8 ms·
How Much Do Skyscrapers Actually Move?
- paulannesley 11y agoThe answer to the title question seems to be: > Inside the building, on those top floors, the oscillation is what unnerves us. A forty-story building may sway a foot to the left, a foot to the right. The span of that period might last around four seconds. A hundred-story building, by comparison, may move on the order of two-and-a-half to three feet to each side, cycling through a ten-second period. Typically, the taller the building, the longer the period of its cyclical motion. And the implicit question of how much movement we feel: > Acceleration is what causes the body forces that might tip us off our firmly planted feet, or nudge us back into the passenger seat of a car pulling away from a stoplight. Fighter pilots experience acceleration at many times the magnitude of gravity—“4 Gs” or more. The top of our hundred-story skyscraper accelerates through its period, as it sways from one side to the other, at a mere fraction of what a fighter pilot feels: maybe ten milli-g’s, or one hundredth of the force of gravity.
- jameshart 11y agoSurely it's not actually acceleration that you feel most of the time. A constant acceleration is, after all, indistinguishable from constant gravity, and so small acceleration vectors which, when added together with the local gravity vector, are still just a little more or less than 1 g, aren't really detectable - they just feel like gravity is pointing in a different direction. Obviously larger accelerations are detectable as being 'not quite like normal gravity'. When it takes different-to-normal effort to move your limbs, your body gives you feedback about it. What you can feel is change in acceleration - a sudden change in the direction your body perceives as 'down'. Braking in a car doesn't feel much different to driving down a hill, but when the car's speed reaches zero and suddenly stops decelerating, the jerk as gravity snaps back to vertical is definitely noticeable. It's the jerk, not the acceleration, that throws you off your feet when you're standing on the subway and it pulls into or out of a station.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI'm afraid the OP had it right. Constant acceleration is what you feel when you are standing on the ground, and feeling the earth pressing against your feet. Just as you would feel standing in a rocket accelerating constantly. If the rocket were moving at a constant motion, you would be floating weightlessly inside it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dperfect 11y ago> Constant acceleration is what you feel when you are standing on the ground Acceleration only occurs when there's a change in velocity. What you feel while standing on the ground is a constant force, but due to the normal force (of equal magnitude but opposite direction) of your feet pushing back on the ground, no acceleration occurs. The rocket on the other hand is accelerating, and that acceleration causes the normal force between your body and your chair to accelerate your body with the rocket.
- jameshart 11y agoYou're going to have to take that one up with Einstein: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivalence_principle
- rosser 11y agoThere seems to be a colloquial usage of the word "acceleration" that only means "change in acceleration". It's not strictly correct, but it's pretty par for the accuracy on a Kinja property.
- userbinator 11y agoAnd the technical term for it is actually the jerk: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerk_(physics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerk_(physics)
- dmlorenzetti 11y agoFor a fascinating read on the intersection of buildings, wind dynamics, and a litigious society, see "The Fifty-Nine Story Crisis" [0]. The article describes the response of the architect/engineer of the Citicorp Tower, when he realized that the building would topple like a domino in winds that could be expected at least once every 16 years. [0] http://people.duke.edu/~hpgavin/cee421/citicorp1.htm http://people.duke.edu/~hpgavin/cee421/citicorp1.htm
- sosuke 11y agoThis damper movement video was really incredible to see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYSgd1XSZXc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYSgd1XSZXc The small scale demos just don't do it justice. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Taipei_101 https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Taipei_101
- Gravityloss 11y agoWhy did you link through Wikiwand? It's some annoying overlay on Wikipedia that makes the window really small? Here's the direct Wikipedia link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipei_101 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipei_101
- bglusman 11y agoIt's actually a browser plugin to restyle^H^H^H^H^H um actually not restyle, redirect from wikipedia to same page on wikiwand? I think it looks nice but hadn't used it before... curious if sosuke has any connection to them, but it seemed more interesting when I thought it was just restyling... the redirect to their own domain is a bit weird...
- sosuke 11y agoHa, no it was just a mindless copy paste.
- boardwaalk 11y agoSomewhat related. Not a skyscraper, but a container ship: https://youtu.be/NE_ri8PkihE https://youtu.be/NE_ri8PkihE Impressive and unsettling.
- Someone 11y agoOn a smaller scale, you can see subway trains bend when going into a turn (where the outer rail will be a bit higher than the inner one)
- 11y ago
- mschuster91 11y agoHow does the concrete not develop cracks when the building sways so much? Same for the lifts - why don't they hop out of their rails?
- munchbunny 11y agoConcrete isn't entirely inflexible either, and it's typically reinforced with steel. Lifts as well - the materials have some ability to flex, and the rails for lifts have some headroom for imperfection. That's all quite intentional because we expect the lift to be in a building that will flex.
- brc 11y agoFor confirmation of this, stop a car sometime on a highway flyover bridge. These are mostly reinforced concrete. Even normal traffic makes it jump and rumble. A big truck going past makes them positively wobble. Concrete can be quite bendy.
- rmxt 11y agoNot much of the exterior shells of these super tall buildings are concrete. Those are the areas that are experiencing large deflections, i.e. are bending in response to the wind. The floor slabs are concrete, but they are essentially rigid and do not see much bending that would cause cracking. The notion of a shear wall and/or shear core allows for the strength of reinforced concrete in shear to be taken advantage of, while not exposing the concrete to deflections that would induce cracking. Not a "vertical transportation" guy, but elevators are often placed in the center of buildings, surrounded by shear walls precisely for the same reason that shear walls are. Less bending, less chance for displacements. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shear_wall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shear_wall
- rosser 11y agoPartly because the materials in question aren't infinitely rigid, and partly because the torsion is spread somewhat uniformly across the entire structure, and never concentrated at any one point.
- 11y ago
- stox 11y agoI used to work on the 97th floor of the Sears Tower. On a really windy day, we would get downright seasick.
- firethief 11y ago> Humans are also terrible at perceiving velocity at a constant speed. This is not so much a quirk of our species as a physical impossibility
- matthewmcg 11y agoWhen the World Trade Center towers were being planned, the builders discovered that nobody really knew how much sway occupants of tall buildings could tolerate. Wind tunnel tests showed that the (relatively) light buildings would sway more than expected and the builders feared that any publicity about this would scuttle the project. They began conducting two secret research programs. One investigated methods of dissipating energy to reduce sway. The other determined how much a room could move before occupants noticed it. This second investigation was conducted under the pretense of "free vision exams." Participants were led into a room that was (unbeknownst to them) mounted on rails and moved by hydraulic rams. The amount of simulated sway was increased until somebody spoke up. The engineers eventually determined that the sway could be brought within acceptable (though still detectable) levels by installing viscoelastic dampers between the floor joists and the building's perimeter columns. The whole story is told in the 2003 book City in the Sky, which is a fascinating read.
- wldcordeiro 11y agoThat's a really interesting way to go about it, I like that solution. I'll have to check the book out.
- iaw 11y agoThere's a really fascinating and relevant 99% Invisible [1] on a building with insufficient sway damping leading to potential for collapse. If I recall, a student discovers the issue while running calculations for a class and reached out to the architecture firm. Worth a listen if you haven't heard. [1] - http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/structural-integrity/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/structural-integrity/
- adam74 11y agoA lot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HB2jgJJG2is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HB2jgJJG2is
- z3t4 11y agoI wonder if you get "land" dizziness after spending time in a tall building!?