3 ms·
How does the concrete not develop cracks when the building sways so much? Same for the lifts - why don't they hop out of their rails?
by mschuster91 11y ago
How does the concrete not develop cracks when the building sways so much? Same for the lifts - why don't they hop out of their rails?
- munchbunny 11y agoConcrete isn't entirely inflexible either, and it's typically reinforced with steel. Lifts as well - the materials have some ability to flex, and the rails for lifts have some headroom for imperfection. That's all quite intentional because we expect the lift to be in a building that will flex.
- brc 11y agoFor confirmation of this, stop a car sometime on a highway flyover bridge. These are mostly reinforced concrete. Even normal traffic makes it jump and rumble. A big truck going past makes them positively wobble. Concrete can be quite bendy.
- rmxt 11y agoNot much of the exterior shells of these super tall buildings are concrete. Those are the areas that are experiencing large deflections, i.e. are bending in response to the wind. The floor slabs are concrete, but they are essentially rigid and do not see much bending that would cause cracking. The notion of a shear wall and/or shear core allows for the strength of reinforced concrete in shear to be taken advantage of, while not exposing the concrete to deflections that would induce cracking. Not a "vertical transportation" guy, but elevators are often placed in the center of buildings, surrounded by shear walls precisely for the same reason that shear walls are. Less bending, less chance for displacements. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shear_wall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shear_wall
- rosser 11y agoPartly because the materials in question aren't infinitely rigid, and partly because the torsion is spread somewhat uniformly across the entire structure, and never concentrated at any one point.
- msandford 11y agoA building is say 500 feet tall. The top moves say 2 feet. In order for this to happen every 10 feet of the building doesn't shift sideways a certain amount. Every 10 feet of the building bends a certain amount. A VERY small amount. Tiny fractions of a degree. So the bottom 10 feet of the building bends say 0.001 degrees. The bottom is flat, the top is tilted 0.001 degrees. The next 10 feet bends an additional 0.001 degrees, but its base was already tilted 0.001 degrees so its top is tilted 0.002 degrees. The next 10 feet bends an additional 0.001 degrees, but its base was already tilted 0.002 degrees so its top is tilted 0.003 degrees. Repeat this 50 times (for 500 total feet) and you've got 0.050 degrees of tilt at the top which might be noticeable. Further, you have to add up displacements the whole way from the bottom to the top as well. If you took a picture of the building sideways it would look like this: http://www.codecogs.com/users/23287/Cantilever-Beams-101.png http://www.codecogs.com/users/23287/Cantilever-Beams-101.png
- mturmon 11y agoI like your reasoning, but I wonder about magnitudes. Since: 10 feet/story * sin(0.001 degree) = .00017 feet/story then: 50 stories * .00017 feet/story = .0085 feet [building] If things added up this way, your magnitudes would be way off. In fact, since sin(x) is linear for small x, you'd need about 100x more angle to get 100x more deflection. 100x more deflection would be about 0.85 feet one way, or 1.70 feet peak-to-peak. Two feet peak-to-peak for 50 stories matches some of the figures quoted in the article for buildings of this scale ("A hundred-story building, by comparison, may move on the order of two-and-a-half to three feet to each side..."). However, on reflection, I think the offsets cumulate quadratically. Because: * \ \ [story 2] \ | | [story 1] | The first story has an angular offset, but the angular offset of the second story adds to that of the first, etc. This must be common knowledge among structural engineers. In that case, since we can just add all the displacements, the appropriate quadratic multiplier would be 50 * 49/2 = 1225, not just 50, and the total displacement is: 1225 * .00017 feet/story = 0.21 feet. This would mean your original, very tiny, angles were only about 5x too low. Nice work!
- msandford 11y ago