4 ms·
> Obviously agreements will be public before they become law (nobody disputes this) Obviously? They've already fast tracked it even before it is available to t
by Someone1234 11y ago
> Obviously agreements will be public before they become law (nobody disputes this)
Obviously? They've already fast tracked it even before it is available to the public. They've made it available to members of congress without it being available to the public. While on paper they might release it just before it became law, they could easily release it a week before giving nobody time to mount a real challenge.
I'd have no issue if I thought it was going to take six months to pass, and members of the public could have a say, but fast tracking makes that highly unlikely.
- twoodfin 11y agoNot to put too fine a point on it, but members of the (U.S.) public had their say when they voted for their President, Senators and Congressfolk. Who, not coincidentally, negotiate all sorts of critically important legislation in private. Besides, the version of TPA under consideration by the House this month requires that any agreement be public for at least 60 days before it can be signed by the President and submitted to Congress for enabling legislation.
- imron 11y ago> but members of the (U.S.) public had their say when they voted for their President, Senators and Congressfolk. That's not how it works. If it was, we'd have SOPA, but we don't. Citizens telling their representatives what they do and don't want is fundamental aspect of a well-functioning democracy.
- dragonwriter 11y agoAgreed, there are few more harmful concepts to a representative democracy, especially one with as poor of an electoral system as the US, but any representative democracy as well, as the idea that citizen input begins and ends with voting. It's like saying a boss's input on an employee's work is limited to hiring and firing.
- twoodfin 11y agoAnd no trade agreement has ever become law without months of Congressional hearings and debate. The proposed version of TPA would guarantee at least two, and at least four is what's likely. So what's the point again?
- EliRivers 11y agoWell then, the only conclusion is that by design you don't have this well-functioning democracy. The people at the top certainly don't think they should listen. RECENTLY, when Vice-President Cheney was asked by ABC News correspondent Martha Raddatz about polls showing that an overwhelming majority of US citizens oppose the war in Iraq, he replied, "So?" "So — you don't care what the American people think?" Raddatz asked. "No," Cheney replied, and explained, "I think you cannot be blown off course by the fluctuations in public opinion polls." Later, White House spokeswoman Dana Perino, explaining Cheney's comments, was asked whether the public should have "input." Her reply: "You had your input. The American people have input every four years, and that's the way our system is set up." That's correct. Every four years the American people can choose between candidates whose views they reject, and then they should shut up. http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20080403.htm http://www.chomsky.info/articles/20080403.htm
- imron 11y ago> Well then, the only conclusion is that by design you don't have this well-functioning democracy Yes. I would agree that the US is not a well-functioning democracy.
- Shivetya 11y agoTo be blunt more than most on this very site were just fat dumb and happy when the FCC fast tracked their rules changes without prior publication, in fact some were insisting on it to quell debate. There is one simple rule, apply the same standards to all or you have no leg to stand on. Far too many people dismiss the rules when they think the outcome is one they may like; even if that decision is one hundred percent ignorant of facts
- anigbrowl 11y agoFast tracked means it goes through an up-or-down vote instead of the appalling amendment process Congress usually prefers, which makes no sense in an international trade agreement. They've made it available to members of congress without it being available to the public. Yes. So they can do the jobs they were elected to do - represent your interest. I'd have no issue if I thought it was going to take six months to pass, and members of the public could have a say, but fast tracking makes that highly unlikely. Honestly, I don't think the public is really competent to form opinions on most of this. >>90% of the complaints I see about trade deals are uninformed, counterfactual, and ignorant. This doesn't mean I think all trade deals are necessarily perfect by any means, but the signal:noise ratio is appalling.
- noelsusman 11y agoIt will be fully public for 60 days before Congress gets a chance to vote for it. Fast tracking just means Congress cannot amend the bill, they can only vote up or down. Opposing fast tracking is essentially the same thing as opposing the entire deal. Our negotiators would be in much weaker positions since other countries would have no reason to believe anything they say.