3 ms·
Since it's a weekend, I believe the board is open to rampant speculation, and this is a good topic as any for it. I mostly lean towards C -- all civilizations
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Since it's a weekend, I believe the board is open to rampant speculation, and this is a good topic as any for it.
I mostly lean towards C -- all civilizations perish. But I think we use the word "perish" to mean some sort of cataclysmic end. That's probably not the case at all. As I look back on the last 300 years, I see mankind evolving more and more technologies. With each new evolution, people do less and less physical activity, and more and more emotion is put into virtual reality. The cataclysm won't be nuclear war -- we should be so lucky. The cataclysm will be eon after eon of inactivity and stagnation. (I already see this in the movement to "solve problems at home first" before space exploration and the "what right do we have to contaminate other planets" school of environmentalism.
I'd give B good odds as well -- good enough that there are probably thousands or millions of civilizations that survived. Also looking at patterns in our own evolution, I think machine-based intelligences operating at super-high bandwidths and living for millions of years would have as much in common with us as we do with ants. Do ants know that people exist? Probably not.
- randallsquared 17y agoFor your C to be the solution, you'd have to posit that all technological civilizations go this route. Maybe that'll turn out to be the case, but do you have a reason to think that, other than that it seems to be happening here?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoNone. A combination might be at work as well. Perhaps civilizations stagnate for so long that if they ever do evolve into a true space-faring species that they're so removed from our reality as to effectively have transcended it. This would explain the lack of contact, the observed trend of mankind, and the odds-on-favorite that something more advanced has to be out there somewhere.
- berntb 17y agoHmm... First, read up on the Orion project. Humanity could have had a technological infrastructure outside the atmosphere in the 1970s. (They sadly lost out to NASA politically.) An Orion exploration could generate money from extra-terrestrial mineral sources inside a not too long time window. Second, consider how much longer the virtual reality thing would take if we were half as fast at speeding up computers (3 years for Moore's law, not 1 1/2). A not unrealistic assumption for a civilization with some other focus. Third, consider if one of the small scale fusion projects (EMC, General Fusion, etc) works. Or a future idea. Then an Oort cloud would be livable, for a technological civilization. From that, it seems a large fraction of technological civilizations should not have all eggs on one planet/culture before cultural stagnation starts. And the groups further away would be able to see the problem happening to others and have a good chance to do things differently. In the same way, a physics experiment with "unexpected" results would need to destroy a whole solar system and not only a planet. The Fermi paradox should have some other answer.
- randallsquared 17y agoAnd the groups further away would be able to see the problem happening to others and have a good chance to do things differently. Well, the initial premise that all civilizations have this happen suggests that later groups wouldn't see it as a problem, but as a goal or path to the goal. There are groups here on Earth that seem to be resistant to the pull of the virtual, but all by resisting technologies of other kinds as well, so it could still be that any group capable of building advanced computing succumbs. There's a depressing thought: Dune as an accurate picture of the attitude towards computing in long-lived technological civilizations.
- berntb 17y agoTo be a bit cynical, most controlling ideologies are against any new way of living. Your argument needs that all the groups of leaders/high priests fails to control their subcultures, even far away from the central system/culture. Note that the argument needs that most every subculture fails at controlling its faithful in most every technological civilization... Doesn't really sound likely -- consider a North Korea or Salafism in the Oort cloud. Edit: A bit clearer and more grammatical, etc.