2 ms·
I generally like and agree with FirstLook/Intercept articles but this.... > Microsoft, after considerable prodding, provided me with answers to some longstandi
by joshstrange 11y ago
I generally like and agree with FirstLook/Intercept articles but this....
> Microsoft, after considerable prodding, provided me with answers to some longstanding questions about BitLocker’s security. The company told me which random number generator BitLocker uses to generate encryption keys, alleviating concerns about a government backdoor in that subsystem
And then to answer it:
> Microsoft told me that while the backdoored algorithm is included with Windows, it is not used by BitLocker, nor is it used by other parts of the Windows operating system by default. According to Microsoft, the default PRNG for Windows is an algorithm known as CTR_DRBG, not Dual_EC_DRBG, and when BitLocker generates a new key it uses the Windows default.
Oh they "told you", great I guess we will just take them at face value and move on case clo... FUCK NO. Are you fucking kidding me???? MS may be getting better over all as a company by security/privacy is something I still don't trust them one bit on. That's not to say I think Apple is some bastion of privacy but MS has been in bed with the government for a LOT longer and hasn't been anywhere near as supportive of privacy/security as Apple has been as of late.
This ENTIRE article is supposed to be take on faith and I'm sorry but that's not good enough. It's one thing to say "Some encryption is better than none" or "It will protect your from run-of-the-mill thieves but not the government" but to eat up everything MS said as fact is insane...
And as one more gem:
> I asked Microsoft if the company would be able to comply with unlocking a BitLocker disk, given a legitimate legal request to do so. The spokesperson told me they could not answer that question.
MS knows what side their bread is buttered on and let me give you a hint, it's not the consumer side.
- MBlume 11y ago> Whatever you choose, if trusting a proprietary operating system not to be malicious doesn’t fit your threat model, maybe it’s time to switch to Linux.
- joshstrange 11y ago1 line at the bottom of a blog post does not forgive the rest of it...
- SomeStupidPoint 11y ago> Microsoft told me that while the backdoored algorithm is included with Windows, it is not used by BitLocker, nor is it used by other parts of the Windows operating system by default. According to Microsoft, the default PRNG for Windows is an algorithm known as CTR_DRBG, not Dual_EC_DRBG, and when BitLocker generates a new key it uses the Windows default. This actually sounds a lot like the government mandated a backdoored crypto algorithm in to a suite of crypto algorithms, and then Microsoft was forced to implement the backdoored algorithm in order to get certified for the suite, which is required for government contracts. > I asked Microsoft if the company would be able to comply with unlocking a BitLocker disk, given a legitimate legal request to do so. The spokesperson told me they could not answer that question. There's a ton of perfectly benign reasons that a spokesman would decline to answer that question, and since we don't have a direct quotation, we don't even know what the response actually was. I don't particularly like Microsoft, but I feel like we should blame them for the things they actually do, not hold them to unreasonable standards.
- MichaelGG 11y agoThat's exactly why MS shipped the slow, back doored RND. It's part of the NIST standards and they went along like other vendors, to tick the box.
- wumbernang 11y agoYou can use WinDbg and a checked build and actually find the answer to the question. Why ask when you can check? All vendors are shits on this front. Look like a good boy on paper and do all your naught stuff via a side channel.
- RexRollman 11y agoThe government depends on Windows. They aren't going anyway else.