4 ms·
I've been a Scientific American reader for over a decade now. (sigh)Each issue gets worse and worse -- the magazine has moved from science to advocacy, and in
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I've been a Scientific American reader for over a decade now.
(sigh)Each issue gets worse and worse -- the magazine has moved from science to advocacy, and in a huge way.
Sadly, this commentary just continues the trend. Right now the signal-to-noise ratio is about 1-10. If it continues to drop I'll have to go somewhere else for scientific-oriented news.
Come on, guys. You can do better than this!
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- RobertL 17y agoEmperor has no clothes and this guy is his tailor.
- logjam 17y agoThe piece is clearly labeled as opinion and analysis. Opinion, analysis, and advocacy is part of many actual scientific journals, as it is of science itself. Go browse Science, Nature, New England Journal of Medicine, JAMA for starters. Now, why don't you enlighten us with exactly what you find wrong with the opinion or analysis in this piece, and provide a little more signal yourself. Science is cited in the opinion piece. Do you have an argument with the science cited? Or with the opinion?
- gritzko 17y agoSorry, that is just very poor advocacy. Accusations, spinning the facts, etc.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThere is no scientific content in the article. There is no analysis. There is nothing but a few scientific words, with 5 paragraphs (out of 9) devoted attacking skeptics. Because the opposition here is not grounded in any robust scientific theory...but a hysterical reaction to the possibly of what? One-world government? The return of communism? ...those working in the fossil fuel extraction and/or burning business. There is, in fact, a climate conspiracy...launched by the fossil fuel industry ...same flaks and hacks who brought you "smoking isn't dangerous." In the paragraphs that were not ad-hominem attacks, there was one grounding paragraph (mentioning hacked emails), and another paragraph which (falsely) claims the most damaging email is a complaint about funding. Only one paragraph provides a few links to climate-related science, and that paragraph is more or less tangential to the main article. The main opinion expressed here: climate skeptics are right wing conspiracy theorists working for the oil and tobacco companies. Not sure why this is hacker news, or even relevant to the issue.
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoThey have been doing this for a least three decades. This is just the first time you have noticed them doing it to something you have first hand knowledge of (thanks to the Internet piping primary data into your home). In the early 1980s, Scientific American did exactly the same sorts of things to "prove" that the Soviet technology program was unstoppable, and therefore that we could either retreat or commit planetary suicide. They had a consensus or prominent scientists and engineers showing, with hard numbers and slick charts, that it was provably impossible to do anything about ballistic missiles. Learned professors lectured us on the untenable accuracy limits of missile interceptors; rocket scientists lectured on the ease with which missiles could be spun to keep lasers from burning through. They had a social science consensus that saying "no" provokes aggression. One business cycle later the Soviet technology program went bankrupt and took the political system with it. Edit: And let us not forget the "nuclear winter" scenarios. Doesn't AGW simply reduce to a previously solved problem? ;-)
- billswift 17y agoThat's why I cancelled my subscription and almost entirely quit reading it in the 80s.
- Daemmerung 17y agoScientific American has been declining ever since Flanagan left its masthead, twenty-five years ago. Try American Scientist (http://www.americanscientist.org/ http://www.americanscientist.org/) instead-- it reminds me so much of what SA used to be. (And don't get me started about the Judean People's Front....)