4 ms·
The way you've formulated it, that's false. However, it makes sense in evolutionary biology that females are going to be more selective about partners than male
by stcredzero 11y ago
The way you've formulated it, that's false. However, it makes sense in evolutionary biology that females are going to be more selective about partners than males. (Perhaps we'll rewire ourselves or develop pharmaceuticals that adjust our sex drives for hedonistic or practical purposes convenient to us?)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kjhsadklj1 11y agoThe fad of repurposing evolutionary biology to explain some current situation needs to go away. It's appealing because it's a convenient way for people to wrap their opinions in science, using such phrases as, "it makes sense..." In this particular claim (females have a biological motivation to conserve sex), you should research findings regarding female bonobos. EG, from [1]: "bonobo females mate throughout their ovulatory cycles with most or all group males." In other words, females may actually be incentivized towards promiscuity because it confuses paternity, bonding the offspring with multiple group males, increasing its chances for survival. [1] https://books.google.com/books?id=_scD6LxIuMUC&pg=PA1938&lpg=PA1938&dq=female+bonobo+confuse+paternity&source=bl&ots=B6VVKWhhYG&sig=GzoE_9bzUq0Kixy3KPVX6Xp_fdw&hl=en&sa=X&ei=QB1zVcbLN8GiNov4g9AH&ved=0CDEQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=female%20bonobo%20confuse%20paternity&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=_scD6LxIuMUC&pg=PA1938&lpg...
- whearyou 11y agoBonobos are an edge case in sexuality. Far more mammalian and primate species behave similarly to stcredzero's conception. Still, the author's basic assumption as HarryHirsch says 'that men want to "acquire sex" (to use the terminology in the paper) and that women are pure... as if women didn't enjoy sex as much as men.' fundamentally undermines an otherwise interesting paper (and probably relevant to the authors, is kind of anti-feminist)
- kjhsadklj1 11y agoI'm not educated in the field, so I am happy to learn if I am wrong. But aren't bonobos one of the closest relatives to humans? That would indicate that the comparison is most relevant to human sexual behavior, regardless of what the rest of more distant ape relatives do. Anyhow, my point is more about using evolutionary biology to explain current situations. EG, it would be incorrect (yet tempting) for me to reply with: "bonobos exhibit paternity-confusing behavior. This is because their more highly developed brains allow for more complex behavior that bonds a group of primates together more closely, e.g., males will care for the groups offspring, rather than just his own." What I did there was to couch my personal opinion/narrative into the scientific language for increased authority. This is how I most frequently see evo bio used.
- stcredzero 11y agoBonobos do not have social penalties for promiscuity, however. This would change the cost/benefit equation for humans. So, interesting, we've come back to social constructs from evolutionary biology. What I did there was to couch my personal opinion/narrative into the scientific language for increased authority. This is how I most frequently see evo bio used. So you engage in such speech/commenting, not as a genuine form of exchanging ideas and formulating new ones, but as a means of aggression on behalf of chosen causes/positions? Scientific facts aren't data to be considered in thought, but as ammunition in a partisan debate? If so, thanks for this bit of information about your world view.
- cyphunk 11y agoBonobos do not have social penalties for promiscuity, however. So, interesting, we've come back to social constructs from evolutionary biology. Outside of religious communities humans don't have intense social penalties either. So this then is rather limited application of evo bio. The reason bonobo was presented was to illustrate the limitations of application of evolutionary biology. At some point it's use feels like darwinphilia.
- 11y ago
- stcredzero 11y agoThe fad of repurposing evolutionary biology to explain some current situation needs to go away. So basically, you're warning against armchair evolutionary biology, as it's harder than some laypeople might think to get it right. That's interesting about Bonobos.