4 ms·
There's a lot of rationalization and sophistry in that article, but this was the most egregious: > Self-disgust and lifelong unhappiness, destroying a precious
by notacoward 11y ago
There's a lot of rationalization and sophistry in that article, but this was the most egregious:
> Self-disgust and lifelong unhappiness, destroying a precious young life
Even if we accept all the rest, this part is ridiculous. There are plenty of jobs that pay better than writing and don't induce self-disgust, and even the worst jobs generally aren't likely to destroy a lifetime. Plenty of people endure a few years e.g. of military service, even though they don't enjoy it, and then move on to completely different things that they find more fulfilling. The author seems to think that nothing other than writing is an acceptable career choice, and that he has an absolute entitlement to such a career. What total bollocks.
There are plenty of problems with our college-loan system, but the fact that Lee Siegel can't make good choices is a problem only with Lee Siegel.
- gregd 11y agoIt's relatively easy to sit on the sidelines of someone's life and compare the choices they've made, to your own, especially when we're aware of the consequences after the fact. What isn't so easy is to admit to yourself, that not everybody has the same choices available to them as you.
- notacoward 11y agoOh, I'm well aware of that, but thanks for the ad hominem. I came from a background no more privileged than his. I had to make some hard choices, which among other things is why I don't even have a degree. I'm sure Lee Siegel had different opportunities and different aptitudes than I did, but those don't seem to have been the dominant factors here. Even with those opportunities and aptitudes, a better attitude would have allowed a better outcome without the need for a loan default. He wasn't willing to compromise on his choice of college or his choice of a first job. Other people who do make such compromises often do just fine, and eventually get into the career they wanted, despite an equal level of opportunity or aptitude. It's unfair that some people have to make such compromises while others don't. I've written plenty about that. Nonetheless, those who choose poorly deserve no sympathy from those who were faced with the same or equivalent choices and still managed to do the right thing.
- gregd 11y agoAd hominem? Really? How do you know he hasn’t made any hard choices? As I stated, it’s relatively easy to sit on the sidelines and have the benefits of hindsight, to call someone out on their choices. What’s unfair is the absurd cost of college and why it’s primary ethos has been to make money.
- notacoward 11y agoWhen you tried to imply that I had "sat on the sidelines" that was ad hominem. It suggests that I'm unqualified to have an opinion, which is not only inherently fallacious but also absurd in light of how closely my own experience actually does match that of the author. Next time, instead of making assumptions and then using them to undermine the source of a statement, try addressing the statement itself.
- gregd 11y agoI wasn't suggesting that you were unqualified to have an opinion. We are all sitting on the sidelines of each others lives. I am no more a part of your life, than you are of mine. But what I was suggesting is that it’s easy for us to sit in judgment of the choices he articulated, as well as the outcomes of those choices, and say that he, “can’t make good choices”. It doesn’t matter what you think your background was in comparison to his. You’re still projecting your reality and the outcomes of your reality, onto another complete stranger and coming to negative conclusions about his life. I call this judgment. Each of our lives is nuanced enough to affect outcomes even given very similar circumstances or “choices” as you call them. Because Siegel’s outcomes ended in him defaulting on his student loans and articulating that, doesn’t mean he can’t make good choices.
- notacoward 11y agoConflating circumstances and choices is absurd. Siegel's default wasn't the inevitable result of circumstances. It was a choice. Whatever the outcome, he can't deny agency. He can't say it was all somebody else's fault, and that he only did what he had to do. He had to do one of several things, and he chose one. Millions of people, none of them in identical circumstances but statistically close enough, made different choices and had those choices work out fine, without the life of self-loathing Siegel predicted for himself if he had chosen differently. That prediction was convenient, but ill-founded in fact.