3 ms·
Do not confuse groupthink with analysis. Simply because a heckuva lot of smart people have studied an issue for decades does not mean -- at all -- that somehow
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Do not confuse groupthink with analysis.
Simply because a heckuva lot of smart people have studied an issue for decades does not mean -- at all -- that somehow they have made more progress than some schmuck reading about all of this for the first time in Newsweek. You do not get a free pass by being smart and asking a lot of questions.
(A side note: I find among academia the meme that somehow intelligence, hard work, and admiration of peers equates to progress. These are all great traits to have, but in themselves they don't automatically translate into solid value for posterity. In fact, in some fields there may actually be an inverse relationship)
Having said that, you are absolutely correct in saying that you should ask questions first. There's no point in getting everybody on the defensive.
But if the reply is "Look -- it's all very complicated, and we've thought about it a lot and we're way ahead of you here and this is the best plausible way to settle several internal arguments... etc, etc" then you have not received an adequate answer.
I applaud your appeal to being inquisitive and polite. I find your defense of this particular case, however, sorely lacking.