If we were in a formal debate, you'd be right. But we're not. The original poster's point is that ESR shouldn't even be admitted into the debate. Personally,

If we were in a formal debate, you'd be right. But we're not. The original poster's point is that ESR shouldn't even be admitted into the debate. Personally, I'm ignoring everything I read about this story unless it there's evidence that it comes from someone who has invested some serious effort into the subject.