18 ms·
Upvote begging (and knowingly using the /newest trick) is pretty unethical, although fortunately uncommon in HN. I'm working on a blog post about the problem o
by minimaxir 11y ago
Upvote begging (and knowingly using the /newest trick) is pretty unethical, although fortunately uncommon in HN.
I'm working on a blog post about the problem of upvote begging. Usually, it's in the minority of users, although some websites don't explicitly enforce it well. (Case in point, Product Hunt makes upvote begging part of the status quo, which compromises the integrity of the site as a whole.)
- cat9 11y agoIt's common because the likelihood of escaping /newest on the basis of "intellectually interesting" alone is miniscule. The traffic just doesn't work that way. Solve that, and you have much more traction to complain about what people should or shouldn't be doing.
- minimaxir 11y agoWhat? No it isn't. (See my submission history for URLs to minimaxir.com, and I have negligible influence in the tech world) Even then, two wrongs don't make a right. It comes down to luck, and sometimes it doesn't pan out. "Growth hacking" to correct bad luck is not necessarily ethical.
- pyre 11y agoOn the other hand, we can't act like the front page is a meritocracy either when there is a significant element of luck involved. Would be be "growth hacking" if I analyzed upvoting patterns to determine the "correct" time to make a submission to maximize the chance of hitting the front page? Don't I gain an advantage over someone that sees an interesting link and just immediately submits it to HN?
- ablation 11y agoI'd be interest to know if "upvote begging" actually works beyond a small amount of users who see the "beg" and know the person "begging". I'm not so sure the majority of people bother going on to a site to upvote something just because they were asked. People are extremely lazy.
- minimaxir 11y agoUnfortunately, that's impossible/infeasable to prove quantitatively without access to the raw data. In the HN case, however, I've seen a number of submissions which get 10+ points in a few minutes (which will get you on the front page quickly), but the submission was on the second or third page. A quick Twitter search shows they were asking for upvotes. People are lazy, yes, but when there's monetary/reputation values tied to placement, the incentives change.
- zem 11y agowhat /newest trick? do upvotes count for more if they're made from the new page rather than the front page? (and if so, does it track state when you click through to the comment page first, then open the article in a new tab, read it, and then upvote from the comment page?)
- minimaxir 11y agoThe inverse: upvotes are penalized if the voter comes from a direct link from a non-HN source (e.g. Twitter), so people direct others to vote via /newest.
- thedufer 11y agoInteresting. How smart are they about this? My HN flow involves always voting from the comments page, even though I got there from the front page or /newest. Does that mean I'm triggering the penalty?
- minimaxir 11y agoEdited parent post for clarity. Anecdotally, new accounts are penalized too even if they vote from /newest (to prevent blatant vote manipulation via sock puppets)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- talmand 11y agoSo, I see a submission I think is interesting and direct link it from my Twitter account; the submission is penalized on every upvote it receives through my link? That just seems like a silly thing to do. Especially since there's an obvious way around it.
- wodenokoto 11y agoWouldn't you in that case link directly to the article and not the comments section?
- ams6110 11y agoWhile vote begging has been around since the first site that supported comment voting, the "Like this on Facebook" thumb-up icon really entreched this in people's minds as a common and accepted thing to do.