3 ms·
And this is why people who don't know science should ask questions first. The tree ring data, after a certain point in history, is no longer a reliable indicat
by btilly 17y ago
And this is why people who don't know science should ask questions first.
The tree ring data, after a certain point in history, is no longer a reliable indicator of local temperature changes. There is no explanation for why trees no longer reflect local temperature changes. We know that they no longer reflect local temperatures, presumably, because we have other more reliable measurements available now (measurements that are not available further back in history).
There is NO SINGLE EXPLANATION for the discrepancy. This is NOT the same as there being no explanation.
What happens instead is that if you look in specific localities you can find specific explanations. Increased acidity here. Drought conditions there. Insect infestations in another. And in yet another the correlation with temperatures remains.
What happened is that after 1960 due to large scale changes in environment in many localities the correlation broke down, so the overall correlation broke down. But there is no single explanation because in different areas the specific reasons differ.
This leaves us with a conundrum: is there any period in which alternative measurements and tree-ring measurements correspond with one another? Is the divergence between our measurements and the tree-rings something we can trace? Is it sudden or gradual? If there is no period in which there is a correspondence between our measurements and the tree-rings, what does this say about our assumption that tree-rings have ever accurately captured local temperatures?
Actually there is about a century of comparative data before that which shows a good correlation. That is why we are willing to project temperatures back farther using that record.
Now there is the possibility that there were previous periods which saw a similar breaking of the correlation. This question is a question of scientific debate.
It seems that the implication is that changes in the environment have rendered tree-rings unreliable. But if we're arguing that tree-rings are unreliable because of environmental change (i.e. the chemical changes to the composition of the atmosphere and water cycle that contribute to global warming), and we're seeking to explain environmental change, we're begging the question (assuming the explanandum in the premise of our argument).
There is no begging the question when we are also studying the mechanisms involved.
Until a causal mechanism for the divergence between tree-rings and other measured temperatures can be specified, how can they legitimately be discarded as evidence, without invoking tautological reasoning?
You are making two large assumptions here. The first is that there is a single causal mechanism. The second is the assumption that we don't actually understand the mechanisms involved. Both assumptions are wrong.
Look. Scientists aren't exactly stupid people. When they spend a lifetime studying something, you should assume that they've asked the obvious questions and try to find out the answers they have found rather than assuming that they are stupid and you're the first to notice the glaring issues.
Unfortunately climate scientists are also humans who are under constant assault from people who can't and won't be bothered to actually learn the record. People who feel they are under constant assault engage in defensive behavior. And people who are being defensive tend to circle the wagons and have difficulty in remaining open with outside groups.
When you encounter such defensive behavior I strongly recommend trying to understand what the defensive person's position is rather than immediately piling on and validating their defensiveness. If they are wrong, this approach leaves you in a better position to figure that out. But if they have a point, you'll be more likely to figure that out as well.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoDo not confuse groupthink with analysis. Simply because a heckuva lot of smart people have studied an issue for decades does not mean -- at all -- that somehow they have made more progress than some schmuck reading about all of this for the first time in Newsweek. You do not get a free pass by being smart and asking a lot of questions. (A side note: I find among academia the meme that somehow intelligence, hard work, and admiration of peers equates to progress. These are all great traits to have, but in themselves they don't automatically translate into solid value for posterity. In fact, in some fields there may actually be an inverse relationship) Having said that, you are absolutely correct in saying that you should ask questions first. There's no point in getting everybody on the defensive. But if the reply is "Look -- it's all very complicated, and we've thought about it a lot and we're way ahead of you here and this is the best plausible way to settle several internal arguments... etc, etc" then you have not received an adequate answer. I applaud your appeal to being inquisitive and polite. I find your defense of this particular case, however, sorely lacking.
- Perceval 17y agoThanks for the comprehensive answer! You've mentioned several mechanisms: acidity, drought, insects, and presumably more. This raises two comparative questions in my mind. First, changes in acidity, droughts, and insect infestations are certainly not events that are unique to the post-1960s environment. Do local temperature data from tree rings from prior time periods also show discontinuities during known periods of drought or insect infestation? Second, there have been large-scale changes to the environment in the past, some for a short period (the "year without a summer") some for a longer period (the "little ice age"). Do tree rings correlate with known large-scale temperature changes, or do they show discontinuities of the type we are witnessing in the post-1960 era? Look. Scientists aren't exactly stupid people. When they spend a lifetime studying something, you should assume that they've asked the obvious questions and try to find out the answers they have found rather than assuming that they are stupid and you're the first to notice the glaring issues. I agree, but as a PhD student, I've found that highlighting errors in methodology, even in peer reviewed articles, is actually pretty easy. You sound like you're familiar with research methodology, so you should know just as well as I do. When taking classes on methodology, one of the principal methods of learning is critiquing the research designs, assumptions, questions, data sets, etc. of other scientists who have been published. It's not hard to find methodological errors, or at least questionable assumptions and questionable glosses over complex issues, when reviewing even the published work of others. Unfortunately climate scientists are also humans who are under constant assault from people who can't and won't be bothered to actually learn the record. Because climate interaction is non-linear and operating on a macro- and long-term scale, it will obviously have a hard time standing up to Popperian standards of falsifiability, and the public is going to have a harder time gaining confidence in climate science's conclusions. Just because climate scientists are under assault from wingnuts who see them as a nefarious player in the Culture Wars doesn't mean that they are excused from answering questions about their methods, assumptions, and data.