3 ms·
Maybe GitHub themselves should just stop accepting keys of a certain length. For example <2048 RSA keys (and <256 ECDSA keys). They could also check against the
by Someone1234 11y ago
Maybe GitHub themselves should just stop accepting keys of a certain length. For example <2048 RSA keys (and <256 ECDSA keys). They could also check against the Debian set.
As the article says, GitHub could be being proactive rather than reactive here. They don't "have" to, but they could.
- benjojo12 11y agoGitHub now, after reporting this to them do not allow keys below 1023 to be added, and all keys that had been smaller than that, have been removed and owners of those keys got a email like screenshot on the top of the post
- Noelkd 11y agoAccording to a 2009 blog post[1]: > Thanks to our new servers, known bad keys[2] from Debian and Ubuntu are now blacklisted. We estimate that about 1000 keys in our database were impacted by this. If you get authentication errors using keys that worked a day ago, please double-check that they are not on our blacklist. If they are, you should ensure your software is updated and generate new keys. We’ve got a guide to help you out with this. [1] https://github.com/blog/500-state-of-the-hub-rackspace-day-0 https://github.com/blog/500-state-of-the-hub-rackspace-day-0 [2] https://github.com/blog/63-ssh-keys-generated-on-debian-ubuntu-compromised https://github.com/blog/63-ssh-keys-generated-on-debian-ubun...
- scintill76 11y agoWoah, this new article says a lot of weak-Debian keys were found. Does this mean Github had a regression in their blacklisting since 2009? Or maybe they didn't blacklist enough originally?
- Noelkd 11y agoOr the list used contained keys that weren't actually weak debian keys?
- viraptor 11y agoActually the facts are not incompatible here. There are two questions: Are weak Debian keys accepted in the web app? Are weak Debian keys accepted by their SSH. The answers were yes and no. It's the same for most systems right now. You can put a weak Debian key in authorised keys, but you won't be able to login anyway.