3 ms·
The comment is calling into question the intent of Microsoft in removing the diffuser. They thought it was important in benefiting security. So, did they remove
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
The comment is calling into question the intent of Microsoft in removing the diffuser. They thought it was important in benefiting security. So, did they remove it for performance or yet another concession to U.S. government? It's a valid question in assessing Microsoft's trustworthiness for security/crypto.
Of course, we already have plenty on that subject. A good answer won't change anything. A bad one is extra nails in the coffin.
- tptacek 11y agoI'm not interested in debating Microsoft's motives, because the engineering issues here are straightforward. The Bitlocker "diffuser" code attempts to make it harder to make targeted changes to plaintext, without making it Hard to do so, because making it Hard is prohibitively expensive. No mainstream full-disk encryption scheme makes it Hard to tamper with on-disk plaintext. The best anyone does is allowing attackers to randomize a wide-ish block at an attacker-chosen offset. It is hard to use that primitive to pop calc.exe on boot, but it remains a powerful primitive: attackers can replace integers in trusted code or data files with very very large integers, and then exploit the resulting memory corruption. The commenter below explains the performance implications, which are real.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNow that is a legitimate critique. It's why I prefer Inline Media Encryptors with trusted path. Those plus an encryption scheme addressing such known issues. The IME knocks the host TCB out of the equation, at least.
- MichaelGG 11y agoIt's been a while since I read the Bitlocker paper, but I remember having the distinct impression the author found it critical to have. And Ferguson knows more about this stuff than I ever will, so I trust his assessment. If this has changed, wouldn't it elicit a bit of an explanation? "Windows 8 takes advantage of better crypto knowledge to remove improve Bitlocker speed." I'd also note that the trend in Bitlocker seems to be to just delegate to the SSD, completely relying on the SSD vendor to get it right. That has zero performance overhead and is more suitable for low end devices.
- tptacek 11y agoIf it's "critical to have", you should be able to mount an argument as to why. It's a little annoying that discussions like these always seem to devolve to "such-and-such an expert said X or Y". We're not debating the Goldilocks Curve vs. the Microsoft NUMS curves. We should reasonably be able to expect people who want to argue about the "Elephant Diffuser" to understand the issues involved.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]