5 ms·
On one hand, this seems almost like a Spinal Tap sort of situation. If you want to make it illegal to evade the reporting requirements by withdrawing $8,000 rep
by mikeash 11y ago
On one hand, this seems almost like a Spinal Tap sort of situation. If you want to make it illegal to evade the reporting requirements by withdrawing $8,000 repeatedly, then write the law to require reporting $8,000, or whatever amount you're after.
On the other hand, the law is written such that it only applies to people who are aware of the law and intended to circumvent reporting. It seems like an easy case that withdrawing $1.7 million in increments under $10,000 is intentional, and that the guy who was Speaker of the House at the time that the law was updated by Congress would know that the law exists.
As is often the case, it seems like a bad person violating a bad law and it's hard to get worked up over either.
- TEMPLEOS_DEV 11y agoThey don't have to. Structuring transactions to avoid reporting laws is also a crime. Periodic withdrawals of $9,999 won't save you.
- MCRed 11y agoA crime is when something hurts someone. The word "crime" is a moral judgement. Here it is merely illegal. That non-crimes are made illegal is an indicator of corruption. When crimes are made legal - eg: kidnapping people for doing something that isn't a crime, as this law does, then you have corruption. Enough of that and you have tyranny. It's easy to remember the difference if you look at it this way: The nazis murdering the jews was a crime, but it was perfectly legal.
- jperras 11y agoWhat you've described is known as smurfing, and it is quite illegal: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structuring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structuring
- Frozenlock 11y agoSo... planning your actions to respect the law is illegal. Glorious.
- differentView 11y agoWhether or not you agree with the law, how is intentionally avoiding having your withdrawal recorded respecting the law? Hastert could have simply withdrawn the entire amount at once.
- passwordreset 11y agoNo, he couldn't, because that would have been against the law.
- rnovak 11y agoNo it wouldn't, it just would have been reported to the IRS. Not illegal, just reported for tax purposes
- Frozenlock 11y agoThis has nothing to do with agreeing with the law, it's about complying with it. If it says you must report any --single-- withdrawal larger than $10k, then you are complying with it if you don't report: A single withdrawal $5k; 3 withdrawal of $9k; Yearly withdrawals of groceries; Like said in another comment, you could easily ask to report any --total-- withdrawal larger than $10k within a time frame if that's really what you wanted.
- Spooky23 11y agoYou are obliged to report withdrawals of $10k or more with a CTR. Your bank is obliged to report any transaction deemed "suspicious", including transactions or series of transactions that you previously reported. Anyone working for the bank can decide that your transactions are suspicious for pretty much any reason. They are required to keep their suspicions secret from you. (Example: Gov Spitzer of NY's fall: http://www.banktech.com/spitzer-exposed-by-bankandrsquos-anti-money-laundering-technology-/d/d-id/1291767 http://www.banktech.com/spitzer-exposed-by-bankandrsquos-ant...? ) Basically, the government doesn't want people moving lots of untraceable money around, period. If you're wealthy and like to spend your money interacting with Federal law enforcement, go for it, but have a good attorney standing by and stfu.
- mikerichards 11y agoIt's only illegal because socialist, fascist scum decided it was illegal
- belorn 11y agoIn Sweden, they have created a similar system but which simply limits withdraws to $1,500 a week unless you visit a bank and ask for permission, for which takes a minimum of 2 bank days. Withdrawing $1.7 million in increments would simply be too impractical.
- pc86 11y agoWait, if I want to pull $2k out of the bank I have to ask for permission and there's a mandatory waiting period?
- ersii 11y agoReally? Well, the Bankomat AB ("ATM Inc") ATM network page says that each card issuer issuer (ie. Bank) that is connected are responsible for setting withdrawal limits individually. Unless the card is from a issuer that is not connected to their network, in which case the withdrawal is limited to 2000 SEK (currently ~237 USD, ~214 EUR). Also, as far as I know - I can walk into a FOREX Bank branch office and withdraw as much as I want to at any time with my current card, as my issuing bank has a deal with them for cash management. As far as I know, there's no laws that restrict cash withdrawal in this way or any laws about reporting cash withdrawal to Skatteverket (Swedish "IRS").
- ersii 11y agoAs far as I know, there's no laws that restrict cash withdrawal in this way or any laws about reporting cash withdrawal to Skatteverket (Swedish "IRS"). The only restrictions I can think about are for cash deposits. Basically, you need to declare where the cash is from. It's a checkbox type item where I usually answer "Savings." (It's that stupid.)
- stonemetal 11y agoThey aren't after transactions of any specific amount, just "interesting" ones. Large rare transactions are interesting, as are big transactions that have been broken up to hide from reporting.