4 ms·
It feels odd to call this a startup instead of a charity or non-profit. The normal goals of a startup vs a charity, which seems a better description for the thi
by rtkwe 11y ago
It feels odd to call this a startup instead of a charity or non-profit. The normal goals of a startup vs a charity, which seems a better description for the things this company/group is doing, don't match well to me (edit in italics: forgot to finish writing this sentence). Nothing particularly wrong with calling it a startup I guess, just strikes me as odd.
This seems to be part of a larger turn towards more data and study driven aid than was the standard. Hopefully the larger nation state players can get around to using aid programs to reap longer term improvements vs the current short term and occasionally overall harmful effects some programs have been reported to create.
- up_and_up 11y ago> It feels odd to call this a startup instead of a charity or non-profit. Everybody is spinning their small business or new charity as a `startup`. Maybe culturally they are aligned with startup principles but my idea of startup was a small group of people looking to shake things up (a market, a technology, etc) rapidly, grow fast and cash out. A guy selling shaving cream on etsy is not a startup by this definition.
- rtkwe 11y agoI think that's part of it. Working on or being a startup brings a certain cachet to it and is more likely to get media attention vs just being a new small business or new charity. A normal new business calling itself a startup doesn't strike me as oddly as charity based groups. At least with a normal for-profit business the goals are roughly aligned and similar whether you're looking for the explosive growth or long term growth and stability, you're still in it to make money instead of charities which should be operating completely opposite.
- caublestone 11y ago"And despite some skepticism, GiveDirectly's financial support is growing (from $5.5 million in 2013 to an expected $40-50 million this year), driven in large part by younger donors working in tech or finance, according to Niehaus." And according to PG, http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html http://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html
- rtkwe 11y ago> A startup is a company designed to grow fast. My issue with charities being called startups is more in the for-profit vs charitable goals. Companies have goals that just don't jive with the goals of a good charity. If we take a definition based purely around 'designed to grow fast' yes it can fit. There's just more connotation to the word startup than the purely growth based definition Paul Graham puts forward. addendum edit: There's nothing inherently wrong with the 'designed to grow fast' definition, it just doesn't sit quite right (with me) applied to charitable orgs because of the additional meaning I talked about above.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWatsi is a startup, the first funded by YC. https://www.ycombinator.com/nonprofits/ https://www.ycombinator.com/nonprofits/ > We’d been thinking about this for a while. We had a hypothesis that many newly founded nonprofits could benefit from the same techniques we use to help startups. We tested this with Watsi in the Winter 2013 batch and it worked wonderfully. They did all the same things as the other startups, including present at Demo Day (which is after all a room with lots of rich people in it). > Since some people were confused when we funded Watsi, I’d better clarify that the money we’re putting into the nonprofits will be a charitable donation, rather than an investment in the narrow sense. We won’t have any financial interest in them.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWell, the quoted parts explicitly distinguishes between "startups" and "nonprofits", pointing out the latter may "benefit from the same techniques [they] use to help" the former.
- Beltiras 11y agoThey are trying to "disrupt" their sector. Sounds like a startup to me.
- tghw 11y ago"Startup" by its very definition is simply a company in its early phases. Whether it's a for-profit corporation or a non-profit corporation, the challenges, at a high level, are largely the same. At a lower level, they vary just as much between for-profit and non-profit as two for-profits in different industries vary.
- mattmanser 11y agoNot really, a startup is a fuzzy concept, but 'business' is always included in the definition. A charity is not a business.
- soyiuz 11y agoThe Oxford English Dictionary defines it more generally: "An instance of ‘starting up’; spec. the action or process of starting up a series of operations, a piece of machinery, a business, etc."
- tghw 11y agoWhy do you think a charity isn't a business? They still have revenues and expenses, employees, marketing, growth, a product to deliver. The only fundamental difference is that their owners don't take dividends or distributions from the business.
- mortehu 11y agoI think you are thinking of nonprofit organizations. Charities don't have to be nonprofit organizations[1], and nonprofit organizations are often not charities. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For-profit_charity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For-profit_charity
- tghw 11y agoWhile technically true, for-profit charities are much less common. Moreover, it's just another step along the spectrum, where for-profit charities, unlike non-profits, are allowed to take distributions, but unlike for-profit corporations, have no obligation to create value for shareholders. (Yes, this is also overlooking privately-held companies, but again, they're just another step on the spectrum.) Regardless, the main point is that charity or not, for-profit or non-profit, they're all still fundamentally businesses and should be run accordingly.
- sidupadhyay 11y agoThese are very salient points, especially given that right now many of the advancements (from a technical and methodological perspective) established from GiveDirectly's early Kenya and Uganda programs are furthered by a spin-off known as Segovia (http://www.thesegovia.com/product/ http://www.thesegovia.com/product/). Perhaps this is the startup behind the scenes that's more inline with the startups brought up on HN.
- smcg 11y ago"startup" gets a lot more traffic on HN than "charity".
- sjg007 11y agoThe startup aspect is that it is small and needs to grow quickly right? The admin fee would be the return?