5 ms·
McIntyre: The deleted data from the “Hide the Decline” trick
- nfnaaron 17y agoI'll probably never know what the data supports (although I'm admittedly skeptical), but I do know that discussing deleting emails and data to avoid responding to an FOI request is probably illegal, and definitely casts a cloud on everything else the participants have touched.
- sriramk 17y ago+1. I have lots of sympathy for emails being taken out of context, internal jargon looking weird when shown in public. But asking someone to delete email/data is just wrong and can't be explained away. I find it sad that there hasn't been an official response to that specific email thread. I also wonder whether it might be borderline illegal.
- Tichy 17y agoI didn't read the "ask somebody to delete data" part in that email? Also I think there have been official statements (I think the other article that was posted, about the "climate researcher who engages skeptics", mentioned the response).
- ionfish 17y agoThe CRU have publicly asserted that they have not deleted emails or data. "No record has been deleted, altered, or otherwise dealt with in any fashion with the intent of preventing the disclosure of all, or any part, of the requested information." http://www.uea.ac.uk/mac/comm/media/press/2009/nov/homepagenews/CRUupdate http://www.uea.ac.uk/mac/comm/media/press/2009/nov/homepagen...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 17y agoPhil Jones, Wed Dec 3 13:57:09 2008: About 2 months ago I deleted loads of emails, so have very little - if anything at all. http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=940&filename=1228330629.txt http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=940&filen... Hat tip: Steve McIntyre. http://camirror.wordpress.com/2009/11/24/denying-email-deletion/ http://camirror.wordpress.com/2009/11/24/denying-email-delet...
- ionfish 17y agoDeleting emails is not the same as deleting emails to prevent disclosure. I delete emails all the time; I presume everyone does. The email being quoted here doesn't say anything about why Jones "deleted loads of emails". You are inferring more than is warranted.
- jacoblyles 17y ago>"Mike, Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4? Keith will do likewise. He’s not in at the moment – minor family crisis. Can you also email Gene and get him to do the same? I don’t have his new email address. We will be getting Caspar to do likewise. … Cheers Phil" http://camirror.wordpress.com/2009/11/25/willis-eschenbachs-foi-request/ http://camirror.wordpress.com/2009/11/25/willis-eschenbachs-...
- 10ren 17y agoJust a side question: I hardly ever delete emails (except for automatic reminders etc), and I always assumed that's the standard thing (I'm using gmail). But ionfish deletes emails, so I'm questioning my assumption. Do you delete emails?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI never delete any emails. I find with several years of emails and a good search engine, it's like having a super memory.
- 17y ago
- tlack 17y agothe real nightmare here is that this is going to cast a huge shadow on legitimate climate research -- and science in general -- for many years to come. these douchebags need to rot in jail for a long time.
- fnid 17y agoIt's a bit extreme to put them in jail. I too think their actions are deplorable, but jail? We didn't even put the criminals behind the financial collapse in jail, why put morally reprehensible scientists in jail? I'd say the financial criminals caused more problems than the climate team.
- tlack 17y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, and I'm not a British citizen so my understanding of the nature of publicly funded work may be a bit different, but if they are colluding to change the results of a study paid for with public monies and destroy evidence requested by an official inquiry, isn't that sufficient cause for criminal charges? The coordinated aspect of their fraud -- exemplified in the leaked emails -- adds a damning, worrisome aspect to the whole affair. On a sociological level, this is a very dangerous situation. The impact of human endeavor and pollution on global climate is almost impossible to judge on a local personal level, so the public must have faith in the scientists we elect to study this problem. Criminal charges would send a strong, immediate signal to scientists in all areas of research: check your personal opinions at the door when processing data. We are all human but if we allow this kind of thing to creep into all areas of research we risk undermining the very scientific underpinnings of our modern secular approach to public policy and, ultimately, the governance of our natural resources. Scientific research must remain balanced. As an aside: the people behind the economic crisis are not in jail, but they should be. Just because they have so far escaped the reach of justice doesn't mean we should lower our standards for other blatant crimes just because they are of the white collar variety.
- Joeboy 17y ago> if they are colluding to change the results of a study paid for with public monies What study? Are you referring to the fact that at some point they drew a graph that updated data extrapolated from tree ring data with actual data from thermometers, and that that graph may or may not have actually been published? How long a jail term does that merit? > destroy evidence requested by an official inquiry What official inquiry? They talked about deleting emails they considered private. How long in jail for that? > Criminal charges would send a strong, immediate signal to scientists in all areas of research On our backward little island we don't yet throw people in jail on the basis of their academic research. I'm sure we'll get there soon.
- Tichy 17y agoFrom the email: "The data are attached to this e-mail. They go from 1402 to 1995, although we usually stop the series in 1960 because of the recent non-temperature signal that is superimposed on the tree-ring data that we use. " So who of the discussing people is well versed enough in tree-ring data to have an informed opinion on this? It sounds as if in recent times tree-ring data has to be read differently (which seems possible, other factors could affect growth, don't know).
- pelle 17y agoDonald Keiller a plant physiologist at the University of Anglia wrote Briffa this October: "1) The appropriateness of the statistical analyses employed 2) The reliance on the same small datasets in these multiple studies 3) The concept of "teleconnection" by which certain trees respond to the "Global Temperature Field", rather than local climate 4) The assumption that tree ring width and density are related to temperature in a linear manner. Whilst I would not describe myself as an expert statistician, I do use inferential statistics routinely for both research and teaching and find difficulty in understanding the statistical rationale in these papers. As a plant physiologist I can say without hesitation that points 3 and 4 do not agree with the accepted science." See link for full email thread: http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=1064&filename=1256760240.txt http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=1064&file...
- waterlesscloud 17y agoThis is interesting too- "I really wish I could be more positive about the Kyrgyzstan material, but I swear I pulled every trick out of my sleeve trying to milk something out of that. It was pretty funny though - I told Malcolm what you said about my possibly being too Graybill-like in evaluating the response functions - he laughed and said that's what he thought at first also. The data's tempting but there's too much variation even within stands. I don't think it'd be productive to try and juggle the chronology statistics any more than I already have - they just are what they are (that does sound Graybillian). I think I'll have to look for an option where I can let this little story go as it is. Not having seen the sites I can only speculate, but I'd be optimistic if someone could get back there and spend more time collecting samples, particularly at the upper elevations. Yeah, I doubt I'll be over your way anytime soon. Too bad, I'd like to get together with you and Ed for a beer or two. Probably someday though. Cheers, Gary Gary Funkhouser Lab. of Tree-Ring Research The University of Arizona" http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=12&filename=843161829.txt http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=12&filena... There really does need to be a full and detailed explanation of all this, immediately.
- ewjordan 17y agoHere's my question, to anyone that knows: is the data set in question the only data set that the (alleged, I suppose) warming trend is observable in? Or is this merely a nitpick at one particular set of data, while other independent ones exist that were generated in different ways? I ask because in fight the over evolution, a lot of fuss has been made over a few very minor results that are seen as vulnerable in order to try to get people to ignore the big picture, which is clear as day (and doesn't depend at all on the individual results being picked at). While I realize not all AGW skeptics are anti-evolution, there's a big enough overlap to wonder if the same tactics or delusions might translate over...perhaps that's a cynical thought, but conservatives have earned no benefit of the doubt as regards scientific matters, so please forgive my prior bias in favor of the mainstream scientists - in every scientific field that I have personal experience in, the mainstream scientists these days are generally solid and honest, and certainly never fraudulent. If this is really the only data set that shows a warming trend, then that's a lot more worrisome.
- philipn 17y agoThis is not the only data set that the warming trend is observable in. [ In fact, some AGW skeptics don't deny a warming trend, but instead argue against human impact causing this warming trend (the A). ] Nevertheless, here is what Real Climate says regarding the "hide the decline" bit (in more detail than their original post): >>Declines” in the MXD record. This decline was hidden written up in Nature in 1998 (http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v391/n6668/abs/391678a0.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v391/n6668/abs/391678a0...) where the authors suggested not using the post 1960 data. Their actual programs (in IDL script), unsurprisingly warn against using post 1960 data. Added: Note that the ‘hide the decline’ comment was made in 1999 – 10 years ago, and has no connection whatsoever to more recent instrumental records. So, every climate record produced in recent years has no connection to this data. And there's lots of these. Your evolution analogy is apt. Many (very smart) people would like to pretend this simply isn't happening or isn't possible.
- psyklic 17y agoAs someone who has done some experimental work, I can appreciate how emails like this sound bad but may actually not be. With every set of data, there is a lot of additional information necessary for interpreting it. I'm sure that if someone is just given my raw data, for example, it is open to interpretation -- however, ALSO given the "metadata" (which is often in my lengthy, informal lab journal), the rationale behind my interpretation is more clear ... If I had to explain every little nuance to amateurs and explain why their interpretations are incorrect, I would certainly not have much time left in my day!
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoAnd therefore you would start deleting emails, ask others to delete emails, claim that original data has been lost when it has not in fact been lost, etc? What would you do if you have a hypothesis and you see that from a particular date onwards the data doesn't support your hypothesis? I think you would try to find out why that is. And if your work directly influences policy and taxes and living standards you might have to provide an explanation that "amateurs" can understand because "we the amateurs" are the same as "we the people" mentioned there: http://topics.law.cornell.edu/constitution/preamble http://topics.law.cornell.edu/constitution/preamble
- Tichy 17y agoI could see myself starting emails if somebody hacked my accounted and started publishing my private correspondence.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoObviously it's not desirable to have email accounts hacked. But what has emerged so far is work related correspondence of public employees working on publicly funded projects. And the content of those emails is about trying to hide data that is supposed to be subject to public scrutiny and peer review. Depending on what kind of organisation you work for, deleting that kind of "private correspondence" may constitute a crime. It has been suggested that some of the data these people were trying to hide was subject to a FOI request (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Information_Act_2000 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_Information_Act_2000). I don't know if that's actually the case, but if it is we may see prosecutions in the future.