3 ms·
The big problem with these studies and local economies is that results are likely to depend very much on localised factors such as proximity to larger markets,
by notahacker 11y ago
The big problem with these studies and local economies is that results are likely to depend very much on localised factors such as proximity to larger markets, not to mention what proportion of the village actually receives the handout, and how much of the existing village economy revolves around people with more wealth than the handout recipients. I think it's pretty much impossible to give a definitive yes/no answer.
It's also worth pointing out that the "minor effects" are minor because they're not statistically significant for the sample rather than because they're not necessarily there. Haushofer and Shapiro, for example, finds that whilst recipients spend $36/month more, comparably poor non-recipients in a village spend $7.5 per month less. The sample size and volatility means the latter part of result isn't statistically significant, but on the other hand it is more consistent with the effects on the poor that didn't receive handouts in these particular villages being negative, and indeed if only a fifth of the village received the subsidy it's even consistent with the benefits being entirely positional, even though the dispersal of the losses amongst a larger population makes it difficult to precisely gauge.