4 ms·
I suspect you are being downvoted because you are not arguing very well. "There are only two viable business models" - and then you admit a third, and a fourth
by dsr_ 11y ago
I suspect you are being downvoted because you are not arguing very well.
"There are only two viable business models" - and then you admit a third, and a fourth, and claim that they are exceptions. There can't possibly be a fifth? There can't be a sixth that someone will invent next year and become the dominant mode of funding digital publishing?
You claim a moral right for web sites to show you ads, but no equivalent moral right for people to use programs to ignore the ads. That's inconsistent, and also morally abhorrent to many people.
Finally, you say that you "don't agree with using adblock but I do consider the reasons valid" -- that appears to be another inconsistency. If ad blocking is immoral, there can't be any reasoning which will overwhelm your moral objections.
Perhaps you are using the word "moral" in an unusual fashion?
- manigandham 11y ago1) There are only two viable business models today. The exceptions are not viable; just because a few can do it doesn't mean they can be used for the mainstream. And I didnt say there can't be more nor was I implying it since I talk about possible future alternatives - it's just reality today only has 2. When more show up and actually prove to work, then there will be more. 2) Both options in a moral argument cant be moral. I don't think it's moral for people to use programs to tamper with what a content provider has given you in exchange for providing that content (which they have full rights to) for free. The usage of the programs isnt the issue, it's what and how it's used for. Modifying a site to make text bigger is fine for example, modifying it to circumvent the advertising explicitly is morally wrong. 3) The reasons why people want to block ads are fine. Most people want more performance, security and privacy. Adblock and it's blunt approach of blocking everything as well as the extortion businesses run by the adblocking companies is immoral. Wanting something and doing it are different, as well as the method. I'm arguing that adblocking as a method is wrong. 4) I'm not sure what other word I could use... it's based on principals since it's not law or hard rules, unless you count breaking terms of use on sites. But it seems nobody cares about those so morality seems to cover all of it.
- throwawaykf05 11y ago> You claim a moral right for web sites to show you ads, but no equivalent moral right for people to use programs to ignore the ads. That's inconsistent, and also morally abhorrent to many people. It's not inconsistent. People have a right to ask for whatever they think their product is worth. And people have just as much as a right to turn down the deal if they find it unacceptable. But people do not have a right to just go ahead and consume the product if they find the asking price unreasonable. The latter seems more morally abhorrent to me.