3 ms·
> Google knows that when I search for Django I want the web framework That isn't a good thing. http://dontbubble.us http://dontbubble.us Unless Jamie Fox some
by stephenr 11y ago
> Google knows that when I search for Django I want the web framework
That isn't a good thing. http://dontbubble.us http://dontbubble.us
Unless Jamie Fox someday starts giving speeches about Django framework, this sounds like a pretty weak excuse to use a google-style (i.e. 'personalised') search engine.
> I think option 1 is more likely for Apple.
Google's business model is basically selling aggregated user data - not in the form of raw data but in the form of targeted ads - for $0 (note, they aren't "free") services.
Apple's business model is about selling hardware and software, and providing a fairly complete ecosystem to use those products in/with.
Given that Apple's iOS+ecosystem accounts for close to 90% of the profits in the smartphone market, I don't understand this claim by people "Apple will have to adopt google's strategy to remain competitive".
If anything people are becoming more sensitive and more aware about the "creepy" factor of having all your personal information in the hands of some corporation that uses it for profit.
- thomasfoster96 11y ago> That isn't a good thing. Well, the search engine I'm using not being able to find what I'm looking for is also a not a good thing. I quite like DuckDuckGo, but 10% of the time DuckDuckGo falters on a search and I have to put in a '!g'. Clearly, you can't be the absolute no. 1 search engine accross almost all queries without using some degree of personalisation. As for a search bubble, Google and DuckDuckGo just take two highly opposing views. In reality, I'd love to be able to turn personalised search on and off at will, but neither DuckDuckGo or Google are going to let me do that any time soon.
- collyw 11y agoI have duck duck go set as my default, but when I want to get something specific and quickly, I often have to use the "g!" option. DDG works well for more "mainstream" searches but for niche stuff the results are not as good.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> That isn't a good thing. http://dontbubble.us http://dontbubble.us I don't get the argument being presented there. In either situation, some information is visible, and other information is buried. Presenting the same top results to everyone is just as bad of a bubble.
- stephenr 11y agoeveryone seeing the same results for the same search terms is inherently not a "bubble"
- ceejayoz 11y agoSure it is. Everyone's exposed to the "average" person's top 10 or so results. With personalized results, potentially millions of different pages are exposed as the top 10 or so results depending on who's searching. You get stuff that's a little more relevant to your usual interests, which places you in your own bubble, but IMO that's better than everyone in the world being in the same shared bubble.
- stephenr 11y ago> Sure it is. I don't think you understand the term "search bubble". It's a bubble because you're cut off from the rest of the world, like the boy in the bubble. The only way everyone getting the same results is a "bubble" is if you consider us living within the atmosphere of Earth as being in a "bubble". > You get stuff that's a little more relevant to your usual interests Did you even read the linked page? Claiming that getting results that are in-line with your pre-disposed ideas (which are expressed through the profile Google/etc have of you) is like claiming that a board of directors full of yes-men is a great recipe for success.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> It's a bubble because you're cut off from the rest of the world, like the boy in the bubble. Everyone getting the same narrow set of search results for a term based on global popularity means everyone's cut off from more diverse search results. We've seen research that indicates people click only the top couple results. IMO, that's a big bubble. > Claiming that getting results that are in-line with your pre-disposed ideas (which are expressed through the profile Google/etc have of you) is like claiming that a board of directors full of yes-men is a great recipe for success. And giving everyone the same results is like having a single board of directors for everyone.