6 ms·
The government has the burden to prove that the defendant knew about the reporting requirement and intended to evade it... this is quite unlike many of the regu
by tantalor 11y ago
The government has the burden to prove that the defendant knew about the reporting requirement and intended to evade it... this is quite unlike many of the regulatory crimes that can ensnare the unsophisticated.
So this is a situation where ignorance of the law does excuse violating it?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignorantia_juris_non_excusat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignorantia_juris_non_excusat
- stephengillie 11y agoPart of the purpose of laws is to act as a deterrent. This can't happen if people are ignorant of them.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI have an extremely difficult time believing that a past member of the legislative branch of the government is unaware of a law. That's your job. To know the law.
- musername 11y agoBut if so, it just shows that there are way too many laws.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoNo, it's his job to write the law. But... Too many 2000-page bills. Too many "you have to pass it to know what's in it" bills. They can write it, and still not know what it says. But the hammer should fall on them for that, too, because if they had done a decent job writing it, it wouldn't be so hard to know what it says.
- anigbrowl 11y agoIndeed, the Speaker of the House is arguably the most powerful member of the legislative branch. In the disastrous event that the President and Vice-President die or are otherwise incapacitated, the Speaker is next in line to head the government. In his or her legislative capacity, the Speaker also wields a vast amount of power, (largely) deciding which legislation comes up for debate or vote, and what sort of practices are acceptable in the legislative chamber.
- perfTerm 11y agoYea I'm a nobody and I know about over 10,000 dollar transaction reports. Anyone with actual assets sure should
- walshemj 11y agoWell a load of Journalists in the UK got of with the argument that they didn't know that bribing police officers/civil service wasn't illegal. Of course the ones who got paid are doing 3 years in jail (and will probably lose all their pensions) whist the hacks got off scott free
- rdtsc 11y agoNot necessarily. The purpose of some laws are entrapment, getting the ability to harass, prosecute, or in general make life difficult for certain people. Some function as catch-alls to be able to slap arbitrarily high number of charges onto someone.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's not illegal to make repeated cash transactions less than $10,000. It's illegal to make repeated cash transactions less than $10,000 with the intent to evade the reporting requirements. So if you are not aware of the reporting requirements it is very unlikely that you are violating the law (you certainly aren't violating the reasonable spirit of the law, you may not escape prosecution...).
- sliverstorm 11y agoIn other words the crime is the intent, so it's impossible to commit the crime without the intent! (Unlike the prototypical crime which is the act)
- maxerickson 11y agoI'm pretty sure they only bother prosecuting cases where the act is committed. I don't think it is so far away from other crimes where intent is evaluated (like murder vs manslaughter).
- mentat 11y agoThey've certainly been doing it without evidence of intent. It's been a huge deal. http://www.bizjournals.com/bizjournals/washingtonbureau/2015/02/irs-seizes-millions-from-law-abiding-businesses-3.html http://www.bizjournals.com/bizjournals/washingtonbureau/2015...
- maxerickson 11y agoThe first business mentioned in that article certainly did structure their transactions with the intent of avoiding reporting regulations, under the advice of their accountant: Convenience-store distribution is a cash-intensive business, and Hirsch said his accountant advised him that he should keep the company's deposits below $10,000 because banks didn't like the paperwork involved with Currency Transaction Reports. The article states But there was no evidence of criminal activity, not that there was no evidence of intent (as the section I quoted makes clear, the intent was obvious). Please note that I'm not making statements in favor of the law in these comments, just characterizing the facts as I see them. ETA: as I keep reading, the second business was also intentionally avoiding the reporting requirements (after a teller told them how). The third one does not directly state that they were trying to avoid the reporting requirements.
- pluma 11y agoIt's not about knowledge of the law, it's about intent. Ignorance is not an excuse, but it can diminish the crime if the crime is defined in a way that requires intent. For example, intent can be the difference between murder ("first degree" to Americans) and recklessly causing someone to die. If you poison someone's food and they die, it's murder. If you unwittingly poisoned the food, it's not, but you may be held accountable for a different crime (i.e. recklessness that resulted in death). This distinction is okay. In fact I'd argue it's expected. EDIT: Heck, if intent were irrelevant, it'd even be legal to plan to kill or harm people as long as you don't fully follow through. If you caught a terrorist before the act, you'd have to let them go because they haven't yet actually harmed anyone.
- thwarted 11y agoHeck, if intent were irrelevant, it'd even be legal to plan to kill or harm people as long as you don't fully follow through. If you caught a terrorist before the act, you'd have to let them go because they haven't yet actually harmed anyone. (IANAL, and these questions are meant only to incite thought or details (if anyone has any)) Is the state of being a terrorist the act of terrorizing or the thought of doing something that is terrorizing? If it's the latter, how is that different than a thought crime? Even if it's planned, but never executed, is one a terrorist? How does one distinguish between having planned but never intending to execute vs having planned but didn't get around to execute? Is a plan that is never executed a failed plan? There is a distinction between "murder" and "conspiracy to commit murder", the former being the act and the latter being participation in the planning. If the actor attempts to terrorize and no one is actually terrorized, has an act of terrorism been committed? If a program is designed, but never written, is it software? If a program is written, but never executed, is it software?
- perfTerm 11y agoI think the difference lies in the planning. Sure, you can think "wow if I blew this place up it'd really mess things up here", but if you think that and then set out to buy fertilizer and an suv, that's obviously a lot more actionable than a "thought crime". The law doesn't punish people who have drastic thoughts, it punishes people who have drastic thoughts and then bring them up to associates as something not so drastic. I dunno, that's the difference to me
- andrewstuart2 11y agoThere are two laws/rules in question. A. Transactions above $10,000 must be reported by the bank. B. Bank customers can't structure withdrawals deliberately to evade the reporting requirement. Ignorance of the reporting law de facto means that you haven't violated the evasion law. You can't deliberately evade something you know nothing about.
- Qantourisc 11y agoIn my opinion ignorance should be allowed. Unless: there was a conflict (which would require you to figure out what is the law on the subject); you endangered someone; clear cases of don't do to other what you don't want done to you. It's even impossible to know the law, how can any SANE person request to do the impossible ?
- aidenn0 11y agoYes. There are many other laws where that is the case. Part of the idea is that if you do something wrong because you think it's legal... well you still should have known it was wrong. With this law, the actual "wrong thing" is trying to avoid the reporting requirement. If you just happen to need $8000 every week, then you aren't trying to avoid the reporting requirement, so you haven't violated the law.