2 ms·
(revisionists trying to discredit scientists instead of providing data) If you claim P=NP, and I show a flaw in your proof, am I also required to provide a pro
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
(revisionists trying to discredit scientists instead of providing data)
If you claim P=NP, and I show a flaw in your proof, am I also required to provide a proof of my own? Of course not.
This is how science should work; both scientists, their competitors, and anyone else with a passing interest will carefully try to discredit existing work. In this case, it looks like a specific attempt to discredit it failed.
You are correct that creating proper charts off proper data would be the best solution. Unfortunately, much of the data has been "lost", making this impossible.
- DannoHung 17y agoScience isn't math.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI don't recall claiming it was. I simply used an example most people here would be familiar with; my broader point remains unchanged for data analysis. One can legitimately critique an analysis of data without providing new data or even performing a correct analysis.
- Tichy 17y agoIt seems I am missing the "trying to discredit" part, where is that from? So far I also haven't seen any "flaws in proofs". I have only seen words like "trick, milk data" that can or can not mean bad things - take your pick depending on what you want to believe.
- ewjordan 17y agoI think the parent post was saying that the "revisionists" like to pick out weak points in one particular small result, and try to unfairly imply that all of the larger results in the field must be wrong, as well, without touching on any of the data or arguments in support of those results. This is what happens in the evolution debate on a regular basis: someone comes up with some minor technical complaint about peppered moth observation, spends a long time debating it, and then declares that evolution is "in controversy" despite the fact that even if their complaints were valid, there are thousands of other pieces of evidence in favor of the larger theory. I don't know enough about global warming to know if its critics are merely hacking away at a weak sapling to draw our attention away from the dense forest that they can't cut their way through. But I know that tactic has been applied in the past, so I don't think it's unreasonable to wonder. Scientists tend to get caught up arguing over whatever particular claim is being criticized, but I think in this situation, it would serve the climate scientists well to point the public eye towards less vulnerable data and claims, if they're out there...
- Tichy 17y agoSorry I missed how you mean a flaw in the proof. The thing about evolution theory is that evolution is a stochastic process. So there tend to be not precise predictions, just likelihoods. Also, it is being applied in thousands (or millions) of cases to explain complex systems. If sometimes somebody who applies it gets it wrong (like say some biologist trying to make sense of bone findings and creating a theory of the evolution of some species or other), it does not refute the whole of evolution theory. It only refutes that particular application. It is like physics: millions of buildings have been built employing Newtons laws. Sometimes an architect gets it wrong and the building falls down. But that doesn't refute the laws of physics - it is just some guy or a team of builders making an error.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI'm not disagreeing with that. AGW may be true while the corrections to this data series may be false, and this data series may be only a small piece to the puzzle. However, fraud and errors are different. Science is (to a great extend) based on trust. When I referee a paper, I trust that Fig 1 is really generated by Algorithm 2 if the caption says so. If it turns out that Fig 1 is photoshopped, my report is meaningless. Peer review is meant to find mistakes and evaluate importance, not eliminate fraud. If a scientist cheats, we must consider all their work to be flawed until they can prove otherwise (i.e., release all data, code, etc). We need to stop and scrutinize all the fruit of their poisoned tree. AGW may be true, and the science may be solid. But until we have more openness, we will never really know.
- Retric 17y agoScience is (to a great extend) based on trust. No, it's easier to assume trust, but science works best when there is almost zero trust in any single authority. This is why it's expected for you to present your methods, data, math, and then your conclusions. Ignoring malice a tiny mistake can drastically change an experiments outcome. So an experiment yet to be independently verified is next to worthless, but it's not sexy to work like that and it does not help your reputation. Edit: IMO, what's missing from this discussion is the idea that independently verifying their results is a reasonable thing to do. This does not mean plugging their numbers into their code and looking at the results but starting from scratch using their methods and testing it yourself. PS: One of the reasons that social science has such a poor reputation is the willingness to accept minuscule sample sizes as representing real research. A little less trust would go a long way to revitalizing those fields. Unfortunately neuroscience seems to be falling for this trap.