3 ms·
That's not really how it has worked. CAs can't be trusted because, in part, the USG wants to corrupt them as needed. Encryption systems get weakened because the
by Zigurd 11y ago
That's not really how it has worked. CAs can't be trusted because, in part, the USG wants to corrupt them as needed. Encryption systems get weakened because the NSA wants to be able to break them. Vulns don't get reported. Etc. It isn't a "double standard." The tech industry well has been poisoned in the same of surveillance.
- themeek 11y agoThis is right, but it doesn't address my comment. Did this play a role in the breach? Almost certainly it did not.
- yellowapple 11y agoNo, but it means that breaches like this will be even more dangerous to the American public, since now such breaches will have the potential of exposing access to "secure" backdoors and the wealth of surveillance data various LEAs have accumulated.
- themeek 11y agoThere's other threads here were people suggest this. It seems pretty speculative to me that there's some large database with all of the mandated software backdoors and keys to get access to. And if it existed, I don't know that it would be such a large threat. Certainly security bugs and professionals inside of industry are targeted by hackers already. Given everything else, I don't know how large an issue this is (compared to say, hacking nuclear defense systems, energy grid, military C2C, etc). It would be interesting to see whether this is considered a threat scenario by the USG.
- yellowapple 11y ago> It seems pretty speculative to me that there's some large database with all of the mandated software backdoors and keys to get access to. You overestimate the competence of government agencies. > Given everything else, I don't know how large an issue this is A significantly large issue, seeing as it puts the safety of the vast majority of Americans at risk by exposing their personal information (everything from banking information to patient records to their precise movements). > It would be interesting to see whether this is considered a threat scenario by the USG. If it's not, then I've lost any sliver of confidence in the Feds that I might have had previously.
- themeek 11y agoWhat's interesting to me is how divergent your speculative threat model is from what Washington is talking about. How fully do your think your threat model addresses the scope of national security concerns of the United States?
- linkregister 11y ago> CAs can't be trusted because, in part, the USG wants to corrupt them as needed Has this happened? Or did a U.S. government official slip up and admit the future intention publicly? (I wouldn't be surprised) The only CA corruption I've heard of was a MOIS/VAJA operation against DigiNotar and a corporation overstepping its agreement with a CA by abusing a delegate root CA.
- themeekforgotpw 11y agoOh yeah, CAs have been broken for decades. I remember reporting way back on Room 641A at AT&T having shadow certs.