4 ms·
People are complicated, and are at least somewhat irrational. So polling is hard, and is prone to bias and manipulation. But two observations are solid. First,
by mirimir 11y ago
People are complicated, and are at least somewhat irrational. So polling is hard, and is prone to bias and manipulation. But two observations are solid. First, most people are entirely clueless about technical matters. Second, most people believe that meaningful privacy is either impossible or unworkably complicated.
I recall discussion from the mid 90s, as ad-funded commercialization of the Internet accelerated, about impact on privacy. I'm not arguing that there was much privacy in the early Internet. But privacy was another available path. Now there's meaningful privacy only on the alleys and back roads of the Internet.
I don't have any answers. But I do know that meaningful privacy is incompatible with the current ad-funded Internet. Maybe there's a workable way to deindividualize tracking data. Maybe anonymous blockchain nanopayments would work as an alternative. Google ought to take the lead on this, I think.
- gizmo686 11y agoIs ad funded and and privacy really incompatible. For example, radio is a largely ad funded medium, but the technology is inherently private. Tracking might make adds more valuable, but they are not worthless. Especially if you condisder that adviters could still do the type of content driven targeting that they have done on previus mediums (that is to say, it is not a privacy violation to say that the readers of a particular piece of content are interested in that type of content).
- mirimir 11y agoMaybe so. Maybe Internet advertising developed with tracking simply because tracking was so easy, and wasn't not prohibited. So there's strong selection for accurate tracking. But that doesn't say that privacy-friendly advertising is impossible. I do get that it's naive to ask Google etc to take the lead. They're just doing what's rational in the current regulatory environment. But who can create Internet-wide incentives?
- mirimir 11y ago... and wasn't prohibited ...