3 ms·
Uni-level math on the reals always bugged me for the exact reason that I thought well-defined problems not involving funny self-reference tricks ought to have a
by eli_gottlieb 11y ago
Uni-level math on the reals always bugged me for the exact reason that I thought well-defined problems not involving funny self-reference tricks ought to have algorithms. Despite this, math professors kept presenting us with patterns to match, but no exhaustive algorithms.
Little did I know, considering the reals are uncountable, so you can't really come up with exhaustive algorithms for lots of things dealing with them.
- JadeNB 11y agoPerhaps you would like to study constructive analysis, a la Bishop? You lose a lot of intuition in the hypotheses, which necessarily become more complicated—or perhaps I should say that you are forced to develop a different intuition about hypotheses—but you gain conclusions of exactly the sort that you want. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructive_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructive_analysis EDIT: Also, the fact that a structure is uncountable doesn't prevent you from operating algorithmically on it (not that you claimed it did!); it just means that there are some elements of it that cannot be singled out algorithmically.
- xyzzyz 11y ago> Despite this, math professors kept presenting us with patterns to match, but no exhaustive algorithms. This is basically what math is all about. If a problem can be effectively and easily solved algorithmically, it is considered trivial, and little attention is given to it. The focus is on actually difficult problems, ones that need clever tricks to get a handle of.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoTo be frank: bull. A problem that can always be solved algorithmically is "trivial", in the mathematical sense, but since the mind is algorithmic, you can't just say, "Well, clever tricks, not algorithms." A mathematician's mind works somehow.
- JadeNB 11y ago> the mind is algorithmic Huh? If you mean this: > A mathematician's mind works somehow. then it seems like you may be using 'algorithmic' to mean something like "unfolding according to (possibly unknown, possibly probabilistic) laws", in which case it seems so broad a term as to be almost useless.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>then it seems like you may be using 'algorithmic' to mean something like "unfolding according to (possibly unknown, possibly probabilistic) laws" They're certainly currently unknown, and we have good reason to believe they're probabilistic. Even such vague, loose descriptions are better than invoking "mathematical intuition" or "it just comes to me" or other explanations for how one does math.