2 ms·
What model, what theory, what principles determine how the raw data should be filtered and processed? If no one can make sense of the data then the data is usel
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
What model, what theory, what principles determine how the raw data should be filtered and processed? If no one can make sense of the data then the data is useless. If there are objective measures for filtering and processing the data and making sense of it, then other experts can critique those methods, they can test the methods, and others, on new and original data to determine how well the methods work. To reproduce or refute results.
This is science.
The risk of public science being misinterpreted by the public is less serious that the risk of private science being inaccessible to other scientists. The first risk is that the public will make incorrect decisions based on misunderstandings, the second risk is that the "science" will be wrong which can lead to the public making incorrect decisions which they believe to be backed by the leading scientists in the field. This second risk is far more dangerous. Whether non-technical people (including journalists) will misinterpret the data is less relevant. Does it matter whether non-technical people can make sense of Quantum Chromo-Dynamics? or General Relativity? or 2D COSY NMR Spectroscopy? What matters is that scientific theories and the data supporting them are available openly, so that others who can understand them can make use of them and can verify them. Anything else is just opinion masquerading as science.