsay1 11y agoThat sucks. "Horizontal Censorship" is definitely on the rise: http://pando.com/2015/02/04/the-geometry-of-censorship-and-satire/ http://pando.com/2015/02/04/the-geometry-of-censorship-and-s...
- leereeves 11y agoWhat kind of extremist attacks a child because of their father's political views?
- saryant 11y agoThe kind that lives in Benicia, CA. And recruiters wonder why I refuse to consider offers back in California.
- shalmanese 11y agoWhat kind of person stereotypes an entire state of 40 million people based on their experiences in one small town?
- PopeOfNope 11y agoThe kind that uses logic and reason instead of rhetorical appeals to emotion. The 'personal is the political' is part of the culture in california and is common throughout the state. And if you don't believe me, you should go on a job hunt and tell every interviewer who talks to you that you're a republican. Now that I think about it, I want to do just that and document the results. Should be interesting.
- Afforess 11y agoWhat outcomes do actions like this encourage? Well, it encourages controversial writers to stay in the shadows, hide their real identities, lest the vigilante mobs find them. This outcome also encourages people in general to say less, creates an atmosphere of self-censorship, and so harms our free society. Whatever happened to "I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it."? If we can not learn to tolerate others and respect their opinions, even those we find distasteful or deplorable, we will reap the consquences, and stagnate as a culture.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoIt also encourages the outraged to try to silence their ideological opponents.
- PopeOfNope 11y ago> Whatever happened to "I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it."? Marxism happened. Limiting speech has always been a tactic employed by the political left. Words like "racist", "sexist" and "homophobe" were designed to shut down free speech. It's extremely effective at silencing any opposition.
- overgard 11y agoYou're getting unfairly downvoted, but you're right: whether you agree with their ideas or not, the main tactic of the left is to police what topics are "appropriate" and marginalize those who are "inappropriate" with a label. I'm mostly apolitical so I'm not particularly outraged by this, but I wish they'd just own what they do. If they really think their ideas stand up, they should be welcoming opposition rather than trying to silence it.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoJust curious why you say that is the "main tactic of the left"?
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pixelperfect 11y agoI am curious, could someone link to the most objectionable content by Curtis Yarvin? I don't think prohibiting someone from speaking at a private tech conference due to offensive views is necessarily a bad thing (e.g. prohibiting a KKK member from speaking), however without seeing his objectionable content I don't know if it's appropriate in this circumstance. Alex Miller said he made his decision without reading any of Curtis's content, and I don't think that's a good idea. Otherwise any group loud enough could get anyone blocked from speaking, regardless of whether they did anything wrong.
- paxdickinson 11y agoThose calling for his removal from the conference cited this six-year-old blog post about Thomas Carlyle as their only specific complaint. http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/07/why-carlyle-matters.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/07/why-car...
- steveklabnik 11y agoThis is factually not true, and since you claim to have read my complaints, this comment appears disingenuous. More specifically, I linked http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/ http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/ and http://techcrunch.com/2013/11/22/geeks-for-monarchy/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/11/22/geeks-for-monarchy/ as a brief introduction if you don't want to wade through the torrent of Dark Enlightenment shenanigans.
- overgard 11y agoWhy does it matter what his political beliefs entail on a technical subject? More to the point, while I'm guessing you didn't dox him or whatever, the fact that he wrote under a pseudonym and (as a person having read his blog) had no idea of his actual name, I get the impression you went out of your way on this one. I don't really care about right or left (I think both sides are idiotic), but it seems like you're going out of your way on this one.
- antics 11y agoI recently helped organize a conference. Since it is apparently not obvious to many people, I'd just like to point out that amongst conference organizers, it is an extremely common belief that your primary responsibility is to deliver a good conference experience to your conference-goers. This is not just a belief StrangeLoop holds -- it is a belief that many beloved tech conferences have (e.g., PyCon), and if you think this can't happen at your conference, you are likely in for a surprise when/if something rough happens to that venue. In fact, this claim is stronger than you might think. This belief is prominently reflected in pretty much every decision every conference makes. People choose codes of conduct to deliberately exclude some people and certain behavior. They make you "apply" to go to their conferences so that they can hand-pick attendees to fit whatever criteria they have for their crowds (e.g., xoxo). People select talks and their speakers to fit profiles they want. And so on. I can name on my hand the number of people I've met who organize conferences, who believe their job is to provide a fair platform ideas. It's just not the way people seem to think.
- devalier 11y agoIt would be fine to ban Curtis if his talk was about his politics. It would be fine to ban him if he did not agree to abide by the code of conduct. The conference obviously does not owe him a platform to discuss his politics. But his talk was about Urbit, not about his politics, and Urbit is a genuinely fascinating piece of technology. Even if the project fails, by studying it, I have learned a lot of ideas that I have applied to my own programming. So there are two big issues with the ban. First, Alex made the conference worse for all those who cared about technology and not politics. Second, he's given the PC-police a scalp. This will make it much harder for anyone to write good-faith but politically incorrect critiques even under a pseudonym, for fear that it could harm career prospects in the future. And how are we supposed to correct problems in society if we cannot talk honestly about them? Most solutions to our problems are outside the Overton window - if they weren't we would have solved the problems already. Now maybe Alex wishes to cater to the more thin-skinned in his audience, rather than the technologists. That his prerogative. But I hope that other conference organizers do not follow suit, and I hope that true technologists in turn shun StrangeLoop for conferences that care about technology first, and instead attend conferences that refuse to ban innovators who haven't violated the code of conduct.
- twoodfin 11y agoAs of 12:30pm EDT, this has been flagged down to #111. Some people really don't want to discuss this.
- devalier 11y agoI think posts with a high ratio of comments to up-votes automatically get buried. So I'm not sure that this was deliberately moderated, or it was just the automated flame-war detection being set off.
- twoodfin 11y agoThat's too bad, because I'd like everyone to read your longer comment here. Just so strange to me that this decision isn't spurring more discussion. urbit-related posts have hit the front page with 100+ up votes in the past.
- jessaustin 11y agoYeah if one wants a discussion like this to stay above water, then upvote the post but don't comment on it. But actually it's probably OK if stuff like this drops off the front page, because it's inherently more political than other subjects.
- to3m 11y agoThink of it as you might a ban on discussing religion and/or politics when dining with people you don't know especially well. Less an attack on MAH FREEDMS, more a simple means of keeping the peace. You may complain that this will give rise to nothing but an echo chamber - and that's possibly true, but I fail to see how it's any worse than the alternative ;)
- twoodfin 11y agoBut this doesn't really involve politics as traditionally understood. Nobody here is particularly interested in defending Yarvin's views, AFAIK. But for an active HN user working on a project right in HN's wheelhouse to effectively be banned from presenting at Strange Loop (for violating what policy?)... It's a fascinating story with broad implications for how we interact with each other. Overall, disappointed in those who have flagged these posts.
- corporealist 11y agoAlex Payne founded a socialist blog: https://www.jacobinmag.com/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/ Why is writing about certain political ideas OK, but writing about certain other political ideas not OK? Why are those certain other political ideas "not OK" enough for someone to be banned from a technology conference?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- steveklabnik 11y agoIt would seem from this blog post, he joined the advisory board, but was not a founder: https://al3x.net/2015/03/03/jacobin.html https://al3x.net/2015/03/03/jacobin.html
- sagichmal 11y ago> Why is writing about certain political ideas OK, but > writing about certain other political ideas not OK? Calling socialism and racism the same thing, just a "certain political view", is about as intellectually honest as calling speeding and murder the same thing, just a "certain sort of crime".
- corporealist 11y agoHas anyone produced evidence of racism? Most of his detractors on Twitter have been beyond hysterical yet I doubt most of them have read anything he's written, and I've yet to see any examples. What is wrong with people that the presence of Curtis Yarvin makes them feel unsafe? EDIT: This seems to be the one example that is being bandied about: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9676625 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9676625 . Replies to that post point out that the case is extremely flimsy. Give me a break. This guy is a rightwinger (outside of his industry) and somebody didn't like it. What an embarrassment. They're proving the right's points.
- ShardPhoenix 11y agoYou're right - socialism is much worse than racism. Socialism (actual socialism, not "social democracy" aka capitalist welfare state) destroys countries (eg North Korea), while racism is merely a moderate problem (eg South Korea is very racist but doing fine). edit: To be fair, people are probably more sensitive to racism in America because America is so diverse.
- corporealist 11y agoAlex Payne founded a socialist blog: https://www.jacobinmag.com/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/ Why is writing about certain political ideas OK, but writing about certain other political ideas not OK? Why are those certain other political ideas "not OK" enough for someone to be banned from a technology conference?
- lkrubner 11y agoAn analogy can be made here to the famous case of Michael Servetus. Please note that I am not saying that Curtis Yarvin is the most important scientist of our era. I'm not suggesting that Curtis Yarvin is necessarily of unusual brilliance. He could easily be wrong regarding all of his political writing. This is just an analogy. Servetus had a lot of unusual ideas. He was a fantastic medical researcher, and, in 1533, he was the first to publish the idea that the heart was the center of a circulatory system, which pumped blood throughout the body. He also decided the Doctrine Of The Trinity (that the Father, the Son, and Holy Ghost were 3 aspects of one god) was entirely false. Therefore he was arrested and put to death, and thus Europe lost one of the greatest medical researchers of the 1500s. You might ask, what is the connection between the pulmonary system, and the the Doctrine Of The Trinity? There is none, save that creative people tend to have original ideas in several areas. If you want the benefits that derive from allowing creative people to have original thoughts, you have to also pay the price, and the price is that they sometimes have ideas that make people uncomfortable. Where 2 subjects overlap, such as math and computer programming, then a grave error in one area might call into question a person's expertise in that other subject. But where 2 subjects do not overlap, then errors in one area do not necessarily bring into question the person's expertise in the unrelated subject. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Servetus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Servetus
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoI don't think Curits Yarvin is going to be put to death for his rather far right political beliefs. That you'd compare him to Servetus is...well, rather ridiculous TBH.
- lukev 11y agoIt is germane to point out that it isn't simply "political" writing or blogging. Moldbug has several essays that are explicitly racist, and though he would no doubt dispute the relationship, the vocabulary and arguments he uses are virtually the same as those of modern Nazis. Strangeloop, in the past, has explicitly tried to foster a minority-friendly environment. Many of the other speakers are from minority groups. It's easy to see that having a speaker with Moldbug's history would do irreparable damage to what Alex has been trying to do. You can still disagree with the decision, but that at least is the context in which it was made. It isn't just that he's politically conservative or holds to some unusual opinion - he has literally written that several of his co-speakers are genetically more fit to be slaves while he, a white male, is genetically designed to be a master. I don't blame Alex for wanting to avoid that dynamic at his conference. Call it "culture fit", if you must. Can't he have the culture he wants at his conference?
- obstinate 11y agoPersonally I'm cool with conferences banning out-of-the-closet racists from speaking. I guess that makes me the minority on HN. /shrug. So be it.
- ossreality 11y agoYeah, maybe we should make this more clear. Sign your name here if you're fine with providing a platform for racists: [] and enter it into the public record.
- k_brother 11y agoCould you provide citations for those posts? This is the first I have heard of either Curtis or Moldbug, and I'm having trouble seeing the connection you're drawing. However, it seems to be the consensus. [edit: I see that there are secondary sources — but I'm curious about a primary source. Shouldn't that be the most important?]
- obstinate 11y agoGoogle is helpful here. There are plenty of articles that have been written about him (speaking as someone else who hadn't heard of him until today). This is the one I'm reading right now: http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/ http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/mouthbreathing-machiavellis/
- overgard 11y agoI'm sort of baffled by this: why would anyone care if he's giving a tech talk? It reminds me of the Brendan Eich situation. I disagree with his political views, but also.. who gives a shit? It's immaterial to the job. I used to read moldbug and I thought he was really incisive for a while, but his blog kept getting more and more, uh, esoteric. (basically unreadable -- it got hard to figure out what point he was even trying to make) All the same though, I don't really care about moldbug's political affiliations in a tech talk, I'd rather just hear what he has to say. (Also: how many attendees would even really know who he was or care enough to protest it?)
- al3x 11y agoThere were a number of people who voiced their objections on Twitter. It's easy to ask the rhetorical question here, but if you really want an answer, go check out what they said. In particular, people who represent groups that Moldbug treats as subhuman in his writing expressed concern and dismay. Perhaps looking through their eyes for a moment might illuminate why a person would care.
- overgard 11y agoOk but, letting a person speak isn't implicit approval of all their viewpoints. And if his talk is about tech, his political motivations aren't even relevant. I could see the motivation if like, he was going to bring in a wild group of radicals from his appearance or something and that would be disruptive, but as far as I know his viewpoints are pretty fringe.
- al3x 11y ago"Letting a person speak" isn't the only impact of inviting that person to your event, particularly an event that facilitates social gatherings and an ongoing dialogue between its attendees. If we just wanted to exchange information as efficiently as possible, we wouldn't bother with the time and expense of in-person conferences. The event provides a social context, and that's why we put so much monetary and cultural value on attendance in comparison to, say, sitting at home and reading an academic paper or a blog post.
- tptacek 11y agoIsn't Urbit named for the Mencius Moldbug blog, whose writer repeatedly refers to same as "UR"? How distinct is Urbit and Yarvin from the advocacy of the Moldbug UR blog? The association between Yarvin and that blog isn't exactly cryptic; for instance, Yarvin has given somewhat recent video-recorded talks espousing many of the same ideas as the blog, purposefully and in some depth. Is it possible that the most boring interpretation of facts is once again correct? That Urbit itself is a relatively obscure project with very few users and was accepted to Strange Loop as a sort of, "huh, interesting" kind of thing, by a panel not fully acquainted with "Moldbug"? And that once they were more fully informed of what Yarvin stands for, the costs of giving him a stage outweighed the benefits? Talk proposals aren't binary things. Program committees weigh pros and cons for most submissions. Some of them are so clearly important that they'd get in no matter how outre' their authors politics are. But it seems like it'd take some retconning to suggest that Urbit is that kind of subject.
- steveklabnik 11y agoI have at least attempted to be _very_ clear that I do not begrudge the organizers of this conference for exactly the reason that you say. Your 'boring interpretation' lines up with my understanding of the situation. As has been said many times in this thread, Yarvin is free to say what he believes, and I am free to say what I believe, and organizers are allowed to do what they want. This is how a free market of ideas is supposed to work.
- politicalhn4tw 11y agoYou have argued to suppress Yarvin's ideas in one realm based on his unrelated ideas in another realm. This is emphatically not how the free market of ideas is supposed to work.
- krapp 11y ago>This is emphatically not how the free market of ideas is supposed to work. I don't think you appreciate what the "free" in "free market" refers to...
- colinhb 11y agoAll I long for is logical consistency and empathy... Various comments from the discussion: > Whatever happened to "I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it."? Getting dis-invited from a tech conference is not losing the right to say anything. The state is not punishing Yarvin for his speech. Giving a talk at a private tech conferences is not a right protected by anyone. > Kicking people from your tech conference because they were racist outside of it hands veto power to whoever determines what racism is and when something is 'too racist'. I'll defend Alex's right to organize a conference. You are free to organize another conference. (More generally, the market of conferences will decide whether Alex is doing a bad job.) > In the end, if you're a straight white male, you will fall prey to it because you're not a protected class. You can see this playing out in video games, movies and SF&F publishing right now. If you are a straight white man, accept that the world isn't perfect (you suffer the consequences of being a member of an identifiable group) and count yourself lucky that you don't have to face the other (often deadlier) forms of oppression faced by other groups. > My personal opinions would get me called racist, sexist and homophobic by Marxist standards and I was exhausted by the political mask I had to assume just to find and keep work. I imagine it was a lot easier to wear that political mask than it would have been to change your skin-color, gender, or age. Your way in the tech industry will be quite difficult if you get any of those wrong.
- escape_goat 11y agoI think your counter-arguments are very bad. I thank you for sharing them here, because I don't think they reflect uncommon opinions at all, and I think they are too easily accepted without reflection. With regards to the "defend to the death your right to say it" hyperbole, I agree that it is overstated. Furthermore, it is true that getting dis-invited from a tech conference does not involve losing the right to say anything; nor is the state punishing speech. However, it would be an error to overlook the fact that speech is being punished. Yarvin would have been welcome at the conference had he not revealed his racist opinions in [what was intended to be] an unrelated forum. Those opinions revealed, he was unwelcome, without (as far as I can tell) any particular reference to his actual public behaviour. So as a practical matter, if the conference's reaction should be considered normative and appropriate, he had a right to say things... unless he wanted a career. Now, you may well wish to argue that this reaction should indeed be normative and correct. However, I am not sure that you would be as comfortable with your actual words in another context. We could be discussing this in Russia in the 1950s, for instance, and agreeing that Yarvin shouldn't have kept his jewish-sounding last name if he wanted a career, or got forbid spoken about his anti-socialist economic views. In such a case, our circumstances would have been very different, of course, and it is incredibly easy to draw broad distinctions between counter-factual racist fantasies and failing to disguise one's ethnic background. But the mechanism is the same, and here you are stating an indifference to --- defending, even --- the mechanism. Another commentator writes that "kicking people out of your conference hands veto power to whomever determines what racism is and when something is racist." It seems to me that if a popular arbiter of opinion about racism could mobilize a grassroots reaction against racism as they saw it, when they saw it, and when they felt like it; and if that grassroots reaction probably would not have occurred without their instigation: under those circumstances, this assertion would come quite close to being true. Again, this is not something peculiar to racism, or fighting against racism, or any particular political struggle at all. It is a mechanism whereby interest groups influence the direction of public discourse and policy. Yet here --- despite the certainty that there are interest groups using such tactics, somewhere in the world, whose views are pure anathema to you --- you are not actually defending the fight for social justice and inclusion; instead, you defend the mechanism. More realistically, I do not think that you intended to even do so much as that. Your reply at first reads as an announcement of indifference and antipathy to the author's concerns. A rejection of actual argumentation or discussion, in other words. (This itself, in case you might overlook it, is rather far from an inherently virtuous sort of response.) However, your parenthetical comment does attempt to justify the mechanism, and the comment is notable in that it specifically rejects the protection of actual minorities, instead embracing a "market" determination of right or wrong: in other words, the nature of a protected minority is to be determined by the opinion of the general majority. A third commentator complains about a sort of reverse-racism burden, in that the "straight white male" is doubly impacted, as both the target of discrimination, and as a target of discrimination who is not a member of "a protected class." I do not think that this is a very defensible argument. However, "accept that the world isn't perfect, and feel lucky you don't have it worse" is not any better. At risk of beating a dead horse, one must in general ask oneself if the response defends the structure or the substance of the allegedly discriminatory circumstance. I will assume you can predict my response to this as an argument defending the discriminatory structure. Insofar as the response is a defense of the substance of the circumstance, then it seems to be implicitly appealing for deference and calling for restitution, of sorts, in that a hardship should be accepted in recognition of the hardships of others. This is a very powerful and emotionally appealing argument... when made to address apparent discrimination that arises out of minority protection. The 'Why The "Safe Area" Of The [Women's/LGBT/Native] Center Is Not Discriminatory' speech would be the typical example, in my experience. Here, it is much less appealing, and also misses the point. Reading your response literally, one should infer that any member of an identifiable group ultimately needs to accept that "the world isn't perfect" and that they will face some degree of 'oppression'; they should protest against and fight that oppression only if it is too much oppression, or too deadly. I am almost certain that this is absolutely not something that you meant to say. I suspect that you meant to convey that you thought the commentator's experienced/feared discrimination was trivial and negligible. This would be fine, as a response, but the attempt to convert it into a self-evident, justified response on this basis is very weak, and I feel that the problem is that you are trying to do the easy thing rather than the hard thing, and to end argument or dialog rather than invite it. "You can see this playing out in video games..." really? Straight white men are falling prey to reverse discrimination in video games? I would love to hear the commentator attempt to justify this view. It would be satisfactory enough, I think, to simply end discussion by responding that "this is ridiculous unless you feel like making a cogent argument to the contrary." Instead, however, you let it slide completely: you even accept the premise. I feel that if you were not intent on justifying [reverse] discrimination (because it is reverse[1]), and instead were concerned about discrimination period, you would not have missed the opportunity to talk about what does or does not constitute discrimination --- let alone missed the fact that this is a ridiculous, indefensible imagination of what discrimination is. Finally, the commentator who writes that "my personal opinions would get me called racist, sexist, and homophobic by Marxist standards and I was exhausted by the political mask I had to assume just to find and keep work." Again, structure, substance, escape_goat goes on for a paragraph or two here in a now-predictable manner, let's skip to the good part... suffering. You are responding to someone reporting a sense of alienation and mental exhaustion specifically because they had to wear a 'mask' in the workplace. Your response is that you imagine that it was a lot easier for them to wear that mask than it would be for them to change their skin color, or gender, or age. This seems obviously true, as those are very difficult things to change. It is also true that these visible, physical qualities have created barriers in the tech industry. But it leaves begging the question of whether anyone should be required to wear a mask, and under what circumstances. Is it wrong to discriminate against co-workers on the basis of the color of their skin, but not wrong to feel uncomfortable around them if they act "too black"? Is it okay to create a "non-homophobic" environment and then fire people for revealing their sexual orientation? I am thinking that perhaps there are some circumstances where you would not find "it's easier to wear a mask" to be a satisfactory response at all. Even though, yes, it's easier to wear a mask. Similar to the case of the third commentator, but more problematically, your response is clearly predicated against the complainant because of their (white, straight, male) identity and whatever mixture of personal emotions, political views, or what-have-you that makes someone fear that their views would be seen as racist, sexist, or homophobic by 'Marxists'. Again, the central, crucial abstract question (should anyone feel this alienated in the workplace?) and the difficult, complicated particular questions (why does this person, as an individual, feel so alienated, and are those feelings justified; do they reflect a work environment that unknowingly makes rigid ideological demands; do they reflect mental health issues; could this person comfortably work with a black/gay/female co-worker [which of these] without 'wearing a mask'; would a black/gay/female co-worker be able to work with them; would the situation be altered by empathy training, counselling, mediation; and so on...) These go unanswered. And this is your response to someone's actual personal suffering, so one must infer that you do not oppose discrimination because it causes human suffering. If there is a different, justifiable basis for opposing discrimination, then you should be straightforwards about that, as this would be the most crucial aspect of your response by far. [1] An oscillatory model of discriminatory impulses resulting in the balanced distribution of prejudice floats into my mind when I say this.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoIs that guy still a thing?
- sudioStudio64 11y agoWhat I mean was that I hadn't heard anything about the Neo-reactionaries for over a year! Damn it with the downvotes!
- late2part 11y agoI wonder how many of the conference goers use reiserfs or its derivatives.
- chrismcb 11y agoI want to make sure I understand the situation. A conference, designed to disseminate information, choose the best talks among those that entered. But one of the speakers has some beliefs that so e conference attendees do not share. These beliefs have nothing to do with the talk. So the conference choose to dismiss one of the top selections, meaning knowledge so etching perceived as good won't be shared. Because a few people didn't like the guy? Isn't this a disservice to the other attendees who might have wanted to hear the talk? Doesn't this mean the conference is less than what it could have been?
- mtraven 11y agoSome commentary: http://omniorthogonal.blogspot.com/2015/06/moldbuggery.html http://omniorthogonal.blogspot.com/2015/06/moldbuggery.html The first link there offers a theory of how nerd culture interacts (or tries to avoid interacting) with politics to produce things like libertarianism and neoreaction.
- lexcorvus 11y agoIn the context of views that are potentially odious but are tolerated in technology, it's perhaps worth noting that two of the instigators of this decision [1, 2] are respectively an avowed communist [3] and a socialist who serves on the board of a magazine that literally takes its name from the people who brought us the Reign of Terror [4]. Should they be barred from speaking at conferences because people might feel "unsafe" in the presence of someone who holds such views? Or should we learn to leave politics at the door, and be willing to listen to tech talks even from people whose politics we find repulsive? I for one endorse the latter view. Strange Loop is entitled to its decision, but I find it both craven and sad. [1]: https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/606219754513264640 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/606219754513264640 [2]: https://al3x.net/2015/06/04/wouldn't-censorship-be-exciting.html https://al3x.net/2015/06/04/wouldn't-censorship-be-exciting.... [3]: http://blog.steveklabnik.com/posts/2011-12-15-marx-anarchism-and-web-standards http://blog.steveklabnik.com/posts/2011-12-15-marx-anarchism... [4]: https://al3x.net/2015/03/03/jacobin.html https://al3x.net/2015/03/03/jacobin.html
- hga 11y agoAnd [1, 3], in reference to explicitly violent European "antifascists", in the context of a "sorely needed" but inchoate as of last October "tech antifa[scist]" movement, is "100% okay with that, personally."(https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/523497129772613632 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/523497129772613632). I assure you that people of the right like me feel "unsafe" about the presence of people like them in American society, and I wonder if they've thought about the consequences of that, of their programs in general, etc. I see no way for this to end well.
- danielHanniger 11y agoAll this shows is that Moldbug and others are exactly right about the tech industry. It is a cesspool of neo-Bolshevist Prog political correctness, rather than somewhere in which people's talent is paramount. Liberals believe that history favors them always. Within this century, we'll see if that hypothesis is correct. The geopolitical death of the West will be the end of this wretched ideology, just as the geopolitical death of the east was the death of Marxism.
- lissencarak 11y agoHaving a Department of Political Police, or policing yourself makes no difference. You are still curtailing somebody's right to the free market of ideas because of "hurt feels". And even if you have the right to do so, it is still wrong.
- danhess00 11y agoMany people smugly note that the Constitution only stops the state from punishing speech. Private parties are free to do whatever they want (including blacklisting the speakers), and those silly free speech defenders are confusing the state with private parties. But that misses the bigger point, which is that the Constitutional guarantee originates from the principle that free exchange of ideas is a social good. The founders believed in free speech because they believed in enlightenment and in pursuit of truth. They were unafraid of ideas. These blacklisters fundamentally have an anti-enlightenment mentality, as they have elegantly shown. Yarvin's most basic point in his writings was not that different people are different (this is so obvious that truthful people do not dispute it, although the anti-enlightenment types find it convenient for trying witches), but that the modern Left polices against heresy with the rigor of the Christian church of the long ago past. It is fitting then that events in Yarvin's life should form a well-publicized proof of his main point.
- Infinite_Light 11y agoThe incentives facing event organizers are quite bad. If only one side throws a fit then non-martyr event organizers will normally capitulate to their demands. Its hard to align the incentives without suggesting people on the free speech side act like the SJ types.