6 ms·
The failure of Digital Research and IBM to reach a deal to bundle CP/M with the original PC provides one of the great "what-ifs" in computing history. If that
by smacktoward 11y ago
The failure of Digital Research and IBM to reach a deal to bundle CP/M with the original PC provides one of the great "what-ifs" in computing history.
If that deal had been made, Microsoft wouldn't have gotten the big infusion of capital that turned it from a niche vendor into the behemoth it eventually became. Which means Windows, Office, and IE (if they were ever developed at all!) would have had to compete in the marketplace without MS being able to use their monopoly over PC operating systems as a lever to boost them up over the competition. Which in turn means a whole host of products whose names are just footnotes today -- Netscape, OS/2, GEM, TopView, DESQView, DeskMate, GEOS, Lotus 1-2-3, WordPerfect, Ami Pro, and on and on and on -- would have had access to the oxygen that could have turned them into the Next Big Thing. Oxygen that Microsoft was only able to deny them because of the muscle the failure of that original deal had given them.
Who knows what the computing world would look like today if that deal had been reached?
- delibes 11y agoI imagine an alternate universe where you wrote : "The failure of Microsoft and IBM to reach a deal to bundle DOS with the original PC provides one of the great "what-ifs" in computing history."
- wvenable 11y agoI think the single behemoth is a bit of stable state for computing, especially in those days. So you would end up with just a different behemoth and it could have been worse.
- brandonmenc 11y ago> a whole host of products whose names are just footnotes today Don't forget BeOS!
- njloof 11y agoApple's been doing a credible job of duplicating the features of BeOS in MacOS X, with the help of some key BeOS refugees (notably Dominic Giampaolo).
- Stratoscope 11y agoThis is very interesting. Could you give any specifics? Thanks!
- codezero 11y agoHFS/HFS+ are very very similar to the BeOS filesystem. Dominic Giampaolo developed that, so I assume that's what's being referred to. There's a great writeup of the file system here: http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf In particular, the labels and how they worked in BeOS are a big part of HFS, when Finder says it's "indexing" it's indexing all those extended attributes (among other things).
- brandonmenc 11y ago> notably Dominic Giampaolo His book on file system design is still a must-read, imo. http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf
- WalterBright 11y agoBut CPM/86 WAS shipped for the PC, by IBM. When I bought my IBM PC, I had a choice of PC-DOS or CPM/86. I chose the former because it was $40 and the latter was $180 or something like that. It was the price that killed CPM/86, as nobody could give a reason why someone should pay so much more than for PC-DOS.
- vangale 11y agoDon't forget UCSD Pascal! (Or maybe we should)
- jpindar 11y agoWhat was so bad about UCSD Pascal?
- WalterBright 11y agoS----L-----O-----W It was basically Java before machines got fast enough to make Java practical.
- cactusface 11y agoThen again you wouldn't have the initial JVM bytecode interpreter without p-code and the p-system, which were the bytecode and runtime environment used by UCSD Pascal. These were a direct inspiration for the Sun engineers developing Java.
- nsxwolf 11y agoDefinitely ahead of its time. For awhile it was possible to run the same applications on IBM, Apple II, TI-99/4A and more but it was cumbersome and it never had a "killer app". It was also difficult to transfer files between disparate platforms in those days. If there had ever been a p-code applications market, distribution would have still required separate boxed copies for different platforms.
- vangale 11y ago
- bryanlarsen 11y agoIt's possible that Microsoft would have "offered" to build the BIOS to get its basic in ROM and used control over the BIOS to put itself into the same gatekeeper position. Also Microsoft was a very resourceful, ambitious company, they would still have developed Office. I wouldn't even write off Windows, it could have easily been developed on top of CP/M. Things could have been very different or they could have been very much the same.
- yuhong 11y agoMy favorite is actually the OS/2 2.0 fiasco now, given that it involved unethical tactics like Microsoft Munchkins etc., not to mention DR-DOS.
- steven2012 11y agoThere's no guarantee that CP/M would have maintained its lead. It could have been the case that MSFT didn't just curl up and die but fight and regain the monopoly. Say what you want about Microsoft, but Gates and Ballmer were/are smart and even smarter with business.
- donflamenco 11y agoA (the?) big reason Microsoft got the IBM contract was because Bill Gate's mom (Mary Gates) was on the board of United Way with the CEO of IBM at the time (John Opel.) Bill Gate's parents are impressive on their own rights. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Maxwell_Gates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Maxwell_Gates "In 1980, she discussed with John Opel, a fellow committee member who was the chairman of the International Business Machines Corporation, her son's company. Mr. Opel, by some accounts, mentioned Mrs. Gates to other I.B.M. executives. A few weeks later, I.B.M. took a chance by hiring Microsoft, then a small software firm, to develop an operating system for its first personal computer."
- wilsynet 11y agoIBM approached Microsoft to provide various software for their PC. Microsoft said they could provide BASIC, but not an Operating System, and helpfully directed IBM to Digital Research. Digital Research passed on the onerous terms (close to free). IBM went back to Microsoft and said "now what?". Microsoft, fearing they would lose the BASIC deal as well, then purchased the rights to QDOS or 86-DOS (a CP/M clone) for $50,000 from Seattle Computer Products, and did the deal with IBM, agreeing to the onerous terms that Digital Research wouldn't. Which as we all know didn't actually turn out to be very onerous at all. This is well documented in Triumph of the Nerds. Mary Maxwell Gates may have provided an introduction, but it was the chutzpah, genius and desperation of Bill Gates that got the deal done.
- guiambros 11y agoPer Walter Isaacson [1], the influence of Mary Gates was more to endorse and confirm the deal, than to serve as an introduction. During a business trip, Mary Gates mentioned to John Opel that "My son is doing business with your company", but he answered that he wasn't aware of any deal, and never heard of any "Micro-soft". On her return, she joked with Bill that his deals with IBM shouldn't be that important. Several weeks later, when deal was ready to be signed, IBM execs ran the agreement by John Opel, who then mentioned "oh, this must be Mary Gates' son. She's great. Yes, go ahead". [1] http://smile.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Hackers-Geniuses-Revolution/dp/147670869X http://smile.amazon.com/The-Innovators-Hackers-Geniuses-Revo...
- JoshTriplett 11y agoA flip side of that: if the IBM/Microsoft deal had been made, the PC clone industry might not have succeeded, so PC might have meant exclusively "IBM PC". Forget about all the products that Microsoft crowded out; what would have happened to the hardware and software industry if a dozen competing "PC" manufacturers didn't spring up?
- nsxwolf 11y agoMaybe a more advanced architecture like the Amiga would have won out.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI was under the impression that most of the consumer hardware that has been dominating the scene over the past couple of decades has firmly been dictated by constraints pertaining to IBM PC compatibility. It's only with smartphones and tablets coming in to overtake the microcomputer/PC (though they still have a long way to go until self-hosting and everything) that this is being challenged.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI wouldn't go so far as "dictated", since that architecture has heavily evolved over time; PCI, AGP, PCIe, USB, VGA, and many other standards all occurred long after the dethroning of the IBM-branded PC.
- brudgers 11y agoAnd there's IBM's MicroChannel the ignoring of which greatly contributed to the continued growth of the PC industry as it shifted to 16 and 32 bits as standard.
- brudgers 11y agoIf Operating Systems had all been a couple of hundred dollars a pop, there wouldn't necessarily have been all the clones on disks and in homes that allowed those companies to be viable...and the actual story of Netscape is quite different from the myth. Netscape enjoyed a multi billion dollar exit and Andreessen is a leading venture capitalist. Companies go bust. Microsoft didn't kill DEC.
- DanBC 11y ago> Next Big Thing WordStar and WordPerfect were pretty big. They were standard requirements for office jobs. WordPerfect didn't fail because MS had a stranglehold on the industry but because they botched their transition to Windows.