5 ms·
> A few others inevitably reached for their phones - although most were then subjected to a form of group self-policing. "A couple of people were saying 'Don't
by joshstrange 11y ago
> A few others inevitably reached for their phones - although most were then subjected to a form of group self-policing. "A couple of people were saying 'Don't film it! Don't film it!'" Kyra says. "Nowadays you really think 'Oh, shall I video it?'," but thankfully most people felt it wasn't appropriate, she adds. "Anybody who did video got shouted at anyway."
I'm sorry, I fail to see what is so taboo about filming? At the very least it documents what happened... Is the concern filming someone in pain/suffering? We appear to have no problem with that when it's photographers in third-world countries. Not everyone can help directly so what is the harm in some people videoing what happened?
- monk_e_boy 11y agoBeing from the UK: It's a bit unseemly. Mind your own fucking business. Get permission. Don't be a twat... etc
- nitrogen 11y agoIt's interesting that this attitude persists in the face of (what we in the US are led to believe is) omnipresent Big Brother CCTV.
- monk_e_boy 11y agoThere is a lot of CCTV, but we also talk a lot about privacy. The argument "If you've got nothing to hide why do you shit with the door closed?" is pretty common here. We generally don't point CCTV at someone's house, and those CCTV that DO point at private property are usually dealt with quickly. After a complaint the police will just tell you to point it somewhere else. They are for protection, not for spying.
- switch007 11y agoWe didn't ask for or agree to that CCTV. Mega corporations installing CCTV all over London does not mean the British people are OK with being filmed 24/7.
- hammock 11y ago>Being from the UK: It's a bit unseemly. Mind your own fucking business. Does that apply to the 5.9 million surveillance cameras located in the UK? http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/10172298/One-surveillance-camera-for-every-11-people-in-Britain-says-CCTV-survey.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/10172298/One-surveilla...
- M2Ys4U 11y agoCCTV is one step removed from a human so the taboo isn't felt (as strongly)
- monk_e_boy 11y agoI replied to this question below. But I'd like to add that I'm not sure where the 5.5 million comes from. Where I live I spend 99.99% of my time NOT under CCTV surveillance. There is CCTV in town centres and in cities, but these are very public places. There is also CCTV in shopping centres and outside some houses, but not that much and most of it is to stop crime, not to spy.
- weavie 11y agoI think it's a reverence thing. Had things not worked out for the chap inevitably the footage would end up on Reddit where endless jokes and mockery would ensue.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "We appear to have no problem with that when it's photographers in third-world countries." There's a goal with those photographs. To make people aware and get them to help usually through donation. There is nothing to gain from a dozen people standing around videoing a man suffering under a bus in central London other than morbid curiosity. What will become of the videos those people made? What use do they have. If you can't help move on as you're probably in the way.
- anon4 11y agoIt's a hundred people lifting a bus in a coordinated action to help. That's something remarkable and we should have examples of it documented. As you can see, it ended on a news article about one hundred people lifting a bus in a coordinated action to help.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> That's something remarkable and we should have examples of it documented. Why though? What is gained from its documentation?
- kefka 11y agoPsychological case study. In many instances, the crowd will do nothing because collectively, nobody knows what needs done. Cases like this start from a core few somehow figuring out how to pierce the crowd-mind was able to get a bus lifted and someone saved. It would be a great way to figure out how to collectively amass people like this when the need arises, and use them for constructive good.
- 6d0debc071 11y ago> Is the concern filming someone in pain/suffering? Kinda? Filming with no other reason, no other commentary, than to reduce it to a cheap jape online or some element of personal amusement.... At least for myself, it falls under the set of 'Why would you want a record of this?' Whereas presumably people aren't - at least not often - jacking off or have a jolly good time over pictures of kids covered in napalm, or whatever, in the newest military adventure. There are, unquestionably, those who do enjoy war videos just for the sake of some momentary vicarious adrenaline drip granted them by the suffering portrayed. You know, the videos that pop up from time to time with rock music over the gun cams of helicopters and the like. But ... wouldn't you find it slightly worrying if you found someone watching one? Or if it was shown on the 10 o'clock news as an item of amusement? It's that sort of thing, at least to me. The recording implies really bad taste. Whether that's a cultural thing (I'm british too) or whether it's a more general thing I don't know.
- ekanes 11y agoIf these people were far away, or for some reason couldn't help, no problem film away. But I too would be upset with someone filming if there was room to help - here's someone under a bus - the right thing to do is try to save their life, not film the situation at his possible expense.
- iamcurious 11y agoMaybe it is because those filming weren't helping?
- akhatri_aus 11y agoIt seems a bit insulting to film it, why would they not help instead? Given the situation it kind of puts people standing out if people try to film it while everyone else is trying to help.
- celticninja 11y ago2 reasons, first they may be wearing the camera (think go pro) so you can film and help. Alternatively you got there a bit late and thre is no room to get involved so filming does no harm. It is different if the first person on the scene is standing over the injured party with a mobile phone held out to record them without providing any assistance e.g. calling 999/911/112 etc
- Symbiote 11y ago> I'm sorry, I fail to see what is so taboo about filming? There have been a couple of cases in the last few months where people have tweeted pictures of people who've killed themselves by jumping in front of trains. - http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/oct/17/police-condemn-onlooker-tweet-photo-body-rail-london http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/oct/17/police-condem... - http://www.herefordtimes.com/news/12928871.Fatality_on_the_line_near_Hereford_train_station___police_ask_public__not_to_film__the_scene/?ref=trn http://www.herefordtimes.com/news/12928871.Fatality_on_the_l... The concern is the deceased next-of-kin might find out via Twitter, which is considered inappropriate. It's also disrespectful.
- exclusiv 11y agoSuicide is disrespectful too. Plus, there are insurance implications. If someone commits suicide their heirs don't have right to insurance $. Documentation of a public act serves to surface the truth whether some people want to see it or not.