4 ms·
It must be a really slow day on Hacker News - how has this got four upvotes? Really, seriously, can someone tell me why this is even the vaguest bit interestin
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
It must be a really slow day on Hacker News - how has this got four upvotes?
Really, seriously, can someone tell me why this is even the vaguest bit interesting or intellectually stimulating to them? I would honestly be interested in hearing an opinion other than mine.
- ars 17y agoBecause we use camel case in programming, and we are curious what non programmers think of it.
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoReally? Do you really care what non-programmers think of CamelCase? Why not ask them what they think of using braces, or indentation? Clearly people think my question detracts from the value of HN because they're downvoting it, but to me it's worth it to investigate a place where the opinion of the "community" differs so radically from mine. I have zero interest in finding out what people think of summation notation, or bra and ket notation, and, quite frankly, I find it inconceivable (and I do mean that, unlike Vizzini) that programmers would care what non-programmers think about CamelCase. Still, you're being up-voted, I'm being down-voted, so obviously people really are interested in that. I'm mystified, but I'll accept it as a data point. ADDED IN EDIT after reading the comment by benatkin to the above: I am genuinely surprised, confused and puzzled. I'll have to re-think my model of what the HN readers think satisfies PG's outline of "On-Topic": Anything that good hackers would find interesting ... gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. I'm going away to ponder the response, feeling somewhat bruised and punished by the "community" I thought I understood and felt at home in.
- benatkin 17y agoI'm interested because I want more than half of the people who are currently in high school to know a little bit about programming in ten years, and I wonder what might trip up some of them in an introductory programming course.
- duncanj 17y agoI imagine, "What's all this? Why not just write (dwim)?"
- 10ren 17y agoI don't find camel case interesting in itself, but the evolution and adoption of the technology of written language is intellectually stimulating to me. The article suggests that written language used to be read aloud - it was a recording of spoken language rather than directly interpretable in itself: monks had to read it aloud to understand it. A bit like an LP (remember Hofstadter's tortoise character who enjoyed LPs by looking at the groove patterns?) And then, it was found that the eye could recognise words directly, without needing to read aloud (or subvocalize), and that this technology became widely adopted over centuries. The article discusses europe - I wonder if it was a localized cultural change; whether the greeks and romans already had this technology or if they needed to "read aloud" (I believe they favoured memorizing epic poetry); and of course whether other areas (especially china) had a similar change at a similar time. There's a tantalizing possibility that it may have been accompanied by biological change, perhaps similar to the bizarre and fascinating concept of "The Bicameral Mind". Or perhaps my intellectually curiosity is reading too much into the article? If so, the article stimulated it. EDIT I was sure the guidelines used to say "intellectually stimulating", but you're right, it's "gratifies one's intellectual curiosity" http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html I found the article more intellectually provocative than gratifying, so maybe you're right. BTW: I've found my upvotes/downvotes on comments aren't working anymore (I need to refresh to see it). Is HN secretly experimenting with vote privileges (karma threshold over 2183? average over 2.68? membership over 304 days?). Is it a bug? Or have I somehow irritated someone powerful?
- raganwald 17y agofeeling somewhat bruised and punished Let go of that like you drop a filthy sock! Think of it this way: If you never disagree with what others put on the front page, how often are you going to be truly surprised? How often are you going to read something that you didn't know you liked until you clicked on it? I like to think that a certain number of articles I detest is a necessary complement to enjoying a certain number of "Wow, I'd never thought of that" moments on HN. I hope that perspective helps you shrug off the odd time you get downmobbed for calling out an article that doesn't "gratify your intellectual curiosity."
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoThank you for taking the time to reply, and I agree with the points you make. I do expect to be surprised occasionally by the articles that make the front page. I do expect there to be articles I hate, and continue to hate after reading them, and I do expect that there are articles for which I change my mind and learn something. What I didn't expect was for people to down-mod me heavily simply for expressing an opinion that was different to theirs. I thought people would ignore or reply. I have always regarded down-modding as reserved for things that don't belong here, and I thought legitimate questioning does belong here. Clearly I was wrong. The conclusion is that people down-mud me purely because they disagreed, and couldn't be bothered to articulate their reasons. That's why I'm disappointed, and feeling set upon. I had hoped and expected that people would value contributions, even if the opinions expressed differed from their own. I thought the article was a complete waste of time, said so, and honestly asked why people thought otherwise. For that I got hammered. I'm disappointed. It won't stop me from reading and contributing, but it has made me stop and reconsider some things. I'll certainly be less open and more wary.
- sounddust 17y agoI voted your post down because you were rude and condescending. Here's an another (more respectful) way in which you could have written your post: "I see that this story has a lot of upvotes, but it's not a story that I found particularly interesting. Could someone give me their perspective on why they liked this article?" You also did what is often done to a large number of articles posted to HN: You asked a variant of "why is this hacker news?!," the answer to which is always the same: "because X number of people found that it gratified their intellectual curiosity and voted it up." It gets old after a while, but I personally wouldn't object to someone repeatedly asking the question as long as they were respectful and truly interested in the response rather than asking it as a way to complain.
- DougBTX 17y agoIt is a light hearted article with a laugh of two, and I learnt that something I take for granted (spaces between words) was only just established by the 13th century. No wonder so many people were illiterate, their texts were illegible. (Ignoring the fact that those texts were probably quite hard to get a hold of in the first place...) It isn't canonical Hacker News, however. Everyone expects HN to trend towards Reddit, though, don't they?
- paulgb 17y ago> It is a light hearted article with a laugh of two I'm glad I'm not the only one who saw it that way. Is it just me, or does Hacker News take things too literally sometimes?
- SapphireSun 17y agoThere was some interesting stuff about why language used to not have spacing in it. The first few paragraphs were not really worth reading. Edit: Removed "in my opinion" because that's obvious :-P
- 10ren 17y agoAgreed, I started skipping paragraphs - just skimming the topic sentences - and then started reading it closely when it began interesting again.