4 ms·
> An encrypted hard drive is a totally unprecedented thing in that regard. Then governments with enumerated powers would need some unprecedented powers to get
by Zigurd 11y ago
> An encrypted hard drive is a totally unprecedented thing in that regard.
Then governments with enumerated powers would need some unprecedented powers to get into that unprecedented thing, right?
- rayiner 11y ago> Then governments with enumerated powers would need some unprecedented powers to get into that unprecedented thing, right? Only the federal government is limited to its enumerated powers. So at best your argument is that mandating backdoors requires state rather than federal action. State governments can do whatever they want unless it conflicts with a Constitutional right, and there is no right to have a place to stash evidence the government can't get to with adequate process.
- schoen 11y agoSometimes human memory is such a place under the fifth amendment.
- rayiner 11y agoThe contents of your human memory are not protected as a general principle. For example, you can be compelled to testify against someone else. You can't be compelled to testify against yourself, but the premise of that protection isn't some general right not to disclose the contents of your memory, but a very specific right against forced confessions.
- Zigurd 11y ago> and there is no right to have a place to stash evidence the government can't get to with adequate process Enumerated powers of government. Unenumerated rights of the people.
- rayiner 11y agoAll that means is that you don't have to point to the Constitution to prove a right exists. The right still has to exist somewhere and be recognized.[1] The power of courts to access nearly all evidence with due process predates the Constitution and nothing about that document shows any intention to alter that practice. [1] "Rights" are exceptions, not the rule. The rule is the will of democratically elected legislatures. Rights are exceptions to democracy and should be construed to swallow the rule.
- Zigurd 11y agoRights are expansive. There is no "precautionary principle" when it comes to rights. If a new thing is discovered, like strong encryption, I have a right to use it in conjunction with my other rights. If I can make a cheap personal rocket, I have a right to launch myself into orbit, as long as I'm not infringing on others' rights. The fact that such a rocket means anyone can build an ICBM doesn't put it outside of one's rights. Governments have no inherent power to "inspect." You seem to think governments should have superior powers to individuals. While there is a philosophical argument for this, that doesn't mean it's always going to be true. If code is speech, so is strong encryption.
- rayiner 11y agoIt's fallacious to use the concept of "enumerated powers" and "limited government" to argue that "rights" in the U.S. are, or were intended to be, structured the way you describe. "Limited government" concerns the allocation of power between the state and federal governments, not the relationship between those governments and individuals. State governments are not ones of enumerated powers and they are not limited. They are successors to the British Parliament and inherited the powers of that institution including the general police power. Against that backdrop, "rights" are those specific restrictions on the exercise of that power that states have bound themselves to by the federal Constitution and their own constitutions. There is no room in that framework for an expansive conception of rights that all exist so long as you're "not infringing on others' rights." A great concrete example is blue laws, which were widespread at the time of the founding and regulated everything from alcohol sales to food consumption. Some of those have been challenged, hundreds of years later and mostly unsuccessfully, on establishment clause grounds, but there is little doubt the states, as a general principle, have the right to regulate public morals.