5 ms·
"In fact when they tried to test it on Earth, it very nearly killed him [...] Without Neil Armstrong Apollo 11 very likely would have ended with Richard Nixon r
by Someone 11y ago
"In fact when they tried to test it on Earth, it very nearly killed him [...] Without Neil Armstrong Apollo 11 very likely would have ended with Richard Nixon reading this somber message"
Not necessarily. It can be argued that Neil Armstrong should have aborted the landing, rather than risk it with so little safety room.
After all, if he couldn't reliably do it on earth, how can you argue that it was purely his intelligence and attitude under pressure that got them on the moon, and not also a bit of luck?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pdonis 11y agoOf course they had luck (and more than a bit). But aborting safely would have required luck too. They were already off their pre-planned trajectory, which meant initiating an abort would have put them off of the pre-planned abort trajectory. So a successful abort would probably also have required manual control, and not just for the minute or so required to land, but for an extended period of time while they tried to figure out the right trajectory to get back up into lunar orbit and rendezvous with the command module. Given that choice, I'm not surprised that Armstrong elected to attempt the landing.
- Nomentatus 11y agoMission control would have had the trajectory back up calculated and in hand, but separating from the lower lander stage and engaging the (different) return rocket at low altitude, outside of normal flight parameters, with an ongoing computer problem of (then) unknown origin - I would agree, that sounds still dicier. Plus, a manual landing was practiced in computer-governed simulators; it wouldn't feel the same, but otherwise the task would be quite similar - except for the dust perhaps.