4 ms·
Considering the DMA vulnerabilities of thunderbolt, that's not too far off. At least until we have some sort of IOMMU-based hotplug device firewalls in our ope
by the8472 11y ago
Considering the DMA vulnerabilities of thunderbolt, that's not too far off.
At least until we have some sort of IOMMU-based hotplug device firewalls in our operating systems.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoUSB 3.0 has DMA too.
- the8472 11y agoBut is that remote DMA? Controller/driver-managed DMA transfers in the fashion of "shovel the next X incoming kilobytes to this memory range" is not the same as arbitrary writes to host memory initiated by a device.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoAh, maybe it isn't, fair point.
- rasz_pl 11y agoOn USB only Host is allowed to be a bus master. Thunderbold does PCI/PCIe and by extension allows any plugged gizmo to take over whole computer.
- lvh 11y agoIsn't that already the case? Current-gen Intel and AMD platforms have IOMMUs; Linux supports them. Linux and Windows support disabling DMA without disabling the rest of e.g. Firewire.
- the8472 11y agoThat's for a specific firewire protocol. Thunderbolt exposes PCIe-lanes, so you can pretty much attach any pcie-device that has drivers. If there are any drivers that do not use the IOMMU properly (just pass through everything?) then we're back to square one. And I don't think all drivers are iommu-aware. The system should only hotplug devices/drivers with user approval.