3 ms·
The reason generally given is that in at least standard cars the brakes can apply far more torque than the engine can. It's telling how naive people are, they t
by Gibbon1 11y ago
The reason generally given is that in at least standard cars the brakes can apply far more torque than the engine can. It's telling how naive people are, they think the problem is 'unintended acceleration' A mechanical engineer thinks the problem describe is 'unintended brake failure'
- jessaustin 11y agoAnd if the brakes won't stop the car, try the key switch! An engine that is not running will not cause acceleration. (Sure there are probably some oddball push-button ignitions that can't be turned off while in gear, but most vehicles can be.)
- fr0sty 11y agoTurning off the ignition may deactivate your airbags* which could make a bad situation worse.You would be much better off attempting to shift your car into Neutral first. * This was what made the GM Ingnition switch problem so deadly. The engine shut off (taking power steering and vaccuum-assist braking with it) and the airbags deactivated making any subsequent crash less survivable.
- jessaustin 11y agoYou're right that shifting is better. That is a pretty terrible failure mode for airbags, however. How much would it cost to put a big reliable capacitor in the airbag circuit, to keep the power on for 30 seconds? A dollar?
- yaakov34 11y agoAbsolutely right. After reading any number of stories about these "runaway death machines", what becomes clear is that the only realistic way for a car to accelerate at full power against the wishes of the driver is for the driver to be flooring the gas while thinking he is on the brakes. We should be adding smarter automatic systems to the cars to assist drivers, rather than e.g. throwing out drive-by-wire linkages and replacing them with mechanics, which are generally less reliable. There are already cars which will slam on the brakes in any collision which is strong enough to deploy airbags - it stops the car from careening around too much. It should be possible for cars to detect an impending collision and slam the brakes 1/2 second early to prevent or reduce it.