3 ms·
I wonder if this is SMM or something even darker and deeper.
by wmf 11y ago
I wonder if this is SMM or something even darker and deeper.
- userbinator 11y agoSMM was my first thought too, although "gone unnoticed for 20 years" (1995) suggests something newer; SMM was introduced in 1990 with the 386SL, and this suggests P6-level. Microcode seems about right - that was introduced in the P6. But, it's also signed (at least Intel ucode is - not sure about AMD) according to previous research... either way, this is going to be interesting.
- mmastrac 11y ago"directed against a uniquely vulnerable string of code running on every single system" That seems to fit with the idea of microcode, but it's pretty vague. What else would be running on every system from the P6?
- nly 11y agoIf it is microcode it wouldn't be a complete disaster. Microcode updates are volatile and can ship with BIOS. Even when updated by Linux it happens early out of initrd.
- dlitz 11y agoSigned how, though? A crypto scheme that Intel came up with 20 years ago is probably not secure, and if they haven't updated it since then, well...
- userbinator 11y agohttp://inertiawar.com/microcode/ http://inertiawar.com/microcode/ suggests a variant of SHA1 or SHA2 with 2048-bit RSA. No doubt it's changed since the P6, probably with different private keys for each CPU model/family, but the public key must be present in the hardware in order to verify, so theoretically it could be extracted... Edit: public key. There might be a test mode which bypasses this or something.
- kryptiskt 11y agoNo, the private key doesn't have to be present. They sign with the private key, the CPU verifies with the public key.
- nly 11y ago"Memory sinkhole" seems be a pun on the "memory hole", which suggests it might be MMU related?
- Zenst 11y agoIf you read "but 40 years of x86 evolution have left a labyrinth of forgotten backdoors into the ultra-privileged modes" then I'm more inclined to agree, though also wondering about V86 monitor after looking at http://www.scs.stanford.edu/05au-cs240c/lab/i386/s15_03.htm http://www.scs.stanford.edu/05au-cs240c/lab/i386/s15_03.htm
- Taniwha 11y agoI think you're right - SMM mode it is, we know the NSA has a bunch of SMM rootkits, I bet someonme found the vector the NSA uses