10 ms·
I really would like to see sports where performance-enhancing drugs (except life-threatening ones) are permitted.
by rwmj 11y ago
I really would like to see sports where performance-enhancing drugs (except life-threatening ones) are permitted.
- johnchristopher 11y agoThat'd be tricky to set up because drugs are discriminatingly life-threatening depending on dosage and individuals.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoWater is life threatening at a high dosage. In fact, a dramatically higher number of people die from water each year than from PED's. Point is, people know the risks when they swim in a pool, people are capable of making decisions for themselves.
- bodyfour 11y agoThe problem is that they're probably nearly all life-threatening (or at a minimum longevity-threatening) in high enough doses. Fully permitted-doping would escalate into a bloodsport where athletes would be competing to show how many drugs they could take before keeling over.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vishnugupta 11y ago>Fully permitted-doping would escalate into a bloodsport where athletes would be competing to show how many drugs they could take before keeling over. Highly recommended reading : https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/08/money-in-the-bank/ https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/08/money-in-the-bank/ It's already happening albeit in a different sport (or entertainment industry).
- gnur 11y ago>> The problem is that they're probably nearly all life-threatening (or at a minimum longevity-threatening) in high enough doses. Everything is lethal in high enough doses.
- Nadya 11y agoEven water is lethal in high enough doses.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tim333 11y agoThey seem tolerated in some body building competitions. If you can call that a sport.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoBodybuilding is more akin to a beauty pageant.
- metamet 11y agoI'd say almost all body building competitions.
- teddyuk 11y agoDo the military use them?
- coob 11y agoYes: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/112269 http://www.newrepublic.com/article/112269
- cactusface 11y agoBeer drinking competitions, debatably.
- mitchell_h 11y agoIt is a known that Pride FC did not test athletes and even had statements in the contracts that they would not test. That might be the closest you'll ever come to what you're asking for. Also, MMA in general right now is going through a huge revolution in PED testing. For a long time it's been a simple matter of testing on fight night, with some athletes being give a therapeutic TRT pass. That is all changing as of this week. All UFC contract athletes will not be given random Olympic style testing year round. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pride_Fighting_Championships http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pride_Fighting_Championships http://espn.go.com/mma/story/_/id/13014746/ufc-announces-extensive-doping-tests-major-punishments http://espn.go.com/mma/story/_/id/13014746/ufc-announces-ext...
- chollida1 11y ago> That is all changing as of this week. All UFC contract athletes will not be given random Olympic style testing year round. I think you made a pretty epic typo:)
- Thriptic 11y agoIn many powerlifting federations they are allowed. There are both drug tested and non-drug tested federations to compete in.
- majani 11y agoCurrently the world's most famous athlete, Lionel Messi, is legally permitted to take HGH, one of the most potent steroids ever made, due to an earlier growth deficiency. Johann Cruyff, also considered one of the football greats, went through the same legal HGH treatments. Their acceleration and injury tolerance is mind blowing. See how Messi blew past 6 players in a cup final last week after playing 50+ games: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOX2QpfMkq4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOX2QpfMkq4 And also here's Johann Cruyff blowing past players with ease: https://youtu.be/YU-k-Ots3iY?t=1m31s https://youtu.be/YU-k-Ots3iY?t=1m31s The popularity of these two players would indicate that athletes legally permitted to use steroids would be very popular among sports fans
- TillE 11y agoLionel Messi is not generally considered a great athlete, with exceptional strength or stamina or anything like that which would be affected by PEDs. His ability is pure skill and intelligence. Cruijff was similar.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoI'd classify an athlete with great skill and intelligence to be a great athlete.
- josefresco 11y agoIn Messi's case this is exactly why it's the supreme advantage. He already possess world class skill and intelligence, add HGH to the mix to boost his athleticism and you have a balanced, top tier athlete.
- CrackpotGonzo 11y agoCompletely disagree. Explosive acceleration, strength on the ball and ability to endure an entire season without being subbed off are all indicative of being a "great athlete".
- dylanjermiah 11y agoNot to be pedantic but HGH isn't a steroid, it's a peptide. On topic, a lot of athletes get legal prescription for TRT (testosterone replacement therapy), and in several sports the legal application is perfectly fine.
- TheCondor 11y agoTo what end? It's just a little more freak show and a little less sport, that's all. Plus the NFL, MLB track and field and cycling have pretty much done just that to varying degrees over the years.
- jusben1369 11y agoI always think this is the exasperated "it's just too hard" response. We want the best athlete with the superior tactical mind to succeed. Not the best scientist.
- bmj 11y agoExcept, as we're seeing in cycling with teams like Sky, money will poured into legal ways to produce "marginal gains." See the kerfuffle during the recent Giro d'Italia when Sky provided their leader Richie Porte with his own motor home to provide more rest. The team also used a helicopter to whisk Porte off one mountain top finish, again in the name of recovery. Professional athletics will always be a money-fueled arms race, whether the means are legal or not. Personally, I like to see "old school" athletes succeed (I'm thinking of cyclist like Oscar Freire, who eschewed most "modern" training devices, and simply rode based on how he felt). Of course, plenty of those athletes doped, so maybe I am living in a dream world.
- aaronharnly 11y agoPerformance-enhancing drugs were endemic in Eastern-bloc Olympic competition for decades. From the Outside Magazine piece linked elsewhere in the comment thread[1]: East Germany's state-supported system of doping, which often began before puberty, left a legacy of Olympic medals—along with deformed offspring, heart attacks, facial disfigurement, and lifelong sexual dysfunction. If you permit the drugs, they'll be used not just in the elite competitors, but in the entire funnel of hopeful competitors starting from high school. These are serious drugs with serious consequences. I for one don't think entertainment is worth that. [1] http://www.outsideonline.com/1924306/drug-test http://www.outsideonline.com/1924306/drug-test
- smcl 11y agoIs that more as a side effect of the fact that this sort of doping is very hush-hush, and if it was more open and permitted safer more effective enhancements would be developed?
- remarkEon 11y agoMaybe, but how would we set up a system of legal doping that doesn't provide any incentives to continue doping on the side, when the consequences for testing positive for a substance don't matter anymore? I could see a system where a certain amount of doping is legal, but you'd still have an incentive to get whatever edge you can on the side.
- jerf 11y agoWe basically already live under the scheme where a certain amount of doping is legal. It's just that what is legal, we don't call doping. But a pro athlete is certainly going to be downing protein powders, creatine powder, etc. that aren't natural either. There's no bright line. So I think you're already correct.
- cafard 11y agoThe late Hal Connolly, an American hammer thrower, told a sports reporter that from about 1960 on everybody in the field events was using steroids. The East Germans were extreme in their devotion to this, but they were far from alone. [Edit: remembered from an article that ran in the NY Times shortly after Connolly's death.]
- dylanjermiah 11y agoWouldn't call it a 'sport' per se, but in bodybuilding there's two divisions, 'natural' (which is supposed to be drug free), and ''(no formal name).
- randlet 11y agoIt's generally referred to as 'untested' I think.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThat's how I refer to it, however I don't think I've seen them refer to themselves as that.
- x0x0 11y agopowerlifting, ifbb (if not on paper, at least tacitly), strongman frankly, I think the majority of this is hysteria driven by whiny baby boomers pissed their sport's records are being surpassed. Of course, tommy john surgery and greenies are cherished traditions. But Barry Bonds is evil because he's black and doesn't tongue bathe interviewers. Or consider the cherished tradition of cheating in the tour de france which was kosher until an american started winning.
- echaozh 11y agoIf you allow car racing, why not drug racing?