>You're arguing over semantics. Selling a product (ads) that is a direct result of having that data is basically selling that data. For some definition of "bas

>You're arguing over semantics. Selling a product (ads) that is a direct result of having that data is basically selling that data. For some definition of "basically" that means "not whatsoever". Selling involves exchanging money for goods or services with another party (to paraphrase Homer Simpson).