4 ms·
"Microsoft said that the key's symbol was "_NSAKEY" because the NSA is the technical review authority for U.S. export controls, and the key ensures compliance w
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
"Microsoft said that the key's symbol was "_NSAKEY" because the NSA is the technical review authority for U.S. export controls, and the key ensures compliance with U.S. export laws" (Wikipedia on NSAKEY)
We actually don't know what it is past that. So, Microsoft says it was required for export approval & made backup key. NSA controls those export requirements. A declassified CIA document [1] from the period shows export changes were pro-escrow and most big companies were onboard. In short, the NSA, FBI, CIA, and other companies agreed on escrow keys for export of strong cryptography. Microsoft added an escrow (err backup) key called _NSAKEY for export approval. Logically, we should assume it was a COMSEC backdoor for NSA so Microsoft could make money on exports.
Assuming anything else is logically questionable given no hard data contradicting this and Microsoft's history of covert cooperation with NSA in much worse ways. Hard data as in statements by Microsoft such as above straight up saying who ordered the change and what it does vs the mere speculation we saw elsewhere.
[1] http://www.foia.cia.gov/sites/default/files/DOC_0006231614.pdf http://www.foia.cia.gov/sites/default/files/DOC_0006231614.p...
- tptacek 11y agoI sometimes don't know where to start with comments like these. We do in fact know what it is, because no matter what the bits of the secret key are, the use of the key in Microsoft's software is published: the code we're talking about isn't obfuscated. You say "[l]ogically, we should assume it was a COMSEC backdoor for NSA so Microsoft could make money on exports". You say that as if it was impossible to look at the code and see where the key is used. It obviously isn't. People have done that work. They did it years and years ago. They explained what the key does. But the conspiracy theory about NSAKEY being a secret backdoor keeps coming up. Once again: the key we're talking about doesn't even make sense as a backdoor. It's a second authentication key, the first of which is a key Microsoft already has, and could already use to the exact same effect.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoGiven your rep, I'll assume you did thorough research and drop NSAKEY for now. I'll dig up that old work later for verification. If it checks out, I'll pass the correction along to others bringing it up along with modifying Wikipedia article to keep it from confusing others.
- tptacek 11y ago'geofft addressed this better than I ever did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9297787 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9297787
- nickpsecurity 11y agoBookmarked for my later research. Thank you.