4 ms·
This conversation keeps coming back and I'm not sure there's ever anything new to say. I'm just going to summarize this the way I see it: 1) There are only two
by manigandham 11y ago
This conversation keeps coming back and I'm not sure there's ever anything new to say. I'm just going to summarize this the way I see it:
1) There are only two viable business models for digital publishers - free content with ads, or paid access. Yes some can survive on donations and ecommerce, but those are exceptions. Direct paid models also only work for some very large and high quality publishers, the long-tail of great small sites only exists because of ads.
2) The main reasons of adblocking usually are performance, security and privacy. Performance is a given, loading less means loading faster. Security is definitely a problem along with privacy, but mostly because this is a global industry that has largely gone without any real regulation. Things are slowly changing but a few bad actors have ruined a lot of trust by coming up with increasingly intrusive formats and allowing malware on their networks from shady advertisers.
3) Blocking ads absolutely does hurt publishers. It's not fair nor "right". It might not be illegal but just because it's easy to do doesn't condone the usage. Lots of sites have terms of service where they explicitly state the content is available in exchange for the ads. The fair choice would be to not visit the site if you don't find the ads acceptable, a choice that has always existed. By visiting with adblock, you are showing that you find value in the content but don't want the publisher to recoup the costs of production.
4) Going forward, advertisers are getting better with less intrusive formats and better security. Regulation is also finally appearing along with things like fraud and viewability tracking. This should all help, but it's a long road. The other option is micropayments but this isnt as easy to solve (needs massive scale, partnerships with sites, perhaps ISP help, etc).
Overall: ads work, it's a giant industry, adblocking does improve performance, security and privacy but costs the publisher and does endanger the wider web of original content. I don't agree with using adblock but I do consider the reasons valid and that its at least pushing for a better industry (and perhaps future model).
Edit: Downvoters, what exactly is the issue? Interesting that anyone advocating that adblockers aren't an absolute good thing gets dismissed here on HN.
- dsr_ 11y agoI suspect you are being downvoted because you are not arguing very well. "There are only two viable business models" - and then you admit a third, and a fourth, and claim that they are exceptions. There can't possibly be a fifth? There can't be a sixth that someone will invent next year and become the dominant mode of funding digital publishing? You claim a moral right for web sites to show you ads, but no equivalent moral right for people to use programs to ignore the ads. That's inconsistent, and also morally abhorrent to many people. Finally, you say that you "don't agree with using adblock but I do consider the reasons valid" -- that appears to be another inconsistency. If ad blocking is immoral, there can't be any reasoning which will overwhelm your moral objections. Perhaps you are using the word "moral" in an unusual fashion?
- manigandham 11y ago1) There are only two viable business models today. The exceptions are not viable; just because a few can do it doesn't mean they can be used for the mainstream. And I didnt say there can't be more nor was I implying it since I talk about possible future alternatives - it's just reality today only has 2. When more show up and actually prove to work, then there will be more. 2) Both options in a moral argument cant be moral. I don't think it's moral for people to use programs to tamper with what a content provider has given you in exchange for providing that content (which they have full rights to) for free. The usage of the programs isnt the issue, it's what and how it's used for. Modifying a site to make text bigger is fine for example, modifying it to circumvent the advertising explicitly is morally wrong. 3) The reasons why people want to block ads are fine. Most people want more performance, security and privacy. Adblock and it's blunt approach of blocking everything as well as the extortion businesses run by the adblocking companies is immoral. Wanting something and doing it are different, as well as the method. I'm arguing that adblocking as a method is wrong. 4) I'm not sure what other word I could use... it's based on principals since it's not law or hard rules, unless you count breaking terms of use on sites. But it seems nobody cares about those so morality seems to cover all of it.
- throwawaykf05 11y ago> You claim a moral right for web sites to show you ads, but no equivalent moral right for people to use programs to ignore the ads. That's inconsistent, and also morally abhorrent to many people. It's not inconsistent. People have a right to ask for whatever they think their product is worth. And people have just as much as a right to turn down the deal if they find it unacceptable. But people do not have a right to just go ahead and consume the product if they find the asking price unreasonable. The latter seems more morally abhorrent to me.
- falcolas 11y ago> the long-tail of great small sites only exists because of ads. The internet, as it existed before ads, has shown this to be false. As has Wikipedia - an ad free site which displays the writings of millions of individuals. Oh, and book authors - they run sites without ads, and frequently even post web-first stories, supported by following them with e-books purchased by their fans. > By visiting with adblock, you are showing that you find value in the content but don't want the publisher to recoup the costs of production. Personally, I'm showing that the producer has lost all of my trust that they can pick ads which are appropriate to their content. Most web site owners are lazy when it comes to ads - they just allow through whatever the ad company wants to put up. It devalues their site, and the fact they don't notice this indicates their lack of respect for me as a consumer. > advertisers are getting better with less intrusive formats Not in my experience. Full page interstitial ads, inter-article highlight ads, auto-playing sound and movie ads, ads for crappy Clash of Clans clones advertised by busty, half dressed women... it's as bad as it ever was. > ads work No, they really don't. The payout per impression has been going down for years, as more and more companies realize that ads just don't work (regardless of the fraction of a percent of people who block them). The only reason ads are still viewed as a remotely viable model is because the ad sellers are lying to the people purchasing ad impressions. "Look at all of this (bot) clickthrough on your new ad on Facebook! How about all of these impressions (from click farms in China)! Now how about buying another 200,000 targeted impressions? What do you mean you didn't get any actual purchases from the previous 200k? You're just not realizing how much value you've gained from being in front of people's eyes. That's another $2,000, please." Could I stop viewing sites which use ads? Yup. Should I? Hard to say. Perhaps I'm nostalgic for the old days where content was made freely available for the sake of being available, perhaps I'm just being vindictive against those who have displayed no respect for me. Either way, I'm not going to stop browsing the web because someone wants to make my eyeballs bleed for an insignificant fraction of a penny.
- manigandham 11y agoMost publishers (like the long-tail) cant sell or moderate every single ad. No advertiser these days picks a single site to run on, rather they purchase based on audiences. Instead, publishers will blacklist certain advertisers but for the most part it's very automated based on context, behavior targeting, and other factors. Also even if a publisher is large enough to do direct deals, they still use the networks to "backfill" the remaining inventory because they would rather make some money than nothing. With the cost of hosting going down and the growth of blogging platforms like wordpress, medium and others, it's becoming much easier for the long tail to publish. Still hard if they want to actually make money but at least they can publish without a problem today. I'm glad for that progress. Arguing that ads don't work though, I just dont get it. What are you basing this on? The entire industry has increased by billions in spend, cost per impression is falling because there's so much more inventory and the shift to more performance based pricing. There are still triple digit CPMs depending on the placement + audience + format so it's not like everything is super cheap. If it's some crappy clickbait link running on some shady site, yea it'll be cheap. Buying ads on FT.com is very different. Ad fraud is a problem sure, the same as fraud is a problem in credit cards. It's just a constant arms race. It's not like the industry is stupid. Please stop thinking that all of the very talented engineers, data scientists and analysts dont know anything. This industry is far more hard data-driven than many others where "gut" powers lots of decisions. Edit: Side note: I know people hate clickbait headlines and all those crappy gossip articles... but guess why they're always around and sites like BuzzFeed are worth a billion? Because that's what people actually click on and read.