4 ms·
Those temporary social issues (and they will be temporary, just while society adjusts) cannot possibly compare to the travesty of a hundred thousand people dyin
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Those temporary social issues (and they will be temporary, just while society adjusts) cannot possibly compare to the travesty of a hundred thousand people dying every day.
- qsymmachus 11y agoCall me a "deathist" if you like, but dying of natural causes at a ripe old age is not a travesty.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThat's entirely your choice, as long as you don't force anyone else to follow you. Consider, however, whether you'd choose to die if you had an alternative, or whether you've simply accepted something horrific because you don't think you can do anything about it.
- LaurentD2 11y agoNot dying is entirely your choice, as long as you do not consume the resources that younger generations need. If you do not die and plan to stay on Earth, then you will have a (probably very negative) impact on other people's lives. They can choose not to accept it.
- dysfunction 11y ago> If you do not die and plan to stay on Earth, Where else could you possibly go? Sending you anywhere else (like a terraformed Mars) might cost more resources than would keeping you alive on Earth for hundreds of years.
- M8 11y agoWhat about people who have 3+ kids instead of 2, while some people can only have 1? Can we choose not to accept it?
- qsymmachus 11y agoSociety has a right to ban radical life extension if we judge that the social costs outweigh the benefits. Whether that is the case is what is up for debate.
- oldmanjay 11y agoSociety has the right to try, but banning things has this way of not actually working, so it's probably best to plan for the reality that if it can happen, it will.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Society has the right to try It really, really doesn't. Note the first item "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness", or the equivalents in other fundamental statements of rights.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI really, really hope you're being a devil's advocate and you don't actually advocate mass murder of the elderly to make room for the young. If your society attempted to commit mass murder, your society would be removed by force and replaced by one that did not. And if that sounds like hyperbole, so does the concept that all societies would intentionally withhold a cure to the single most deadly affliction humanity suffers from: aging.
- qsymmachus 11y agoThere is a big difference between arguing that radical life extension could have serious social and environmental costs, and arguing that we should execute the elderly. Death is not an unmitigated evil, nor is eternal youth an unmitigated good. I don't think that's a radical argument.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> There is a big difference between arguing that radical life extension could have serious social and environmental costs, and arguing that we should execute the elderly. I agree. Discussing ways to solve those problems would be an aspect of the former, which is completely reasonable. However, at the point where you suggested that society could ban life extension, you started arguing for the latter. Follow your argument to its logical conclusion. What are you proposing, and what would the effect be? You suggested intentionally withholding a cure for a degenerative disease (namely, aging). How else could that possibly be interpreted? > Death is not an unmitigated evil, nor is eternal youth an unmitigated good. I don't think that's a radical argument. It's safe to say that's our fundamental point of disagreement. Personally, I plan to address that disagreement by continuing to donate to fund the development of effective treatments for aging, as well as the development of longer-term cures for mortality. At the point where those treatments become more widely available, arguments against them will start looking a lot sillier.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's a cultural perspective. If you didn't expect everyone you meet to eventually die within a hundred years, the fact that they all were would be a travesty. In some respect, it's no different than if everyone died at fifty years of age. That's a travesty, yet something close to that was the norm for millennia. We expect more now.
- LaurentD2 11y agoPeople dying is beneficial to humanity in countless ways. People not dying is the "travesty", and preventing death is probably one of the worst things you could do to humanity.
- astazangasta 11y agoNo, death is a travesty. While it may be true that overpopulation is worse, death is awful. Painful, slow degeneration over decades as your body systems shut down and your loved ones watch. What a gain it would be to have people continue their productive lives for decades or centuries longer. The costs: we would give up having children. The replacement rate for an immortal race must be very low. The weight of old, bad ideas might be harder to shake off.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deciplex 11y ago> The weight of old, bad ideas might be harder to shake off. This sort of thinking seems to me a consequence of assuming that brains are somehow separate from the rest of the body, almost bordering on dualism. They might be easier to shake off, and I suspect this to be the case, if all human brains are rejuvenated brains with 25 year-old physiology. It is not clear that "old people set in their ways" is a result of minds that have simply been around a long time, regardless of their physical condition (i.e. immortal or not), as opposed to a consequence of a physically aging, deteriorating human brain. So we might find ourselves with the equivalent of a population composed entirely of twenty or thirty-somethings, except some of them happen to have many decades (eventually centuries and millenniums) of experience. We may well be much better off than now.
- RyanMcGreal 11y agoSo do you volunteer to stop taking vaccines, treating bacterial infections with antibiotics, reject medical intervention in the case of acute injury, etc? I rather doubt it, even though we take all these radical inventions in the prevention of death for granted.