Suppose the question was "Which airlines ban whacking reclining passengers on the head with rubber chickens?", and I answered "Well, they don't specifically ban

Suppose the question was "Which airlines ban whacking reclining passengers on the head with rubber chickens?", and I answered "Well, they don't specifically ban assaults with rubber chickens, but any airline's T&C will have something banning violence against other passengers". Is my answer still off-topic? And how does this differ from what's essentially the same Q & A re: Knee Defenders? At the end of the day, the issue is that you can't tamper aircraft, not that you're doing it with a Knee Defender specifically.