10 ms·
The Online Privacy Lie Is Unraveling
- higherpurpose 11y agoExactly what I've been saying about the NSA mass surveillance issue. It's not that many people are "okay with it" but that they don't truly understand what's going on. If 1 in 2 people don't even realize their supermarket data is shared with others, how can we expect them to easily understand that the NSA is actually collecting their "dick pics" as well as everything else, including GPS locations, 3G tower locations, and so on? I strongly believe if most people actually understood what was going on, they'd be much more upset about it. There's a reason why "tech people" are much more upset about it. It's not because they're "nerds" or anti-social or what have you. It's because they actually understand what's happening and what can be done with all of that data. And they also pay attention to hacks like the recent OPM one, where the government proves itself to be completely incompetent in keeping our data safe, enforcing the idea that neither the government nor companies should keep too much data about us and for very long. If we could get "normal" people to have as much understanding about these privacy issues as tech people do, that could lead to some real privacy reforms.
- hackuser 11y ago> It's not that many people are "okay with it" but that they don't truly understand what's going on. Also it says that people who know feel powerless to do anything about it. What choice do they have, other than live in a cave?
- asuffield 11y agoYou can throw away your supermarket loyalty card, and stop getting those 2% discounts. You're not powerless. You're making a choice.
- dredmorbius 11y agoAs with other measures: show me that not using the card guarantees my privacy? The only thing that is guaranteed is that I've lost the discount. Recording accounts from credit, debit, or check payments leaves the customer equally screwed. More likely: I request loyalty cards under assumed names and discard or exchange them often. Though that likely leads to other data trails. Anonymisation and tradecraft are hard.
- wutbrodo 11y agoThis is absolutely preposterous. Scrubbing every single instance of data collection is obviously very difficult, but there are tons of high impact, low cost things you can do but that people choose not to do. That really belies the "people actually care but feel powerless" nonsense. For example: Browsing only in an incognito window prevents the persistence of many kinds of identity across browsing sessions, at the low cost of having to type a username and password more often. (I already do this for Facebook because their cookie policy passes my personal line. It's not a hardship at all, but that may be because when I have the power to change something I don't like I prefer doing it instead of simply whining and pretending I'm powerless). Not using a loyalty card prevents tracking of your purchases and the only cost is the loss of a two percent discount. Goimg to google's ad settings and turning off personalized ads. The cost is: ten seconds and seeing 10% more ads.
- dredmorbius 11y agoCounter-counterexample: EFF's Panopticlick shows how much individually identifying data can be obtained simply from browser fingerprints. IP address adds to that. Verizon was injecting tracking headers into its subscribers' Web traffic directly. Again: the problem with countermeasures is that you've got to take a hell of a lot of them before you've any real assurance of even modest privacy. See RMS's "How I do my computing" essay, featured here recently. https://stallman.org/stallman-computing.html https://stallman.org/stallman-computing.html
- wutbrodo 11y agoI did mention that "complete" privacy is rather costly, but I think it's silly to Ignore low cost countermeasures that have a high impact. Hell you can even defend against fingerprinting, which is basically a medium cost very high impact fix. https://panopticlick.eff.org/self-defense.php https://panopticlick.eff.org/self-defense.php I also disagree that the stated countermeasures don't have much of an impact. The universe of entities that get any sort of picture of your behavior narrows VERY sharply, and the remaining holdouts (the govt, those who control the pipes) quite obviously require policy solutions
- irishcoffee 11y agoHeh so, NSA didn't break the law then, people are just too buried in their iphones to care until asked? [Fun fact, POTUS could tell NSA to stop doing something (or anything) whenever they. 8 years, not a word. Information is power, if you are informed.]
- mirimir 11y agoAre you sure about that? At least some NSA efforts are buried deeply in need-to-know mazes. How can POTUS tell NSA to stop what he has no way of knowing about? And how would he know whether they had stopped?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ionised 11y agoThis is the argument I make when faced with the idea that people are 'okay' being spied on, as if it somehow justifies what the NSA is doing. It's not acceptance, it's ignorance of what is actually happening.
- hackuser 11y agoFor those considering whether to read it, it's a powerful statement on consumer acceptance of privacy trade-offs: Key findings on American consumers include that - - 91% disagree (77% of them strongly) that "If companies give me a discount, it is a fair exchange for them to collect information about me without my knowing" - 71% disagree (53% of them strongly) that "It’s fair for an online or physical store to monitor what I’m doing online when I’m there, in exchange for letting me use the store’s wireless internet, or Wi-Fi, without charge." - 55% disagree (38% of them strongly) that "It’s okay if a store where I shop uses information it has about me to create a picture of me that improves the services they provide for me." The authors go on to note that "only about 4% agree or agree strongly" with all three of the above propositions. And even with a broader definition of "a belief in tradeoffs" they found just a fifth (21%) were comfortably accepting of the idea.
- sliverstorm 11y agoTo me that says: - We REALLY don't like information gathering on the sly - We don't like blanket information gathering of everything I do - But we might be OK with information gathering that is directly related to my interaction with your business, and used in a positive way Which is relieving to me, as it seems like a very healthy attitude overall.
- asuffield 11y agoI am interested in whether, if you turned the questions around and asked questions like "I want to give up my grocery store discount in exchange for the company running the store not collecting information about me", you would get the same results. Those loyalty cards are completely opt-in, the way they are used is widely known, and out in the real world with money on the line, people turn out to say "yes, I want this". What does this tell us about the results of this survey?
- gnoway 11y agoThat it may illustrate the article's premise: while people know what's going on with data collection, they believe they are powerless to stop it. Or that we have a society where 5% off is so important that people are willing to give up their privacy to get it.
- hackuser 11y agoI think the argument that people accept it is disingenuous. If it was broadly acceptable, why would businesses and governments often hide what they are doing? Why wouldn't they clearly inform consumers up front? In fact, if consumers like it so much then why not advertise it, to attract more customers? Why haven't I seen this ad on TV? At Acme, we collect your personal information and build an intimate profile of you -- everything you do, from your emails and web usage, to who your friends and family are, to your income, wealth and debts, to your medical and driving histories, to your interests in culture, religion and politics. You'd be amazed by what we've learned about you! The more we know about you, the better we can serve you!
- XorNot 11y agoBecause people are irrational, and will give wildly different answers to fundamentally the same question, depending on the phrasing. Because the reality is, people's lives have been continuously improving as more personal data has been collected and aggregated about them by various services and that now, more then ever, the transparency and accountability of governments has increased in response to many of those exact same services (Twitter/YouTube/Facebook/Google). The metadata question gets asked contextlessly, which utterly changes its meaning. Google Now is pretty upfront (and obvious) of the type of data it's going to need to work. Given the value proposition, people are okay with that and why should they not be?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 11y ago> Because people are irrational So they shouldn't be empowered to make decisions for themselves? What 'rational' person will decide what is best for these people, as well as altruistically understand and protect their interests?
- jkestner 11y agoI like how Microsoft made a point with Cortana to put what it knows about the user in a "notebook" that you can browse and edit. Whenever it does something smart, like suggest that it track a flight, it lets you ask "How do you know this?" This doesn't make anything harder to use, just more transparent.
- zmmmmm 11y agoTries to make good points but indulged in so much hyperbole that I had to stop reading. Words like "stolen", "lie", "heist", etc. I do think there's a case to be made that online companies misrepresent to users how they deeply they track them and use their data. But going overboard and pretending that having somebody know some statistics about you in a de-identified and aggregated manner is some heinous invasion of your personal privacy equivalent to someone sitting with a spy camera watching you in your bathroom - that is completely unhelpful in the other direction. There's enormous genuine value in this kind of data. That is, mutual win-win value to consumers and end users and companies that learn to understand the data. At the extreme there are a whole range of diseases where the only real hope of curing them explicitly depends on us gathering enough data to find cures. At a much more subtle level, a rental car company knowing enough about its users to accurately predict when and where they are likely to want cars helps everyone and gets you cheaper prices and better availability. The problem at the moment is that this issue has become recognised as a way to attack advertising based internet companies and is thus being exploited by their competitors. Those competitors don't care whether the baby is thrown out with the bath water - in fact, if the baby goes all the better because it's not an area of strategic advantage for them. So they might as well sabotage all of it to get a bit of commercial advantage, and screw it if consumers and society are the worse off for it. We need to be cognisant that much of the heat around this is created by this being a commercial battle ground and the actual issues are much more nuanced and need more careful thought.
- skidoo 11y agoI think what tech companies do with information collected is absolutely no different from identity theft. They help themselves to quite a lot more than what any of their terms of service statements regard, and seem to be using said datum for increasingly nefarious aims. In that respect, terms like "stolen", "lie", "heist", etc, are wholly apropos.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hackuser 11y ago
- Zak 11y agoI'm a bit surprised by some of the mistaken consumer beliefs cited in the article. For example: > 65% do not know that the statement “When a website has a privacy policy, it means the site will not share my information with other websites and companies without my permission” is false. Do people really not understand that having a policy on a particular topic does not imply anything about the contents of said policy? > 55% do not know it is legal for an online store to charge different people different prices at the same time of day. Why would people expect there to be a law prohibiting this? It's no different (conceptually) from a small boutique shop that doesn't use price tags charging an enthusiastic student a lower price than a wealthy collector. For a more institutionalized example, membership in various organizations has provided unadvertised discounts on tangentially related products and services for a long time. > 62% do not know that price-comparison sites like Expedia or Orbitz are not legally required to include the lowest travel prices. Again, this shouldn't be surprising. They don't advertise that they show the lowest price. They're not even capable of guaranteeing that they show the lowest price, as some airlines won't share pricing data with them.
- jbuzbee 11y ago> 55% do not know it is legal for an online store to charge different people different prices... > 62% do not know that price-comparison sites like Expedia or Orbitz are not legally required... Statements like tell me that the survey was biased. It's making it seem like these companies are doing something that should be illegal when all they are doing is charging what the market will bear.
- nfoz 11y agoThere are many situations in which "charging what the market will bear" is illegal. We have legal price controls, and restrictions on what/how items can be sold, in many asset classes.
- seanp2k2 11y agoIf places can profit from operating in the margins where the law is shaky and they're unlikely to be challenged on their choices (risk vs reward), they probably will.
- mirimir 11y agoPeople are complicated, and are at least somewhat irrational. So polling is hard, and is prone to bias and manipulation. But two observations are solid. First, most people are entirely clueless about technical matters. Second, most people believe that meaningful privacy is either impossible or unworkably complicated. I recall discussion from the mid 90s, as ad-funded commercialization of the Internet accelerated, about impact on privacy. I'm not arguing that there was much privacy in the early Internet. But privacy was another available path. Now there's meaningful privacy only on the alleys and back roads of the Internet. I don't have any answers. But I do know that meaningful privacy is incompatible with the current ad-funded Internet. Maybe there's a workable way to deindividualize tracking data. Maybe anonymous blockchain nanopayments would work as an alternative. Google ought to take the lead on this, I think.
- gizmo686 11y agoIs ad funded and and privacy really incompatible. For example, radio is a largely ad funded medium, but the technology is inherently private. Tracking might make adds more valuable, but they are not worthless. Especially if you condisder that adviters could still do the type of content driven targeting that they have done on previus mediums (that is to say, it is not a privacy violation to say that the readers of a particular piece of content are interested in that type of content).
- mirimir 11y agoMaybe so. Maybe Internet advertising developed with tracking simply because tracking was so easy, and wasn't not prohibited. So there's strong selection for accurate tracking. But that doesn't say that privacy-friendly advertising is impossible. I do get that it's naive to ask Google etc to take the lead. They're just doing what's rational in the current regulatory environment. But who can create Internet-wide incentives?
- mirimir 11y ago... and wasn't prohibited ...
- EGreg 11y agoThat is why we invented this: http://www.faqs.org/bs/ad.iphone.php?r=%2Fpatents%2Fapp%2F20120110469 http://www.faqs.org/bs/ad.iphone.php?r=%2Fpatents%2Fapp%2F20... Bitcoin has solved distributed money. But distributed social networking is still a hard problem to solve. That's why people take what they can get. They host their own blogs with Wordpress, the web is distributed, but social networks are all centralized silos! But soon that will change. When http://platform.qbix.com http://platform.qbix.com hits 2.0 :)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 11y agoExcept for that "everything you buy goes on the perpetual record of the blockchain" bit. And the fact that the one anonymous transaction most ably facilitated by Bitcoin is fraud.
- indians_pro 11y agocan you elaborate on the second sentence?
- dredmorbius 11y agoMt. Gox, for example.
- shawnreilly 11y agoLet's build something to help solve this privacy problem. Who else is in?
- woutor 11y agoI'm in!
- shawnreilly 11y agoSend me an E-mail shawn.k.reilly@gmail.com and let's discuss
- indians_pro 11y agohow can an apprentice programmer (c++, python) help?
- shawnreilly 11y agoSend me an E-mail shawn.k.reilly@gmail.com and let's discuss
- dredmorbius 11y agoWhy do companies seek more information on customers? Read their own fucking marketing collateral. Companies aren't falling over themselves to grab every last piece of personal data available in order to push their own prices through the floor. Don't be ridiculous. They're doing it: ⚫ To find prospects who can't see their way out of a bad deal. ⚫ To find prospects who are highly inclined to spend. A wonderful Spanish proverb I discovered recently is "Buy from desperate people, and sell to newlyweds." Find those who absolutely need cash (even at pennies on the dollar) for their belongings, and buy from them. Find those with stars in their eyes, and sell to them. Look at the office furniture market: fire/liquidation sales (buy) and startups (sell). ⚫ To sow market confusion to the point that meaningful distinctions simply cannot be made. ⚫ To upsell, to increase conversions, to tack on additional fees, to tie people into service contracts. All that bullshit. Aon on Retail and Insurance: Retailers have a chance to improve operating margins by 60 percent, McKinsey projects. ... "Data has always been important in the underwriting process, but now the depth and breadth of available data has led to a dramatic increase in focus. The quality of data can be a key factor in securing coverage, in obtaining the best possible terms and conditions, and in setting equitable premiums. On behalf of our clients, we collect and collate data that we then present to insurance markets and use as a negotiating tool. http://one.aon.com/putting-big-data-work?page=2 http://one.aon.com/putting-big-data-work?page=2 Pitched at small biz: Based on the purchase behavior information you gathered from your sales receipts, you could consider running a few targeted seasonal promotions to capitalize on the behaviors you’ve observed. For example, if people year after year tend to buy similar products during a particular month, then consider running a promotion to further incentivize that specific product during that time of year. http://www.businessknowhow.com/internet/data.htm http://www.businessknowhow.com/internet/data.htm IBM on MidSize business: Analytics can turn this “big data” into the kind of insight that enables companies to stand apart. In fact, analytics will be a deciding factor that determines whether companies succeed or fail. Those able to effectively tap data for game-changing insights can capitalize on virtually endless opportunities. http://www.ibm.com/midmarket/us/en/business-analytics.html http://www.ibm.com/midmarket/us/en/business-analytics.html Using SAS software (a large enterprise analytic platform): Using SAS solutions, we combine above median usage metrics – recency, depth, duration, high value content – with other online conversions to identify a customer acquisition opportunity or trigger alerts for our current customer marketing efforts.... By enhancing outbound nurture emails with web behavior and topics of interest, you become more proficient with your targeting.... http://blogs.sas.com/content/customeranalytics/2014/05/30/why-big-data-analytics-is-digital-marketings-best-friend/ http://blogs.sas.com/content/customeranalytics/2014/05/30/wh... Borrowed from a response of mine to ex-Googler Chris Medina earlier this year: https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/dqqT25xAFtc https://plus.google.com/104092656004159577193/posts/dqqT25xA...
- dredmorbius 11y agoA flipside of this is that there's no general guarantee that not participating in such services affords much by way of protection. You're already creating copious datastreams: ⚫ Your address is available : USPS (or foreign equivalent), USPS NCOA file, DMV, voting registration, payroll processors, magazine subscriptions, addressbook snooping from other parties' records. http://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-post-office-sells-your-new-address-with-anyone-who-pays-and-the-little-known-loophole-to-opt-out/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/adamtanner/2013/07/08/how-the-po... ⚫ Your place of employment: payroll processor, banking records, LinkedIn. ⚫ Purchases: Credit card, debit card, loyalty programs, checks, retail-site tracking (phone signal or WiFi monitoring). ⚫ Your general consumer preferences are bracketed: Age, sex, home address, income, educational data, magazine subscriptions, purchasing daa. ⚫ Your email exchanges: Even if you don't use Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, or other major email service providers, people and businesses you rely on do. If you've communicated with them, or even if you haven't, your data are there. ⚫ General location information: cellphone tracking data. ⚫ Annual driving data (miles): state smog data, insurance processors, toll tags.. ⚫ Online activities: IP address, ISP, browser fingerprints. ⚫ Medical data: Hospitals, insurers, payment processors, billing services, third-party labs, drugs suppliers, etc... ⚫ Generally: data, information, photos, events, etc., entered about you by third parties into online or offline, public or private, systems. So: you can try to take specific steps to make small portions of your data, but it's rather like building a dam when you're 1) already neck-deep in water and 2) surrounded on all sides. Until you can create a comprehensive and nonpermeable barrier, you see little benefit. Opting out offers you little additional privacy, and costs you the discounts or other benefits provided. Possible alternative: opt in but under your own terms. Fuzz data, share cards or identifiers with others, use tokens (phones, toll tags, credit cards, etc.) for a brief time, then discard them or, better, exchange them with someone else.